5 ms·
Google ads in search will always be valuable because you can advertise nail varnish to people who have just searched for "buy nail varnish". Google and Faceboo
by onion2k 11y ago
Google ads in search will always be valuable because you can advertise nail varnish to people who have just searched for "buy nail varnish".
Google and Facebook both have the problem that their business model is predicated on having thousands of small advertisers bidding on ads. That's what they leverage to generate profit. In any market that's dominated by a single entity that smaller companies won't compete with for ad space, both Google and Facebook lose the ability to make money.
When the majority of people who want to buy nail varnish bypass search entirely and go straight to Amazon, Google and Facebook have a huge problem. The same is true if developers go straight to Stack Overflow, people looking for rooms go straight to AirBNB, people moving around cities go straight to Uber, etc, then Google and Facebook will have no one to sell ad space to any more.
I'm not about to suggest Google and Facebook are doomed; they both have talent enough to think of ways to meet these challenges. I would however suggest that they are not too big to fail.
- malka 11y ago> I would however suggest that they are not too big to fail. Nothing is. Ultimately, everything fails.
- Rzah 11y agoOf all the things that might happen, users going directly to websites rather than through google/facebook is by far the least likely. Whats more likely to happen is that someone will come along with better search with less advertising (just like Google did), or someone might build a better social network with less advertising (just like facebook did). There's as much precidence for these things reoccurring as there is for users increasingly searching rather than using the url bar.
- jonatanheyman 11y agoRather than using the URL bar, I think it's more likely that people will just open their Uber app, flight booking app, shopping app, etc. I don't think that is an unlikely development.
- Yhippa 11y agoFacebook is trying to head that off by having app integrations in Messenger. The whole new bot craze too. Wonder if Google will jump on this train via Hangouts.
- austinsharp 11y agoThere have been rumors that Google is planning a new, entirely separate messaging service, with bot integrations etc. http://venturebeat.com/2015/12/22/google-is-reportedly-developing-a-chatbot-infused-messaging-service/ http://venturebeat.com/2015/12/22/google-is-reportedly-devel...
- Yhippa 11y agoI've been down on Hangouts due to it's bugginess but pretty much have to use it due to Project Fi. I they came out with something as rock solid as WhatsApp but with bots I would be on board again.
- dajohnson89 11y agoSame here. I'm forced to use hangouts, due to having Project FI. But google hangouts drops calls, and also does annoying little things like compressing images sent via SMS.
- melvinmt 11y agoBrace yourselves, Google is launching something social again... This is why I have mad respect for Zuckerberg. He's willing to place gigantic bets (Instagram/WhatsApp) when and where it matters.
- at-fates-hands 11y agoThere are a ton of thing I hate about Zucks but have to respect his foresight by making very timely and smart purchases to expand his brand.
- Bartweiss 11y agoMost of the time, people seem more likely to Google for "amazon nail polish" than actually visit the site. Of course, company-name keywords usually mean that the ad and the first hit are both Amazon.
- cpeterso 11y agoI disagree completely. People trust sites like Amazon and prefer them if they have already registered an account or are Amazon Prime members. When you want to buy a new CD, do you just google for the band name or do you head to amazon.com (or your preferred music site)?
- subpixel 11y agoI observe people doing this all the time. Especially people who are less technical than you or I. Convenience trumps accuracy and people want a list of offers they perceive to be competitive, not a list of search results. Millions of people look on Amazon first, or Cheapoair, or Hotels.com, the list goes on.
- dpweb 11y ago>> Whats more likely to happen is that someone will come along with better search with less advertising and no one will ever find out about it, cause GOOG owns the OS on billions of devices.
- a_small_island 11y ago>When the majority of people who want to buy nail varnish bypass search entirely and go straight to Amazon Do you even do this? My guess is the majority will never do what you're setting out to believe. Strictly speaking of Amazon, they don't even have the best prices these days.
- blowski 11y agoI use DuckDuckGo hash bangs - !auk nail polish
- onion2k 11y agoIf a purchaser is really price conscious then they'll turn to price comparison websites, everyone else will go directly to their favourite store, where 'favourite' is driven by services like Amazon Prime that add value rather than being anything to do with brand loyalty[1]. Either way, Google is not part of the equation. [1] I have a Prime account because having it for Amazon Video and Amazon Music is far cheaper than paying for Netflix and Spotify. The fact I now go to Amazon by default to buy things because I get free, quick delivery is a bonus for me, and a big win for them if I'm paying more than other places for things I guess.
- Scramblejams 11y agoI constantly do this, so does my wife. Even if we don't end up buying from Amazon, we'll read lots of reviews and often figure out what to buy from there. And for me, if I don't buy from Amazon, I usually end up going straight to eBay after that.