7 ms·
Every time someone in the medical field tells me about how dangerous motorcycles are, I remind them of the woman I knew (world-class rider in some aspects of th
by mikestew 11y ago
Every time someone in the medical field tells me about how dangerous motorcycles are, I remind them of the woman I knew (world-class rider in some aspects of the sport) who was in a motorcycle crash. The crash didn't kill her, the people giving her the wrong drugs did.
Years later I read _The Checklist Manifesto_, only to be horrified that not only did medical personnel need to be told to use checklists, many resisted the idea. It's one thing to kill people because of a mistake, we all make them and thankfully the ones I make usually don't get anyone hurt. But it's quite another to kill someone because your industry is one step ahead of using leeches. I mean, suppose I make a commit that rolls into production and takes out production data. Someone asks, "did you follow the checklist?" If I say, "yes", it's unlikely that heads will roll and we'll update the list when we find out what went wrong. But if my answer is, "no. In fact, I don't even have a checklist/documented procedure, I just make sure my commit message is informative and hope I remembered everything", I'm likely to get fired. A doctor does it, shrugs it off with "we did everything we could", and a lot of time we all just go on about our day.
- smileysteve 11y ago> But if my answer is, "no. In fact, I don't even have a checklist/documented procedure, I just make sure my commit message is informative and hope I remembered everything", I'm likely to get fired. Or even, the nurse has a checklist, but I don't need checklists, I'm a professional.
- sopooneo 11y agoI can not think of a single good reason to avoid check-lists in the medical field. And the doctors who resist them may very well just be arrogant and elitist. But there may also be some other reason. I don't know because I'm not a doctor, but I do know there are always things I don't know to consider in unfamiliar fields. Do we have any doctors on the board who could explain a defensible resistance on the part of doctors to using checklists?
- 794CD01 11y agoNot a doctor, but familiar with some of the arguments. Visible use of checklists damages patient trust. You may (correctly) argue that patients who see their doctors following checklists should trust them MORE rather than less, but most data shows otherwise. Patient trust is very important not just for improving outcomes (they need to follow your instructions after discharge) but also in selecting a physician. That's why checklist use is higher in the OR, when the patient is unconscious. Checklist use is slower. Virtually all physicians are already overscheduled. Lengthening every visit by 30-50% so that the doctor can go over a checklist that only ends up mattering a tiny percentage of the time means fewer patients get seen.
- petra 11y agoThe problem of patients not trusting doctors who use checklists seems solvable , maybe via education maybe via other means. It's just a matter of will.
- 794CD01 11y agoI hope so too. However, it is currently a problem.
- danielrhodes 11y agoThat explanation is so backwards in reasoning it would be humerous if it weren't so pathetic. Sadly you see people citing data over common sense all the time. In this case, the choice between human life and hospital efficiency and "trust" produces a false trade-off: The dire consequences of one choice all but force you to take the other option.
- 794CD01 11y agoTrusting "common sense" over data is irresponsible if not outright delusional.
- danielrhodes 11y agoIs that always true?
- leonth 11y agoI am not a doctor, but I do have several practical defenses (I don't want to go through political ones). There are many business processes in the healthcare field, and the impact and ease of imposing checklists will be naturally very different for each: * Diagnosis and treatment protocols / pathways - these span long periods of time (days to months), any checklist will probably be quite complex and redundant to the already existing longitudinal case notes. * Procedures (like surgeries) - some parts like preparation can be subject to checklist. But the procedure itself may need >= 2 clean hands and good concentration, thus glancing over checklists multiple times during procedure, or worse attempting to tick off stuff might cause more harm than good. (don't tell me to add one more guy there - we need him to save another patient, and google glass is dead for now) * Processes related to ordering, dispensing, and administering medicines: there are probably tens/hundreds of thousands of these processes happening in a hospital at any given day. If a checklist introduces speed penalty it will be rather burdensome for the facility (and patients too). Furthermore, an equivalent of a checklist (e.g. refusing to proceed unless certain required fields are filled) has usually been codified in the hospital systems being used. Also, I feel that adding a checklist for something that you do hundreds of times a day, will not achieve anything, because the muscle memory will take over - you will just do things as per usual and sign off "all done" on the checklist, because you always do them all the time whether you remember or not, right?
- flarg 11y agoHandling of medicines has check-lists; surgery is moving that way too. Diagnosis is complex but also amenable to check-lists.
- ams6110 11y agoSurgical nurses can handle the checklists. Of course the surgeon himself will not be ticking boxes. Analogous: in a multi-crew aircraft, one pilot is flying, the other is managing/monitoring (including the checklists).
- petra 11y ago>>>Diagnosis and treatment protocols / pathways Even with what you say, clinical decision support(which can be viewed as an automated system of double checking) have shown to lead to better care.
- IndianAstronaut 11y agoIt is likely the same reasoning behind why doctors for ages refused to wash their hands...arrogance.