5 ms·
I find it disheartening that the only way it seems we can think about college anymore is a sort of vocational school where we train for careers.
by emodendroket 11y ago
I find it disheartening that the only way it seems we can think about college anymore is a sort of vocational school where we train for careers.
- Vraxx 11y agoUnless you're lucky enough to already have enough resources to spend both time and money attending a school without any expectation of return, it seems to be the natural conclusion to me. Without the incentive of higher paying jobs backing colleges, something tells me they would be quite a bit less successful in recruiting students.
- 11thEarlOfMar 11y agoThat is a side effect of the cost. In-state public university costs are up 296% over the last 20 years[1]. It is no surprise that a family spending that much money, per child, will consider the return on that spending. It is far more than a typical car and more in the realm of buying a home. [1] http://www.usnews.com/education/best-colleges/paying-for-college/articles/2015/07/29/chart-see-20-years-of-tuition-growth-at-national-universities http://www.usnews.com/education/best-colleges/paying-for-col...
- emodendroket 11y agoWell, is it, or is the rising cost a result of us thinking of it as some "investment" in a future career? I think it's a sort of vicious cycle.
- mtberatwork 11y agoThe rising cost is a direct result of cutbacks in public funding. http://www.cnbc.com/2015/06/16/why-college-costs-are-so-high-and-rising.html http://www.cnbc.com/2015/06/16/why-college-costs-are-so-high...
- emodendroket 11y agoYes, no kidding. But why are those happening?
- kdamken 11y agoWhen it costs upwards of $100,000 to attend, you better be thinking of what you're getting for your money. Unfortunately in America it doesn't come free.
- lintiness 11y agonothing's "free", not even college in european utopia.
- throwaway049 11y agoUndergrad tuition is free to the student in some European countries. As you wrote "free", I concede that the cost is picked up by the taxpayer. http://www.topuniversities.com/student-info/student-finance/how-much-does-it-cost-study-europe http://www.topuniversities.com/student-info/student-finance/...
- kdamken 11y agoIt's way more "free" in Europe than the US though.
- lintiness 11y agois it? how does one measure that? do they have some super secret method to running a university more cheaply than the us? is anything sacrificed in so doing? how do reputations stack up? these are complicated issues, and pretending one's free and the other's an outrageous ripoff is a ridiculous simplification.
- umanwizard 11y agoOECD expenditures on tertiary education per student in 2011: http://imgur.com/5brGGWw http://imgur.com/5brGGWw [1] The U.S. is an outlier. [1] Source: http://www.oecd.org/edu/EAG2014-Indicator%20B1%20(eng).pdf http://www.oecd.org/edu/EAG2014-Indicator%20B1%20(eng).pdf
- kdamken 11y ago
- crispyambulance 11y agoYes, and it is odious that "value" is measured based on ROI from getting the degree. Do STEM degrees yield more ROI? Perhaps, but if the article is attempting to help an individual student frame their thinking about what to major in, it is very bad advice. People should follow their aptitudes. Study what compels them and what they're talented in, regardless of statistical ROI's that apply NOT to individuals but to a population of people. I've seen it a lot, good students who force themselves into degree programs for subjects they have no interest in: going to pre-law or pre-med or finance or engineering, not because they love the subject matter but for status and for the hope of a "well-paid" career (often propelled by parents wishes). We may very well need more STEM folks, but what we DON'T need is more STEM folks who are passionless, untalented duds who are in it for the money/status.
- sergiosgc 11y ago> People should follow their aptitudes. This is posed in too absolute terms. People should, among their aptitudes, pick some activity that has the prospect of a fulfilling professional life. Aptitude and personal preference represent one aspect of such fulfillment. Market fit is, however, most definitely relevant towards professional success.
- crispyambulance 11y agoA "fulfilling" professional life is rather hard to define but the economist article seems to take the very narrow view that "fulfilling" means to maximize the ROI for time/money spent in education by optimizing one's selection of major. The fact is people do just fine majoring in things such as studio arts and literature. It could very well mean that they don't end up working professionally in those fields, but that is OK. Some of these people end up working in the same companies as their peers, some end up in menial jobs after college, some become your boss (and some do all or none of these). And I am not even mentioning the fact that at age 18, many many students have yet to find themselves and settle on a major, let alone a career path.
- humanrebar 11y ago> People should follow their aptitudes. Study what compels them and what they're talented in, regardless of statistical ROI's that apply NOT to individuals but to a population of people. I can be the best plate-spinner in the world, but I still need to provide for the people that depend on me. People should start with the set of jobs that can support them and their (future! sometimes unexpected!) family and then pick the things they have aptitude at.
- rayiner 11y agoI find that point of view to be a conceit. It's an emulation of the noble classes of yore, who learned things they didn't need to know as a way of signaling that they could afford to do so because they didn't need to work. Most people are no better off 10-years down the line for having learned about what native Americans used to live in Virginia or what covalent bonds are.
- CPLX 11y agoFor an opposing viewpoint, today might actually be an excellent day to ponder the effect of a lack of understanding of basic math, science, and history has on the general electorate.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 11y agoI assume you're talking about Trump. We've had universal basic education in those subjects for decades, so that cannot be the explanation. I suspect the problem is not a lack of education, but a lack of indoctrinating the right values. Consider climate change. I believe climate change is happening and needs to be addressed. But I don't really understand the mechanics. Neither do the people who think it doesn't exist. Rather, I've been socialized to trust experts and scientists when they speak on their area of expertise and they have not. People who dislike Trump don't do so because they know facts he doesn't. They dislike him because they have different values than he holds (or purports to hold).
- humanrebar 11y ago> They dislike him because they have different values than he holds Right. I believe in the Golden Rule and Trump thinks it's not a big deal. https://youtu.be/PX9reO3QnUA?t=17 https://youtu.be/PX9reO3QnUA?t=17
- rayiner 11y ago
- Bartweiss 11y agoAside from the "it's expensive!" claim, I would argue that the vocational school view is increasingly driven by how large colleges behave. As access to professors declines in favor of TA/lecturer taught classes, and as the amount of red tape rises, the whole "pursuit of knowledge" claim grows slowly thinner. It's not gone, obviously, and some places are better than others, but it seems to be getting scarcer. If your degree no longer offers a shot at the sublime beauty of understanding, I suppose it's time to start counting dollars.
- emodendroket 11y agoWell, yes, it's one thing for businesses to prattle on about how colleges must be reformed to teach only things they think they need, but it's frustrating to see colleges start accepting it too.
- JackFr 11y agoTo say anything more means to assign some meaning or value to life other than hedonic consumption, which nowadays is something people are often reluctant to do in a public forum.
- sokoloff 11y agoTo be fair, that article is in the Economist.
- shanemhansen 11y agoColleges are enthusiastic partners in positioning the concept that college is a path to a good career. They only seem to bring out complaints about using colleges as "vocational school" when people expect results. It's not like university admissions offices are filled with people saying "Are you sure you want to come here? Don't do it for any hope of having a job in the future, this is a $n year exercise in pure reason and research." What I find truly disheartening is that if you judge colleges by their actions, they think of themselves as tax-advantaged businesses trying to extract the most dollars possible from financially naive kids, donors, and sports fans.