18 ms·
78% of Reddit Threads with 1,000+ Comments Mention Nazis
- wahsd 11y agoIt's kind of the de facto escape hatch for some and a baseline analogy many can comprehend because of decade long conditioning. It does not surprise me one bit. What's always rather surprised me though is that no one seems to have realized that the decades of collective shaming of Germans for having gone through the national socialist dictatorship and war, has led to a deeply lost and self-loathing society without pride, dignity, or healthy identity. The society is in rather advanced stages self-destruction and decomstruction. The question is really only whether German culture and society will at all survive it's suicidal tendencies.
- WaxProlix 11y agoPerhaps if there were some sort of party that could rise to prominence on a platform of making Germany great again?
- mwfunk 11y agoEven more effective if the supposed reasons for non-greatness are one or more groups of faceless Others, within and without the country. Someone could go far in politics this way, with convenient scapegoats they could promise to drive out of the country, and perhaps even build a wall for keeping them out. Not that that would ever happen nowadays, what with millennia of history to learn from...
- clock_tower 11y agoI think that, in a way, the developing immigrant crisis (look at the problems at Cologne on New Year's) is going to be a good thing for Germany, forcing them to determine what parts of their heritage are worth standing up for after all. The Greek crisis was also an example of Germany standing up for themselves; I think that, if you ask the Germans, they've made as much restitution for the Nazi period as it's meaningful to make (look up the details, they're pretty formidable), and at this point improvident foreigners looking for handouts and talking about Hitler are just engaged in bullying. In the long run, I expect Germany to survive, but I'm not making the same bet on the US. I'm planning on moving from the US to Ireland at some point; I don't really want to be here, or to make my children be here, for the chaos almost certain to ensue 40-50 years from now. (Or 10-20 years from now, if we end up with President The Donald and he keeps his campaign promises.)
- rm_-rf_slash 11y ago>I'm not making the same bet on the US As The Economist put it, America has "friends to the north and south and fish to the east and west." If anything truly threatens the US, it is ourselves. The idea that anyone could sustain supply lines to invade the States is out of their mind or has fallen asleep too many times to reruns of Red Dawn.
- clock_tower 11y agoI don't watch trash. It's precisely ourselves that any threat will come from; I expect that the current environment of political upheaval will only get worse.
- selimthegrim 11y agoWhat exactly is wrong with the current passel of immigrants to the States?
- clock_tower 11y agoIt's not the immigrants that I'm afraid of; it's the locals. The Scotch-Irish are being shunted aside by the march of history; their cultural values, especially their economic improvidence, keep them from getting into the mainstream (read _Albion's Seed_); and they're not going to go gently into that good night. As Christian belief declines in the Scotch-Irish parts of the US, Nazi belief grows. (I have personally seen an aspiring pastor with a tattoo on his arm incorporating both the cross and the swastika, who saw no contradiction between the two.) Things are going to come to a head -- either in fierce government repression, or in uprisings or civil war -- and I don't want to be collateral damage when they do.
- stcredzero 11y agoThere were plans drawn up by the UK for conducting warfare in N. America, with the specific aim of countering a US invasion of Canada, the purpose of which would be to deny the port of Halifax to the Royal Navy. During this time, Canada drew up contingency plans for invading the US and fighting off an invasion. Britain hoped that the Canadians would be able to defend Halifax, but had no plans to bail out Canada in this circumstance. The US drafted a plan for the invasion of Canada, while the UK drafted a plan to defeat the US Navy at sea. I think there's a Nova episode about all this.
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoSadly I think you're right. A reflexive anti-national shame is probably the cause of the myopic dream of multiculturalism, where culture and ethnicity and very old instincts about judging people who look different from you don't matter anymore, now and forever. It's almost as if some Germans are so ashamed of their national past that they would rather see nationalism eliminated entirely than to accept the messy world as it is. Ironically, I am now realizing how much of a burden that ideology is being forced on much of Europe, not necessarily the same way that the Nazis conquered Europe, but in the same insistence that they are ultimately right.
- eridius 11y agoInteresting, but I'm a bit disappointed the author didn't at least try to filter out things like "grammar nazi" or, as might be found in r/seinfeld, "soup nazi".
- comboy 11y agoYeah, or "I did nazi that coming", the bigger the thread the more memes are in it.
- samcheng 11y agoRight; I'd guess that at least half of the 'nazi' mentions are actually lame puns.
- dTal 11y agoCtrl-F "nazi that"... yep. I don't think we can draw any conclusions from this beyond the fact that the Reddit hive mind thinks Godwin's law is hilarious and mentions Hitler at every opportunity.
- gkya 11y ago> In this post, I’ll only try to find out how many Reddit comments mention Nazis or Hitler and ignore the context in which they are made.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- hristov 11y agoI suppose that reddit threads with 1000+ comments will mention a lot of things. Seeing how they have so many comments and so much text and all.
- diyorgasms 11y agoIt's interesting that the highest non-history subreddit is /r/european, which is a neo-nazi forum. Cool dataset at least.
- spriggan3 11y agoit's also interesting that r/socialism , r/anarchism , r/gamerghazi which are respectively socialist , anarchist and anti-gamergate forums are on the top of the list.
- diyorgasms 11y agoWell, from my experience hanging around in leftist subreddits, I can say there's an awful lot of loud and repeated objection to the Reddit admins harboring neo-nazi fora such as the aforementioned /r/european. Whether the admins allowing that speech is virtuous or villainous is a different debate, but the leftist subs routinely criticize Reddit the company for harboring actual Nazis.
- cb18 11y ago>/r/european, which is a neo-nazi forum That's not an accurate characterization. There is an element of that, but it is frequently pushed back against. It's mostly people who are dismayed by this recent migrant madness and the resultant massive spike in horrible crimes. It is ostensibly also just a place for discussion of european culture but attention to the migrant madness, and seeking political solutions for it dominates the conversation because the issue is so heavily censored elsewhere on reddit. edit: And it's highly likely that the vast majority of occurences of the string 'nazi' in that sub are in the context of satirical postings like, Oh, you think borders should be secure and rapists should be prosecuted? You must be a nazi!
- cr1895 11y agoAlright, sure, to be more precise it is both neo-nazi and white supremacist. I thought I'd have to look at least a little bit harder than literally the first link I clicked, but: https://www.reddit.com/r/european/comments/4htthg/til_muslim_population_in_france_is_growing_two/ https://www.reddit.com/r/european/comments/4htthg/til_muslim... Some choice comments include "sieg heil, NSB (Dutch fascists) was not wrong," comments about "negroid France," calls to poison halal food, issues they find with the survival of the white race due to the "blacks" and Muslims. It is not a place for discussion of European culture. It is a vile cesspool of racists and hate.
- Negative1 11y agoSo is his extrapolation that at 4k+ it will reach towards 100%?
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoNazi is an easy shorthand for evil. You don't need to show a Nazi kicking a puppy to say the Nazi is evil, because they're already a Nazi! We get it. The downside of this shorthand is that it dumbs down conversation. The Nazi-accuser shunts the Nazi-accused into a digestible category that needn't be historically comparable at all to be rhetorically effective, and the accused has less incentive to cordially communicate when it is clear that they are not being taken seriously, so either reasonable people leave or inflammatory folks troll, and we're all worse off.
- tstactplsignore 11y agoAt the same time, not all Nazi analogies are equally wrong- it's fallacious to claim that moustaches are evil because Nazis had them; it isn't exactly fallacious to claim that persecuting and demonizing a minority combined with enthusiastic nationalism through slowly increasing propaganda campaigns under the leadership of a charismatic leader should seem at least slightly worrying because we have Nazis as a historical example. The Nazis and the 30s and 40s can present real historical lessons- another is that in the 30s, the German Communist party declared "After him, us!" in response to Hitler's rise and their refusal to cooperate with the socialists, with the reasoning being that his disastrous short term would hasten about a communist revolution. Unfortunately, we often see the exact same argument used by both socialists and some of the more extreme Bernie Sanders fans today with regards to Trump. There are historical lessons and analogies in the past which can be genuinely useful to understanding the present. At this rate, it feels like if 1930s Germany had Godwin's law, it would have been used to quash any dissent about the actual rise of Nazism.
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoYou're right. Too right. The Nazis are a rightfully perfect metaphor for these times and many others. But there are always exceptions. Nobody is wheelbarrowing carts of Deutschmarks to buy a loaf of bread. Race (and the idea of inherent superiority/inferiority) is viewed much differently, in fact until the 70s it was generally accepted that Neanderthals became whites, Homo Erectus became Asians, and so on. And if the post-Cold War era has taught us anything, there is no "End of History" where humanity converges along the One True Path. No analogy is perfect. American slaves had little relation to Roman slaves aside from being owned people. Too much has changed since the 30s to be an exact repeat.
- raldi 11y agoThat stat is hard to interpret in a vacuum. What percent of such threads contain a comment that mentions potatoes, or bismuth, or juggling?
- tyingq 11y agoOr cats.
- christianmann 11y agoOr nazi cats.
- jsmthrowaway 11y agoDid you guys run any sort of analysis like this, on comment content in aggregate, during your tenure? I would guess with all of that data it'd be fun for hackathons to come up with interesting conversation starters like this one, despite the flaw you point out. Glad folks are putting together these datasets now, too, if informally.
- raldi 11y agoNo; we were usually too busy just keeping the site up and trying to generate revenue.... though actually, there were occasional times where we said "fuck that" and took a break to work on something fun, like an April Fools stunt. If anyone did such an analysis, it would have been ketralnis.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- hamhamed 11y agoMaybe try it on HN threads, don't think Godwin's Law would be as effective
- stepvhen 11y agoHN threads don't go above 1000 nearly as often as Reddit, without any regard to the differences in audience, or the size of the audience, or the scale of the content availavle to comment on.
- minimaxir 11y agoUnlike Reddit, invoking Godwin's Law in Hacker News will get your comment killed.
- mynewtb 11y agoYes, the moderation is literally Hitler here.
- blazespin 11y agoSo .001 * .78 or, .00078 of comments mention nazis.
- tyenl 11y agoI think the thread is counted if there is at least 1 mention of nazis in the thread. Therefore it is possible that there are multiple mentions per counted thread meaning that at least .00078 comments mention nazis, but in all likelihood far more comments mention nazis. Edit: after reading the article, I don't think that this observation stands.
- minimaxir 11y agoTechnically not correct. The OP only looks at threads w/ 1000+ comments. The vast majority of threads on Reddit have less than that. (see: http://jeroendelcour.nl/blog/Reddits-attention-inequality http://jeroendelcour.nl/blog/Reddits-attention-inequality )
- nxzero 11y agoUse of the term should just throw a flag and information the user that users able allowed to filter comments based on keyword and if there comment will not be viewable to XX% of the community. Second, mods should still be reviewing the community for inappropriate behavior. While I'd never use the term, it's a good reminder that what words you choose often define you.
- pessimizer 11y agoIt's important to remember that civilized intellectual Westerners relatively recently democratically elected leaders who shovelled intellectual, sexual, and racial minorities into mass graves based on magical theories.
- mg1982 11y agoTrue. But not important - or salient - 78% of the time on popular Reddit threads, right?
- tn13 11y agoI am not surprised and I don't find it alarming. More comments means more fights and words like "Nazi" are bound to appear because it is basically a slang for evil. Forget reddit, a quick look at American politics itself shows very liberal use of phrases like Fascist and Nazi when in reality people probably mean just evil.
- anonymous_iam 11y agoThus Goodwin's Law has been proven to be true once again.
- brotoss 11y agoI did Nazi see that coming!
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- compactmani 11y agoAllow me to make a more general conjecture: As an online discussion grows longer, the probability of a comparison involving word_x or word_y approaches 1.
- christiangenco 11y agoMy thoughts exactly. I won't put any credence in this information until I see a graph comparing the relative frequency of "nazi" as discussions grow with "Justin Bieber", "anosmia", and "Kevin Bacon".
- kazinator 11y agoWhy? The definition isn't relative to these in any way. It doesn't say that Nazi mentions are more frequent than Bieber mentions. Just that it's more likely to occur in longer threads relative to shorter threads.
- mikeash 11y agoThat's an obvious and boring conclusion, though. It's barely beyond saying that if you roll dice, sequences with more rolls tend to have more sixes.
- kazinator 11y agoYes; unfortunately, Godwin did not commit to any numbers, like "the thread length required for a 79% probability is 500 responses".
- cableshaft 11y agoSomewhere the people in a subreddit are kicking themselves for not doing their jobs well enough to bring that up to 98%.
- kazinator 11y agoTo validate Godwin's Law, you have to apply it properly. What Godwin's Law refers to is this: either an ad hominem attack occurs in which some debating parties compares their opponent(s) to Nazi's, or else some other sort of non-constructive, inappropriate comparison is made between some subject and the Nazis. ("Those crazy GNU Nazis don't want anyone to get paid for programming." "I'm gonna ignore you topic Nazis and write about whatever I want.") Simply mentioning Hitler or the Nazi party is not enough; there are valid, constructive ways to do that. For instance, a legitimate thread about WWII history will probably mention Hitler or the Nazis! Also, comparing any violently repressive regime to the Nazis is completely valid.
- stepanhruda 11y agoDid you read the article? > Then I excluded history subreddits
- kazinator 11y agoHow can you be sure that an ad hominem attack or other inappropriate invocation of the Nazis doesn't take place in a history subreddit that is also chock full of legitimate references?
- stepanhruda 11y agoGodwin's law doesn't talk about only ad hominem attacks though. It talks about comparing someone/something to nazis, most often it'll be related to the content the comments are on. Most of the content outside r/history is unlikely to be originally related to WWII. I would count a random mention of nazis under a trump article as Godwin's law. Although, knowing reddit most of the comments are probably along the lines of "I did nazi that coming". Source: I spend a lot of time on reddit
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- S_A_P 11y agoSo I know that reddit has always been a bit more crass than your average community, and this could totally be me. But the last time I pulled up reddit to waste some time, I seemed to notice that more pseudo porn, wtf and generally nsfw stuff was on the front page. I personally don't care that is the case per se, but its utility as something to introduce me to something new/interesting seems to be vastly reduced. Maybe I should just yell get off of my lawn and move on.
- askyourmother 11y agoI think a thread being godwin'd on reddit, is like any programming thread on HN getting dragged down into "but, you should use Rust." Annoying, very annoying, and a hard problem to solve.
- AimHere 11y agoIt's solved by the OP of every programming thread using Rust of course!
- vlunkr 11y agoThis was how it was the first time I visited reddit, they have since changed the default sub-reddits to much less NSFW stuff.
- sudojudo 11y agoReddit has suffered from Eternal September for quite some time. There's a really good article on this subject that I can't seem to locate. But, if you put Reddit into the Wayback Machine, you'll see the frontpage transform over time, from something like Slashdot in 2009, to a meme image board in 2012, to a cleaned-up, marketing-friendly, image board in 2014, to the Facebook-feed-like mess that you see today. When I first joined, the default frontpage was fine. But after time, I had to edit out default subreddits from the main feed. The final straw, in around 2013, was not being able to escape trolls and punsters, anywhere on the site. These days, if I browse Reddit, I restrict myself to heavily moderated subs, like /r/askhistorians and /r/askscience, and subs with less than a thousand subscribers. Anywhere else on the site is like visiting the Facebook page of a 14-year-old Nazi womanizer with a Trump infatuation. AOL and Windows 95 ruined everything!
- Patient0 11y agoI bet you could find other words than "Nazis" for which this is also true...
- astazangasta 11y agoHey, maybe it's just worthwhile talking about Nazis? World War II was one of the most catastrophic failures in the history of the world, and the rise of Nazism was an enormous subcategory of failure. These events defined the shape of the century; they demonstrated the horrific extremes to which humanity can descend, and they're absolutely worth appreciating so that we can forestall their reappearance again. Moreover, it's not like the Nazis just went away; they continued to exist, and the ideologies that produced them not only still exist but are once again becoming a powerful political force. So fuck yeah, everyone, talk about Nazis. It's one of the most important things you can talk about. (But read Hannah Arendt first.)
- ninjakeyboard 11y agoper a random selection of 1000 comments, how how likely is it that a comment will contain mention of nazis?
- Someone 11y agoSo, is that a lot? Let’s assume a very simple model, with Reddit writers picking words from a fixed distribution, 10 words per reply, and all ‘over 1,000 comments’ threads having exactly 1000 comments. Then, if the probability of picking ‘fried rice’ is p, the probability of ‘fried rice’ not appearing in that 1,000 comment, 10,000 word thread is (1-p)^10000 That apparently, is around 0.22: (1-p)^10000 = 0.22 Solving for p gives us 10000 log(1-p) = log(.22) log(1-p) = log(.22)/10000 1-p = exp(log(.22)/10000) p = 1 - exp(log(.22)/10000) That’s about 0.000066, or 1 in 15,000. Let’s compare that with https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=nazi&year_start=1800&year_end=2000&corpus=5 https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=nazi&year_star.... That gives us numbers close to 0.000066, but only for the mid 1940’s. Current level is around 0.000008 or 1 in 125,000. Let’s compute how many words such a long Reddit thread needs to get at that level: (1-0.000008)^w = 0.22 w log(1-0.000008) = log(0.22) w = log(0.22)/log(1-0.000008) That gives me around 190.000 words. That does not seem impossible for me. If long threads on average have 2,500 comments, it is only 36 words per comment. One would have to look at the distribution of thread length and #words/comment to say more about this. Now, let’s hope there isn’t an embarrassing error in the above computations :-)
- webkike 11y agoWhere did you get that the probability of a thousand word comment not containing the fried rice is 0.22?
- 0xffff2 11y ago"Fried rice" is a standin for nazis/Hitler, so 1-0.78=0.22.
- minimaxir 11y agoBernoulli trials assume events are independent. That is likely not a good assumption in this case.
- Bartweiss 11y agoIt seems like a terrible assumption for this case. Godwin's Law is largely a specific case of conversational drift (unless you start out talking about Nazis). Everyone starts out on topic, then gets more hyperbolic and distracted until you end up at some other idea, in this case Nazis. So not only are comments in threads not independent samples, we're specifically looking at a proposition about non-independence.
- GCA10 11y agoI'm amazed that a full 22% of ultra-sustained Reddit threads are completely free of Nazi references. That's a beautiful display of self-restraint by a big crowd in an ugly world. I would have pegged the odds of sustained Nazi-free discourse on Reddit as comparable to -- say -- the odds of finding 1,000 Medium posts without the word "f*ck" or its variants in any of the headlines.
- djscram 11y agoSeems likely that most 1,000+ comment threads are political.
- minimaxir 11y agoIncorrect. Most 1,000 comment threads are in the default subreddits. Using BigQuery to group the number of threads by subreddit: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1_bL0dVn3z2R-pUkWuWNr7rnVe5SVXHfm3U6ZczV3u5U/edit?usp=sharing https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1_bL0dVn3z2R-pUkWuWNr... SELECT subreddit, SUM(num_comments >= 1000) as num_comments_gte1000 FROM [fh-bigquery:reddit_posts.full_corpus_201512] GROUP BY subreddit ORDER BY num_comments_gte1000 DESC LIMIT 1000
- djscram 11y agoSeems likely that most 1,000+ comment threads are political.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 11y agoNovelty account names tend to have references, just saw one the other day where not only did a commenter have the username of "Hitlerly Litler" or something to that effect, but someone pointed it out with the /u/username syntax because they thought it was funny. If they're doing naive string searches, does every thread that guy shows up in get counted? What about robot_hitler, MeinFurher, and all the others? Did anyone control for the topic very well? Many of the current news stories deal with fascism, or things people might worry to be fascism or totalitarianism or genocide.
- beat 11y ago40% of Reddit threads with 1000+ comments involve photos of kittens, including all 22% that don't mention Nazis. That means 18% of Reddit threads involve both kittens and Nazis.
- minimaxir 11y agoYour snark with made-up numbers assumes that p(kitten) and p(nazi) are independent. Which they aren't.
- mikestew 11y ago⌘-F "Godwin" shows me seven usages in this thread. I was looking for something like "see, Godwin was right". One commenter seems to have gotten it right. The rest think it's something one "invokes" (to quote one usage). Godwin's law is like the law of gravity: it always existed (in Godwin's case, post-WWII, obviously), whether you "used" it or not. You drop an apple, it'll hit the ground. An online discussion (or probably any discussion) grows longer, someone's going to make a Nazi comparison, which this article seems to confirm.
- hellofunk 11y agoI'm sure there are other common words in most/all of those threads that wouldn't surprise us.
- loblollyboy 11y agoand only 65% of hn threads
- Bartweiss 11y agoI'd like to propose Godwin's Number: the number of responses needed to produce a 50% chance of a reference to Nazis.
- timdellinger 11y agoI like it! It can be thought of as an LD50.
- linux_girl 11y agoI certainly did Nazi this coming.
- coldtea 11y agoSo? It's like mentioning good or evil. "Nazi" is just a stand-in for "the worst evil" (or sometimes just for plain evil). It's also a major historical and political even of the 20th century, with tons of analogies and lessons to draw from. I always found Goodwin's law (and especially the corollary, since the law is just a funny observation) BS.
- jamesblonde 11y agoIs the code available for this in github? The dataset is 370 GB, i think. What did the author use - postgres/Spark/other?
- skeletonjelly 11y agoBigQuery, it's mentioned in the linked article. http://bigquery.cloud.google.com/table/fh-bigquery:reddit_comments.2015_05 http://bigquery.cloud.google.com/table/fh-bigquery:reddit_co... Probably this dataset which is updated periodically
- blater 11y agoFirst rule of the Internet : all comment threads tend towards comparison to hitler. Multiply by 20 for YouTube.
- JBReefer 11y agoThat's called Godwin's Law
- qwertyuiop924 11y agoWas anybody surprised by this?
- orionblastar 11y agoYeah a thread will eventually have someone comparing someone else to Hitler or Nazis. It is Godwin's Law. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Godwin%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Godwin%27s_law
- known 11y agoSounds like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pareto_principle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pareto_principle
- sandGorgon 11y agoanybody what is the exact query being used ?
- ck2 11y agoWell Nazis were arguably the biggest stain ever on human history. Pretty much a reference point for any human being who has gotten some education. Also a handy, lazy way to box-up anyone you disagree with or want to troll. As generations move further and further away from WW2 people may stop relating to it though. Hard to imagine kids in 2100 using Nazi references. Might be climate destruction references instead.
- shitgoose 11y ago181 comments and already 35 mentions of Trump. Beats Godwin.
- awalton 11y ago... does this correct for non-Nazi Nazi usage? Like "Grammar nazi" or "Spelling nazi"?
- stefanix 11y agoIt would be more interesting to compare TTH (Time To Hitler) on different websites. Not sure reddit is a contender. Maybe look over to Fox news.