3 ms·
This won't be a very popular position, especially here, considering the high population of tech people and those who might be running servers this might affect,
by stcredzero 11y ago
This won't be a very popular position, especially here, considering the high population of tech people and those who might be running servers this might affect, but I think it's important for people to realize that the simplistic "DRM is Evil" position is misguided.
Imagine an alternate universe where government and huge corporations started using data encryption on its records in the 80's, as a way of defeating the FOIA and other demands for transparency. There is a public hue and cry, and with righteous indignation, people start thinking of "encryption as evil." To help prevent the repeat of such high profile abuses by large organizations, people work to ban data encryption.
That's not how history played out, however. In real life in the 90's, due to the PC revolution, ordinary people outside of academia started to become aware of the potential benefits of encryption over computer networks. There is a fundamental asymmetry of power between large institutions and individuals. What is a public good in the hands of the public can be horrible when it allows organizations to exercise dangerous degrees of centralized control. So it is with DRM. DRM restricting access by individuals to the software we fairly bought and to our shared cultural experiences is horrible. However, DRM protecting individual data against the depredations of companies and other institutions would be a tremendous pubic good.
Imagine a world where companies could no longer say about your personal data, "It got out somehow. Who knows? There's nothing anyone can do about that sort of thing. Privacy is dead." DRM won't be foolproof. Nothing like that can be. (Which is precisely why it's unsuitable for centralized control, in a particular way that it causes lobbying money to request stupid legislation.) However, it will greatly increase the cost and legal risk of companies doing bad things with our personal data. The same asymmetry that makes DRM horrible makes it absolutely wonderful when you reverse it by 180 degrees! That asymmetry is this: Any given company, no matter how large, can't ever match the level of knowledge and man-hours that can be mustered by the internet at large. This precise economic asymmetry that makes DRM an unworkable idea that incentivizes oppression also makes DRM the perfect tool for helping the public to keep large organizations in line. One whistle-blower, one hacker's discovery, and that errant company can be prosecuted under the DMCA. (1)
Why aren't we requiring companies that handle vast amounts of private data to use DRM -- Digital Rights Management -- to protect the rights of individual human beings? After all, the rights of individual Homo sapiens should be the priority.
(1) -- Occasionally, some people will have their information breached, and their information could be disseminated beyond control. However, the bulk of the populace would still be protected.
- icebraining 11y agoThe term DRM refers specifically to the technologies built to restrict usage of proprietary hardware and copyrighted works. Access control to data (even enforced by encryption) already existed, and it's pernicious to whitewash DRM by expanding its definition.
- stcredzero 11y agoThis is the typical incorrect common-knowledge story. If you look at the papers from which DRM came, it's obvious that it wasn't solely aimed at copyright and didn't require proprietary hardware. The term is general, as are the concepts behind it. It's not that I'm expanding the definition. It's that an uninformed public has narrowed it, much as happened with "meme."
- icebraining 11y agoCan you please provide a reference of these papers? I've made some searches before posting previously and everything I found (search for writings from the 90s) corroborated my understanding of its origins.