12 ms·
I wrote a small piece on planned death
- UweSchmidt 11y agoMy take: all the recent changes in western society could be tagged with "Individualism". Fundamental changes regarding lifestyle, relationships and sexuality were enabled by the demise of collectivist ideologies like communism and national socialism which had clear ideas how humans should live, and the wealth and flexibility of modern economies, which enable the individual to exist without any dependencies except a job. Instead of refering to moral, ethical and other absolutist arguments it's useful to look at how until recently rules limiting the individual were probably necessary for collective survival, and delight in the freedom we can have now. Right now we're watching people around us coming to terms with planned death (possible now since the community does not need you to tough it out until the end any more). There are more radical and crazy changes ahead that would be revolting right now but will be normal in the future.
- loup-vaillant 11y ago> collectivist ideologies like communism and national socialism I sense a conflation between communism and USSR dictatorship. I'm not sure this is warranted. (Then again, China is supposedly lead by a "communist party".) More generally, are you suggesting that collectivist ideologies necessarily leads to totalitarianism? > which enable the individual to exist without any dependencies except a job. That last exception will need to be remedied some day. Some more automation and substantially more redistribution should do it. Which is why I'm so disturbed by your juxtaposition of communism and national socialism: many people equate redistribution with communism with dictatorship, preventing us to solve the problem of ever growing structural inequality. We're going to get over this trauma if we're to avoid the coming horrors of corporate capitalism (or the horrors of its unplanned demise).
- UweSchmidt 11y agoI didn't mean to conflate things; imagine a benevolent communist leadership, or compassionate national socialism: you would still be under a massive ideologically influence. They might not burn your book, but expect massive resistance to anything that does not conform to the collectivist mainstream. To any human from before WW2 we are all crazy weirdos and live a life of an eccentric dreamer.
- loup-vaillant 11y agoPossibly. But we do have our own conformism too. We do live under our own ideology. There is no escaping ideology: we humans have values that go beyond our own self anyway. Good luck finding the "right" (whatever that means) ideology, though.
- mafribe 11y agoconflation between communism and USSR dictatorship. It's a simplification, but historically warranted, in the sense that the USSR was created explicitly with the end-goal of leading to a communist society as described by Marx/Engels in the "Communist Manifesto", i.e., the ideal society where the "contradictions of capitalism" have disappeared. Moreover, the 10 points that the "Communist Manifesto" says (Chapter II. Proletarians and Communists) are required to bring about communism were all carried out in the Soviet Union and its satellites (and brought about not communism, but Stalin, Mao and Pol Pot, not to mention an inability to feed the population). If you want to be more precise in your terminology, I suggest the following distinctions: Marxism is a theory. Typically 3 things are theorised. (1) How capitalism (re)produced inequality. (2) A theory of revolution as intrinsic part of the transition from contemporary society to communism via socialism. (3) A theory of post-revolutionary society. Socialism. This describes post-revolutionary, but pre-communist societies, in particular USSR and its satellites. Communism. The ideal society, post-revolution, where the "contradictions of capitalism" have disappeared.
- loup-vaillant 11y ago> the USSR was created explicitly with the end-goal of leading to a communist society […] I'm not sure that's true. Granted, it was ostensibly, outwardly created for that purpose. But I'm not sure that was the actual intent of those who lead that charge. My History is quite dusty, so I wonder what exactly brought about the dictatorships you mentioned. Besides, it wouldn't be the first time a revolution lead to (near) absolutism. The French revolution for instance lead to Napoleon. Given this, I wonder how representative governments were able to emerge at all. It doesn't make me very optimistic about the possibility for democracy either. (Yeah, for various reasons, representative governments are hardly democratic: elected leaders are very poor proxies for the will of the people.)
- mafribe 11y agothe actual intent We cannot look into people's head. We have to take into account what they say they do. Yes, we can question to what extent they were telling the truth, possibly even to themselves. wouldn't be the first time That's why revolutionary political movements continue having a bad name.
- lgieron 11y ago> My take: all the recent changes in western society could be tagged with "Individualism". Fundamental changes regarding lifestyle, relationships and sexuality were enabled by the demise of collectivist ideologies like communism and national socialism which had clear ideas how humans should live, and the wealth and flexibility of modern economies, which enable the individual to exist without any dependencies except a job. I don't know the details on nazis (national socialists), but what you're describing was actually was a goal communism - to produce totally atomized units which for everything depend only on the state (that included a totally dystopian dissasembling of families, ex. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pavlik_Morozov https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pavlik_Morozov)
- J-dawg 11y agoCould you elaborate on the radical and crazy changes ahead?
- UweSchmidt 11y agoI am hesitating since that would put things that were just accepted very recently, wounds still healing, in a relation to things that are currently way out of bounds. Not my intention. But just to illustrate, recently a court in Germany supposedly denied someone the right to marry their pet. Why? Ah and there was a promient case of cannibalism between consenting adults a few years ago. Got moral, ethical concerns about it? Or just caught some phobia? Either way, the society-transforming force of Individualism will ensure that the individual will get their way and get to do whatever they want. The Internet (find likeminded people, get crazy ideas, be happy alone) and the declining birth rates (more focus on individual uniqueness and development) have only accelerated this trend.
- throwaway324324 11y agoIf collective survival was the driving influence, we would have been in favor of suicide for people who were a "burden", like cancer patients. http://www.straightdope.com/columns/read/2160/did-eskimos-put-their-elderly-on-ice-floes-to-die http://www.straightdope.com/columns/read/2160/did-eskimos-pu... Assisted suicide isn't a new freedom - we had it in the past, it went out of favor, and now it's favorable again. Ancient Greece had radical and crazy practices (infanticide, certain sexual pairings) that are revolting "right now". Having to come to terms with those particular practices isn't something that I look forward to doing in the future.
- camillomiller 11y agoI'm in the metro, crying. Fuck.
- buro9 11y agoI've chatted with friends about my desires should I get a cancer that is more likely to kill and not be treatable, to refuse chemo, and to live what remains of my life qualitatively rather than quantitatively. I would plan how best to handle my death, and aim to enjoy every moment before a quick and severe pain takes over and does the job. Some have said this is a selfish viewpoint, that I should stay around longer for the ones I love. But the reverse is true, it is selfish of those that love to demand quantity over quality, especially when it slowly strips away the very being of a person. All we can do is live a life fully, but that isn't "as long as possible", it is "as much as possible".
- concerto 11y agoEveryone's choice is personal, and while it is not fair for people to say your hypothetical choice would be selfish, I would also ask you to be careful about your judgements on others who are actually facing this and have made a different choice.
- teekert 11y agoWhy would you let that pain even take over, why not gently increase Morphine as you go? That is how it's done here in the Netherlands and, I guess also in Canada now. A friend of mine (then 24) went home to die even though doctors still wanted to treat him. But as everyone else he didn't want to die alone, in a hospital. He went home, had a cigarette, stared over the sea, drank a beer with his soccer mates. Within 2 weeks he died. His way. those two weeks were a lot more valuable than the 2 months just spend in isolation because of the absence of an immune system. I'd definitely choose quality over quantity, it sounds bizarre to me that you yourself would not be the person allowed to make that choice in some countries.
- marincounty 11y agoMy father died of liver cancer. He was under the care of Hospice. They gave my father enough drugs (Morphine, benzodiazepines, ect.) in the beginning. He lived two months pretty happy. He liked the effects of the drugs. My father was a pretty hardcore drinker, but very functional throughout his life. He was also very conservative, and would never take an drug that wasen't legal. Growing up, every once in awhile, he would tell me, "I think I would like the effect of heroin, but I would never take it." My father could never seem to relax, kinda like myself, and my brother. Even as a kid, I knew my father needed to switch up his drugs, but I knew there wasen't much of a choice. As the years went by, I asked him to see a psychiatrist. Of course he said no. "But dad, you have this great union insurance--just see if the Dr. has anything for you." He never went, and I don't know if any doctor would give him anything--other than a detox program. What the doctor didn't know is my father stopped drinking for two months in his thirties. He felt better, but it was obvious he was nervous. He went right back to drinking. The problem is, I really think, my father needed a drug like clonezepam before he went into detox. Anyway, he never went. My experience with Psychiatry is they gave me anti-anxiety medication, but it just was never enough. Years later, my doctor gave me a off-label drug that did the trick. I just wish the Dr. would have tried the harder drug years earlier. Back to my father last two months. He was pretty functional, and liked the effects of the medication. In those two months, I thought my father would turn into a more compassionate person. He didn't. He spent his free time deciding who was going to get his money. My sister, and brother both tried to manipulate him, but my father seemed to like the attention? I stayed out of the drama--just because. Well after two months, the drugs weren't enough. He needed more, but the hospice Dr. was way to prudent on the amounts. My father only saw the Dr. once, and every other communication was by phone. The hospice nurse arrived, I believe, a week before he died. We asked her for more drugs. She said, he just needs us around him. He was misserable that week. My greedy sister kept lessening his medication so he would wake up. He would wake up misserable. The nurse thought it was o.k.--like it was an act of love. I never told the nurse, but my sister wants him up to sign a trust. I got the feeling even if I told the nurse how manipulative my sister is, I don't think the nurse would have done anything. My sister has a way of gaining people's confidence quick. Never understood how people couldn't see through her? My father was under medicated that final week. There was not enough meds on hand. My sister had the nurse under her spell. Plus, the nurse was projecting her own father's death over my father's. The nurse was always crying, and talking how difficult it was when her father died. I'm not questioning the nurse's emotions, and at first found them--honestly--I'm glad she cared enough to show emotion, but her crying made verything more stressful. My father didn't even know who this crying nurse was in the end. My biggest gripe is she let my sister cut back on his pain/anxiety medications. The last three days of my father's life were hell. He would wake up frightened. He was always in intence pain. He was skin and bones. My sister once lifted the sheets and said, "In a way it's interesting? I said, "What?" She said, "Oh, the way the body breaks down." Yea--I was floored. While I knew she loved her father, I didn't say anything. Plus, I knew a death like my father's would be terrible. My father's last words to me were, "Son--when will this end?". I didn't know what to say. I wanted to say, you need more medication, but didn't. He wasen't conscious enough for me to answer his last question. He died two days later. All the family, and nurse were there. The nurse was saying all these new age beliefs, like he knows his loved ones are here. He wants you to talk to him. My sister had her indifferent kids saying kids things into his ears. He was never fond of kids--even his grandkids, so their voices didn't sooth him. I don't even know if he knew who was trying to talk to him? He kinda rswatted them away from the bed. The last two days where horrid. He wasen't conscious, but he felt pain. So much pain. Pain! He was back to full doses of medication, but it wasn't enough. I called the doctor, and said he needs more. The Doctor said any more, and he might die. I didn't argue. I was an emotional mess. I was just thinking what's wrong with dying at this point? I left an hour before my father passed. The rest of the family was there. I just didn't want to see him die like this. I knew he wasen't responding to us, but still had that horrid pain. There's a part of me that feels guilty for not being there. I figured what's the point of watching my father in so much pain. I found the professionals really had no answers in my father's death. I got home and had a few glasses of wine, and got a call an hour later. "He died." I told my sister I'm sorry. She called back a month later, and wondered why her mother, nor myself weren't calling her. I made up some excuse. When my father died, It was so painful--I'm still not quite over it. It has been 11 years and 5 months. Even though we didn't get along; the way he died greatly affected my life. In a weird way, part of me died that day. (I hate to say this, but when my time comes, I don't want to go the way my father did. If I'm well enough, and have the money I will go and buy drugs off the streets. I've never even bought drugs before, but I think if I have the energy I will try it? Maybe? If I'm still in CA, and we have a Right to Die bill that just passed. Sorry, I went on. The man who's writing these brave posts is hitting me hard. I'm glad he's bringing death out in the open though.)
- notlisted 11y agoThe only reason why I may ultimately move back to Western-Europe: the right to arrange a peaceful death on my own terms. Sad news nonetheless.
- datamoshr 11y agoPieters calmness as he wrote these two last pieces is admirable. As an existential thanataphobe[1] I'd love to understand a bit more on how he's come to this level of serenity and acceptance. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_anxiety_(psychology) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_anxiety_(psychology)
- Delmania 11y agoWhat choice did he have? He probably went through the classic 7 stages of grief. In the end, his death was inevitable (as is all of ours), he just was faced with it as a reality as most of us think it is many years off.
- PieterH 11y agoHonestly, when I was told I had cancer five+ years ago, it was just the same. I understood the diagnosis rapidly, cooperated fully, and when they told me I would be operated (on my birthday, 2010), I realized I might live, and prepared myself for surgery. I never had any strong negative emotions about it.
- joncrocks 11y agoI think he's had a while to come to terms with it. He first got cancer in 2010 according to a blog post last year: http://hintjens.com/blog:109 http://hintjens.com/blog:109
- PieterH 11y agoIf you read my book The Psychopath Code you'll see my discussion on "grounding", which is a simple (yet hard) technique for keeping yourself free of destructive emotions. That book, BTW was absolutely panned on Reddit since I'm not a psychologist. I watched hundreds of comments telling me to fuck off, to kill myself, how did I dare discuss such things without credentials. And at the same time I watched my book sales spike up to 10 times more than ever before, and I chortled like a gleeful madman... Sometimes it's really just a matter of perspective and I'm usually good at finding the right perspective on things.
- panorama 11y agoI can't fathom how it must feel to live each day while a cancer grows inside of me. Pieter is definitely a man of much greater fortitude than I. I also can't get over the fact that 1 in 2 people develop cancer in their lifetimes. One would think curing cancer ought to be amongst humanity's greatest concerted challenges.
- loganmhb 11y ago> One would think curing cancer ought to be amongst humanity's greatest concerted challenges. One of the reasons "curing cancer" is so difficult is that cancer itself is not really one disease but many, with diverse causes and treatments. What works for one kind cancer doesn't work for another, so some kinds are fully curable and others unstoppable, with of course many in between. New research tends to chip away at variations of the disease without being able to cure it wholesale. If you're interested in the recent history of cancer and cancer medicine, the book "The Emperor of All Maladies" is a fascinating treatment of the subject.
- PieterH 11y agoIn my case, my lungs are filling up with something that is slowly choking me. I take oxygen and have bad coughing spells, and that's it. No pain yet. When the cancer grows into my stomach it'll be worse. I've no timetable so am guessing a month or two before I need permanent pain killers and am effectively out of action. (If I can't think and write clearly, I'm finished.) I'm organizing a party/wake/meetup/barbeque at my place on 5th June, no matter what state I'm in. :)
- goldenkey 11y agoWe strive to have a high signal to noise ratio on HN. There's nothing wrong with what you wrote, they are your emotions. However, please make an effort to tell us more about how you feel or your thoughts and comments on the post.
- sago 11y agoThere are times when subduing our emotions is important for quality communication. We should rise above our instincts. There are other times when the emotion is what needs to be communicated. When our instinct is to empathy, not tribalism. Subduing emotion at that point is inhuman.
- camillomiller 11y agoYeah, sorry, you are right, but that was probably the most sincere reply I could post, put in a very straight form. I had to stop reading, because it was too much.
- goldenkey 11y agoHey its all good mate. I realized I was a bit abrasive too. Maybe I was wrong, people seem to have some strong commentary some agreeing, others disagreeing.
- rbanffy 11y agoThis is signal. What is written, how it's written and what's not written because writing was overwhelming are all part of it.
- bcook 11y agoWe all cry at a funeral... that is not what the family or loved ones remember. They remember the speakers, the speeches that offer something useful to explain the occasion. No disrespect to the parent poster (or author) but... acknowledging that something that is obviously sad is actually sad is not a very useful observation.
- ins0 11y agoFor those who have not read his first blog post or want to read the comments from the first article: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11547212 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11547212 http://hintjens.com/blog:115 http://hintjens.com/blog:115
- PieterH 11y agoThanks for the links. I'll also try to contribute to this thread where I can.
- pieter_mj 11y agoI recently witnessed my uncle's euthanasia. There's a few things to consider and discuss with your leifarts (as the euthanasia assisting doctor is called in Belgium) : - death is instantanious (within 15-30 seconds of administration of penthotal) - often a sedative is given. Dormicum can lead to loud snoring so you should discuss with your doctor necessity/alternative
- jonathankoren 11y agoAnd yet in the US you're pretty much stuck with refusal of treatment which inevitably means dying slowly of dehydration. The outcome is the same and everyone knows it. After all, that's the point. It's just needlessly barbaric. We don't even treat animals that way.
- lostlogin 11y agoIt is strange. Allowing the state to take a life but not allowing the individual the same right over their own life.
- wbillingsley 11y agoLimiting the options to "palliative care" instead of active euthanasia is partly a bulwark against there ever being social-pressure-to-die. And given many societies aren't very good at identifying or dealing with elder abuse as it is, it seems a reasonable bulwark to have.
- BatFastard 11y agoHow about the incredible social-pressure-to-live!, not only social pressure but legal pressure. In my father's last few weeks of life I would see him wake up each day asking "why am I still here". Because you have NO choice.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- 11y ago
- thu 11y agoI'm from Belgium, just like Pieter, and a former colleague of mine worked with him and knows him well. I didn't want to read its previous blog post when I saw the title on HN. Then that former colleague posted it on Facebook, and I told myself the title was about Pieter himself. The father of my girlfriend died from cancer a few months ago. When I met him three years ago he was fine. Not sure if it is a good idea to read this post if you're too close to depression but it is actually almost playful. "Internet hugs..."
- PieterH 11y agoI'm determined to show people that death does not need to be a sad or depressing thing. Loss is, of course. I know my kids are going to suffer. I know they're going to be angry, confused, maybe even self-destructive at times, when they realize over and over that the person who steered them has gone, and they have to learn to steer themselves. Yet it's part of the order of things, isn't it? Loss forces us forwards. My kids are strong and they know it and they'll get courage in their darkest moments by remembering that I was never afraid, angry, or self-destructive, when I was dying. This part, it is playful and joyful, and I'm so incredibly happy to be part of it. And I'm not on any drugs, just a large carton of Ayran my son bought me from the baker this morning. :)
- disposeofnick9 11y agoI've seen too many people get unnecessary, life-quality-killing butcherous surgeries and read the evidence confirming most end-of-life surgeries rarely have useful benefit. If you're going to check out, go with dignity and don't put your family / self through extended suffering. If you have to go in an unprogressive country, nitrogen itself leaves no evidence and paraphernalia is minimal and can be removed. Also, please do a will, pick an executor, prepaid funeral and make a Quick Reference guide to finances, assets, bills, keys and passwords... both my mother and I are getting this done ahead of time. It's not as depressing as leaving family to stumble through things while grieving.
- danielweber 11y agoMy mother was an RN nurse and saw way way too much of that. My parents have made her wishes very clear to the rest of the family.
- nxzero 11y agoWonder how many people read this and think... "I'm not going to die."
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- emptybits 11y agoRay Kurzweil, perhaps.
- nxzero 11y ago(Sam & Elon too.)
- JoshTriplett 11y agoOr, a more productive thought: "We shall have to work faster." (From http://www.yudkowsky.net/other/yehuda http://www.yudkowsky.net/other/yehuda)
- mbrutsch 11y agoMy mother had a DNR. She contracted meningitis, and died. She was resuscitated, suffered severe brain damage, and lived another 2 years as a semi-vegetable before dying in her sleep after choking on her own vomit. If I believed in such things, I would hope my stepfather is in Hell. edited for spelling
- MacsHeadroom 11y agoThis is very sad. If you're reading this and don't have a "Living Will," know that this is exactly the sort of thing they are for.
- throwaway324324 11y agoYour stepfather apparently violated your mother's directive based on the desperate belief that his spouse could recover, and she did not. This is absolutely tragic. Then your stepfather presumably refused kill his spouse (due to hope, moral beliefs, cowardice, etc.) by unplugging her from standard, non-extraordinary life-support. She eventually died a painless death. For which of these does he deserve to suffer for, more than he has already? A DNR is not an order to cease basic life-support post-resuscitation. For example, I don't want extraordinary measures, but I also absolutely do not want anyone to euthanize me if I somehow end up semi-vegetative.
- exolymph 11y ago> I also absolutely do not want anyone to euthanize me if I somehow end up semi-vegetative. Just out of curiosity, why not?
- throwaway324324 11y agoBecause I would be participating in killing a living human. It's our duty to avoid intentionally doing that, even if it really hurts. Technically it's the same reason that I don't want someone to euthanize me right now. The value of my life does not derive from feeling happy or otherwise using my senses. Nothing important changes when I have brain damage (or cancer, or depression). All I have to do is be human, and my life has a certain type of value that makes it wrong for anyone to intentionally end it. If I try to build in loopholes, or start messing with semantics, or if I compromise because something is going to hurt, I end up being unable to act from reasoned moral principles, which is something else I value. (I have a similar curiosity, if you'd oblige, about what makes euthanasia any different from simple suicide - I actually asked that earlier, but all I got was downvotes.)
- tempodox 11y agoKaplah!
- Delmania 11y agoMemento mori, everyone. Are you living like you're going to die?
- known 11y agoWish I know the cure for cancer
- sdegutis 11y agoIt sucks that we've taught most children for the better half of the past century to avoid all suffering at all costs. That lesson isn't actually coming from actual "compassion," which literally means "suffering with [someone]." Sure, there are some unnecessary sufferings in life which we should avoid and help each other out of, like teaching a child not to touch a hot stove. But then there are plenty of necessary sufferings in life that people shouldn't be "saved" from, but rather taught how to deal with and handle properly. The same people who want to avoid and help others avoid the suffering of a painful death, are the same people who would try to convince their friend to divorce her recently-drug-addicted spouse, who she should have "compassion" on, i.e. "suffer with" him, by spending her time helping him through it until either the addiction is gone or death does them part. They're the same people who can't stand the thought of a young girl feeling ugly or a young boy feeling dumb, so they tell her how beautiful she looks in that dress or how smart he is, which inadvertently gives both of them an inferiority complex and causes them to put all their self-worth in their looks and smarts (respectively), often ironically causing the suffering they were trying to spare them from. These are the same ones who encourage "transgender" teenagers (those who have no real condition but just want attention), because they can't stand the thought of a young person feeling unaccepted and unloved. So instead of teaching these teenagers to properly handle their emotions, and to properly examine their thoughts, they just give in and applaud them in their delusions. All these "solutions" are actually causing more problems than they solve, both in the short-term and the long-term. All because they tried to spare someone else from a necessary form of suffering. Rather, they should be teaching young people to learn to handle rejection, whether from a crush or a college. They should teach them to accept the truth even when it's painful to hear. They should teach them to bear patiently with the many inevitable difficulties of life. (Patience also comes from the Latin word for "suffering [with].") These are necessary forms of suffering that will come to everyone in life, and it's a shame that people aren't taught how to handle them anymore.
- throwaway324324 11y agoSome of my family members have died to suicide. One violently after many people could not restrain them. One very much planned, very much like Pieter. Both found reasons to end their suffering, to take authoritative control over their own death. The suffering doesn't go away, it just takes another form in other people. It seems I'm the authoritarian lunatic, the psychopath, because I cannot see what separates euthanasia from every other tragic suicide. * Is it because someone else performs the injection? Then what about suicide by cop, and cases where the patient injects herself? * Is it because their family members join them in that initial feeling of peace following their decision (which suicide prevention pamphlets warn to watch for)? * Is it because a cancer patient really is better off dead? Then so are many other seemingly-hopeless people, who are depressed, abandoned, and addicted. Is it because doctors agree that they are better off dead? Nobody is pro-suffering, but sometimes we must suffer for the things that make us human. When we hear about deaths, aren't the most painful ones those where a person has said "this human life is not worth living"? No inanimate disease can say something so painful, can affirm it so permanently through willful action.
- throwaway324324 11y agoWhat are the downvotes for? The questions aren't rhetorical, if that's the issue - I really do want to know what distinction people see between this and suicide, which periodically comes up as a topic here, and people are so much against.
- robryk 11y ago> (...) what separates euthanasia from every other tragic suicide I see two large differences: 1. A requirement for euthanasia is usually that the patient keeps wanting it for a reasonably long period of time: it should never be a spur of the moment thing. 2. Another requirement usually is that the patient is mentally competent. > When we hear about deaths, aren't the most painful ones those where a person has said "this human life is not worth living"? If euthanasia is forbidden, people _will still be saying that in similar situations_, just they won't be able to do anything about it.
- throwaway324324 11y ago
- pillowkusis 11y agoI've never known your work until just recently Pieter, but your writing is elegant and powerful. I will remember it when it's my turn to follow you. I can imagine no worse fate than contracting alzheimer's disease, and its a prospect that frightens me all the more knowing that in the US, it would be very difficult to avoid suffering through it to the bitter end. In the US, you have little control over your death. Your eloquent advocacy for planned death is much needed. Thank you for your work.
- mindfulgeek 11y agoI watched my father die of cancer when I was in my early 20s. He went through a bone marrow transplant -- twice. The first time he was sick and it was hard, but he was cancer free for a few months and managed to walk me down the aisle at my wedding. When the cancer came back, he had very little chance of surviving. He opted for full blown treatment, against everyone's recommendations (and my mother's wishes). His body was still weakened from the first transplant, and the cancer grew resistant. Those had been the worst 6 months of my life. In the end, they sent him home. He looked about 80 years old, with thin skin and a frail frame. A few days later he passed in what I found to be the most humiliating and painful few days. After I watched him die, I promised myself I would never let my kids see me die that way -- petrified and feeble. I hadn't realized it then, but the child I made that promise for was barely one when I got my diagnosis. The odds were not in my favor, but I wanted nothing more than to give her a mother. I decided to risk everything and be treated. I spent what could have been the last months of my life in a hospital, too sick to see her. As my oncologist told me -- I was losing one year to save the rest. Best risk of my life. She's almost eight and has a one year old brother. Life is good. Good luck to you. The world is filled with miracles. Your attitude will be the most important thing your children remember. Keep loving them.
- alatkins 11y agoThanks so much for sharing this and congratulations on your recovery.
- nashadelic 11y agoI literally had to hold my breath till your story unfolded. Congratulations on winning your fight!
- olantonan 11y agoMost people die a sad death. Pieter Hintjens dies committing. I will follow suit and keep a git client close to my death bed when it's my time.
- makenosound 11y agoIf you’re interested in some further discussion, Andrew Denton and The Wheeler Centre have been working through the topic of euthanasia (with a particular focus on Australia) in their Better Off Dead podcast: http://www.wheelercentre.com/broadcasts/podcasts/better-off-dead http://www.wheelercentre.com/broadcasts/podcasts/better-off-...
- bettyx1138 11y agothank you for writing this. #respect