4 ms·
I studied Japanese in school and I think it would have been extremely difficult to learn on my own. So... I'd say it depends.
by emodendroket 11y ago
I studied Japanese in school and I think it would have been extremely difficult to learn on my own. So... I'd say it depends.
- Bartweiss 11y agoLanguage seems like a complicating factor here. It's difficult (especially in non-Latinate cases) to learn self-directed, and people who are fluent and willing to work in the field can actually do quite well traveling and translating for businesses and government agencies. Of course, all of these numbers are complicated by "salary of graduates" versus "salary of graduates employed in field".
- jjuel 11y agoBut it does depend. If the above poster was taking Japanese as his sole Major it is probably not worth it. If he/she is taking it as an addendum to say a Business degree then it is very much worth it.
- emodendroket 11y agoI guess it depends how you define "worth it." I have a satisfying career but it has nothing to do with my ability in Japanese.
- emodendroket 11y agoIf you're studying Japanese because you think it will make you money it is a bad idea
- Tideflat 11y agoLess well known languages like Japanese tend to have higher returns on investment than common ones like Spanish. IIRC Spanish has a return on investment of about 3%.
- emodendroket 11y agoIn my experience the Japanese translation market was very crowded and didn't pay well so my first plan went out the window.
- dagw 11y agoI forget if it was Planet Money or Freakonomics, but there was a podcast about the ROI of learning a foreign language and according to the research they cited the only foreign language worth learning from a pure ROI perspective was English.
- jerf 11y agoGiven the thousands of majors, there are certainly exceptions on both sides. But I'm still comfortable with that assessment in general; "learning an entire language" is also one of the exceptions. I'd also point out that if for the sake of argument that was your primary goal at college, college is a very cost-ineffective choice. There's plenty of non-college ways of doing that, for way less money, since it's something that business people have to do routinely. Even if it means taking languages courses from the local community college on the side... I'm not aware of much evidence that major colleges teach the courses all that much better or indeed even differently for languages.
- emodendroket 11y agoI'd be very surprised if business people spend much time reading Japanese literature, learning anything other than pure modern business Japanese, or probably even learning to read and write the language.
- treehau5 11y agoOnce you embark on the quest to learn japanese, you begin to look for other avenues to hone in on those skills -- whether its finding other people who speak it, or in some people's cases, play on japanese gaming servers, or skyping/hangouts and converse with japanese people in full immersion. After that you want to start reading more literature, so you do what anyone would do and search for japanese books on Amazon. After a while amazon starts offering you remarkable suggestions based on what the majority of japanese speaking people are reading. You would be surprised how much you could learn on your own! My case it was german. I was so fascinated with the german language, and germany as a whole, in part I must sadly admit because I was such an avid fan of WW2 history. I actually tried to go the traditional route, and I hated it. I noticed one time some germans playing counterstrike and other MMORPG's I was playing. I got to know them better, in part because of their extreme delight in my ability to say a few things in german. Then it turned into ventrilo/teamspeak sessions, which then turned into me wanting to read actual german books, then it went on to learning about Otto Von Bismarck, German Reunification, the East/West cultural divide, watching foreign german films such as Der Unterfall, Das Leben der Anderen, Good Bye, Lenin!, effects German engineering such as Gottlieb Wilhelm Daimler and von Braun, which led me down the path of looking into german businesses, especially the ones that are here in my own home state (which are many), it was so much fun! edit: I realize you qualified it with 'business' people, implying they won't see the value of learning the other things, but since business people is a large group (of which I myself can be considered a part of) I imagine there are others like me.
- Retric 11y agoI think you can self learn Japanese by moving to Japan without much formal education ed: in Japanese. This assumes having a background where you could move to Japan. But, over a 20 year time scale it's not unreasonable.
- emodendroket 11y agoThat would be next to impossible without some college degree. Might as well study Japanese.
- Retric 11y agoYes, but the idea was you are better off studying something else and then picking up Japanese on the side. Instead of studding Japanese and learning that other thing on the side.
- emodendroket 11y agoWell, besides that, twenty years is a lot longer than it took me to achieve.
- Retric 11y agoSure, but it's a classic time money tradeoff. If you have a large trust fund it's a non issue. Or, if you can pay for two degrees in time and effort then the second degree need not pay for its self. However, if you have two interests then gathering credentials in the one which can make more money is probably a better investment.
- emodendroket 11y agohttp://www.theonion.com/blogpost/find-the-thing-youre-most-passionate-about-then-do-31742 http://www.theonion.com/blogpost/find-the-thing-youre-most-p...
- xiaoma 11y agoI studied Japanese in school too. Being young and having free time helped a lot, as did having a Japanese roommate who invited all his buddies over to drink in my room until 3am every weekend. Nonetheless, I have achieved a level of fluency and especially literacy in Mandarin that puts my Japanese of that time to shame and I have no formal credential backing it up. You don't need formal classes to become fluent in a language. If you'd like to learn how some very successful language learners have done it, check out http://lingsprout.com/experts http://lingsprout.com/experts
- emodendroket 11y agoYou don't need formal training in anything to practice it unless there is some sort of licensure scheme.