2 ms·
This is one of the worst articles I've ever read about adtech and is clearly written by someone who has never worked in it and knows nothing about it. It's all
by manigandham 11y ago
This is one of the worst articles I've ever read about adtech and is clearly written by someone who has never worked in it and knows nothing about it.
It's all summed up by this at the end of the article:
> Q: It’s all baseless speculation.
> We base our research on subjects that are gaining traction in the overall news flow. We have found 94 articles about "ad fraud" over the last 5 years, only looking at influential, qualified sources (http://11wall.st/?to=2016-05-04&from=2011-05-04&query=%22ad+fraud%22&group=all&nz=0&k=%22ad+fraud%22%3B&p=y5 http://11wall.st/?to=2016-05-04&from=2011-05-04&query=%22ad+...). So, no, we’ve not dreamt this up, this is something real that the media is talking about. This is the whole point: as coverage of online advertising’s shortcomings grows, people will start to grow aware of it, and will start to question the system.
The "news" coverage is similar to this article in that it's about 20% accurate and 80% sensationalist stories. Also 94 articles is like a week of normal trade press output so it's not even a big number over 5 years.
Advertising and marketing technology is one of the most data-driven and results-oriented industries around. That's just fact. It's been like that for decades. The reason there are hundreds of billions being spent is because there's so much control, flexibility, efficiency, scale and accountability available today that can drive sales and massively improve a company's revenues.
Adtech today is bigger and better than ever because even when things change (like mediums, platforms, audiences, technology), the industry always adapts just fine.
Anyone thinking advertising doesn't work should look at how exactly the successes of the favored Silicon Valley companies have come to be, because outside of making a decent product, it's all marketing. In fact, two of the biggest companies in the world today have been built around advertising and it's clear it's going to stay because it's an integral part of the economy.
- kafkaesq 11y agoAnyone thinking advertising doesn't work should ... But that's not at all what he's saying -- he's saying the market for it saturated, and its efficiency has crested. It's clear it's going to stay because it's an integral part of the economy. Nor is he saying that it's "going away." Or anything remotely close to that.
- manigandham 11y agoThat last paragraph are my comments on the general tone of the post and this HN thread. That's why it starts with "anyone". Regarding the article though: > online advertising efficiency has been decreasing for years > Alphabet/Google, who has 90% of its revenue coming from online advertising, will see its business scale back to the levels of 2010-2011, while its share price will crash to the $200-$250 area > Awareness for fraud and the inefficiency of online ads grows past the point of no return over the next 2 years. The whole sector crashes as clients reduce spending and demand better reporting and transparency. This is all very poor conjecture derived from reading a few dozen "news" articles. None of this is or will be true based on the facts and progress of the industry today.