3 ms·
I thought this article was poorly researched and the conclusions don't follow from any of the data presented. The narrative is basically just a disgruntled "old
by titzer 11y ago
I thought this article was poorly researched and the conclusions don't follow from any of the data presented. The narrative is basically just a disgruntled "old man yells at cloud" screed. Then I saw this:
> This is a re-run of the online advertising crash of the early 2000s, when the proliferation of banners and pop-ups destroyed any value these ads had (and led people to install pop-up killers, just like with ad blockers today). It took one Google to come up with contextual advertising to bring the market back to life.
What is the author claiming here? Really? The dot-com bubble was due to advertising? Huh? Perhaps he means something completely different, because the real dot-com bubble had everything to do with actual online businesses, a ton of credit, startups, and vapor. It was not about advertising.
- wutbrodo 11y ago> I thought this article was poorly researched and the conclusions don't follow from any of the data presented Seriously. A whole paragraph and graph about how click prices were declining and no mention of the move to mobile? Just some assumptions pulled out of his ass about how ads suddenly rapidly declined in quality in those particular years? (never mind that both desktop and mobile ad prices were growing, with the overall decline attributable to the shift to mobile usage). There's a lot of crap on the Internet but it's pathetic that HN has finally stooped low enough that such low quality drivel gets frontpaged by uncritical up voters.
- bhouston 11y ago> It was not about advertising. High CPMs were part of the bubble. Not the primary core of the bubble but it did support a lot of companies. In the run up to the crash CPMs (for just impressions) were very very high, but after the crash they dropped 10x fold. This wiped out many companies that were dependent upon these fat CPMs for their continued existence. Some citations: https://www.quora.com/What-does-the-dot-com-bubble-burst-have-to-do-with-the-ad-tech-industry-and-advertising-technology https://www.quora.com/What-does-the-dot-com-bubble-burst-hav... https://moz.com/blog/return-of-the-cpm-ad-model https://moz.com/blog/return-of-the-cpm-ad-model
- mtanski 11y agoArguably if the various vendors in the ad bidding lifecycle chain did more to combat fraud and only show 90% viewable ad (the tech exist) this would lead to lower volume of impressions and higher CPM since everybody is competing for the same audience. A lot of these vendors' business are predicated on large scale and they tend to be reluctant to turn off bad actors.