4 ms·
We had 25%+ unemployment during the Great Depression, at a time when hardly any women were in the workforce. I would say that was a much more difficult time th
by chrisco255 11y ago
We had 25%+ unemployment during the Great Depression, at a time when hardly any women were in the workforce. I would say that was a much more difficult time than this great stagnation we find ourselves in currently. Our economy is now largely service-based, but we are still quite a ways off from automating most services. There's a lot of speculation that the economy will imminently suffer rapid upheaval with few jobs to replace the ones that are automated, but it remains speculative.
- ThomPete 11y agoWhat you and others get wrong in that analysis is that you don't take into account that just one algorithm have to learn something then all the others can do the same. Point machine learning towards a problem and things that normally was cumbersome and took several people to do is suddenly done in the fraction of a second. It's like claiming that if an alien race landed on planet earth with superior skills and superior technology it wouldn't effect the human ability to survive because we endured battles with other species before. We can't use history to teach us much since the opponent is different. This is not speculation anymore. This is unfolding right in front of us and we better take it serious.
- chrisco255 11y agoMachine learning is still far from automating most services. If anything, machine learning will create as many jobs as it will destroy.
- ThomPete 11y agoYou must be able to provide some examples of jobs that will be created. So when machine learning will remove the need for radiologist and many surgeons as it's already well underway to. What areas is it that these doctors will then be able to work in thats going to be of value? It's ironic how steadfast many of you are in this idea that more jobs will be created when there is no evidence it's the case and the new jobs that are created require much less than whatever it replaced. You are also confusing globalization with actual job creation in the west.
- stormbrew 11y agoIt should probably be noted that unemployment rates then are not necessarily comparable to unemployment rates now. They were collected differently and less perfectly, as the entire concept was quite new as of the 30s afaik.
- beat 11y ago"Automated" jobs language reminds me of the old saw that "Technology is stuff that didn't exist when I was a kid". Entire industries worth of jobs have been "automated" away over the past couple of centuries. Say, 150 years ago, you needed to move a ton of rock a hundred yards. How was it done? By hand. You needed to harvest an entire field of grain. How was it done? By hand. A couple of centuries ago, virtually everyone was employed in farming. Now, hardly anyone is. Powered vehicles and hydraulic lifting wiped out more jobs than computers ever have.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> We had 25%+ unemployment during the Great Depression, at a time when hardly any women were in the workforce. I would say that was a much more difficult time than this great stagnation we find ourselves in currently. Certainly the Great Depression was more of an acute problem that the current ones; the current ones are more persistent. We're forty years past the peak in real (inflation-adjusted) hourly wages. > Our economy is now largely service-based, but we are still quite a ways off from automating most services. Arguably, that should be a "because" rather than a "but". > There's a lot of speculation that the economy will imminently suffer rapid upheaval with few jobs to replace the ones that are automated, but it remains speculative. The idea that there will be a rapid cliff in the number of jobs is mistaken, sure. What there is -- and not merely imminently in the future, we are well into it -- is an end to the returns to labor increasing alongside economic output. There's still output growth, but the returns are captured by capital. Automation is a key reason for that.