3 ms·
Well, circumvention of DRM by technical means is currently forbidden by copyright law. This isn't great, but I suspect it has an effect of moderating just how b
by geofft 11y ago
Well, circumvention of DRM by technical means is currently forbidden by copyright law. This isn't great, but I suspect it has an effect of moderating just how bad DRM is.
Remember that there are two reasons DRM is bad. The first is that it prevents you from doing things permitted by copyright law (e.g., fair use). The second is that it has unrelated side effects to your computing freedom. The recent batch of DRM, like streaming from Spotify, is nowhere near as bad for your computing freedom as stuff like Sony's rootkit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sony_BMG_copy_protection_rootkit_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sony_BMG_copy_protection_rootk... . The first downside is true of all DRM; the second is true of only some.
Because it is not legal to just have a GitHub project explaining how to break Spotify's DRM, there's no incentive for Spotify to be as malicious as Sony. Their DRM only has to be good enough to convince the publishers that it works. If we say that all copyright protection is off, and DRM stands or falls entirely on its technical strength, we encourage an arms race. There will be non-sketchy websites offering reliable and well-engineered DRM removal tools, and the labels will point to them and insist that Spotify step up their game.
- Johnny_Brahms 11y agoThose laws are, like DRM, made in the interest of companies. They'd have to go as well.
- geofft 11y agoI'm not sure what your proposal here is. You want companies, which are government-created structures with the ability to acquire large amounts of funding, provide employment, etc. to have a free-for-all on just how strong their DRM can be? Why?
- Johnny_Brahms 11y agoAnd then people would find out just how locked in they can become. And hopefully demand something else.