8 ms·
The Bug in the Physical Building
- femto 11y agoThe original story in The New Yorker, by Morgenstern, has quite a bit more detail http://people.duke.edu/~hpgavin/cee421/citicorp1.htm http://people.duke.edu/~hpgavin/cee421/citicorp1.htm
- Animats 11y agoIt's a much better article, too. This has been on YC before: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7605993 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7605993
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- oddeyed 11y agoSupporting the analogy of this construction error as a bug, the error itself was found by a person completely unrelated to the project who had access to the 'source code' (built plans). Source: http://www.onlineethics.org/cms/24528.aspx http://www.onlineethics.org/cms/24528.aspx (via the Citigroup Center Wikipedia article)
- michael-the1 11y agoThere's also a great 99pi podcast episode about this. http://99percentinvisible.org/episode/structural-integrity/ http://99percentinvisible.org/episode/structural-integrity/
- raisedbyninjas 11y agoThis also goes into how the bug was found by a student who managed to contact the lead architect and the process of quietly patching the building. The repair happened under a deadline of an approaching tropical storm for added suspense.
- d33 11y agoNot sure if I understood it correctly - so there's a building that would collapse sooner or later in a very dangerous way, but it's still there after almost 40 years? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citigroup_Center#Engineering_crisis_of_1978 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citigroup_Center#Engineering_c...
- asmithmd1 11y agoWhen the bug was discovered (by an undergraduate architect major) they worked nights and weekends to weld the bolted joints. http://www.slate.com/blogs/the_eye/2014/04/17/the_citicorp_tower_design_flaw_that_could_have_wiped_out_the_skyscraper.html http://www.slate.com/blogs/the_eye/2014/04/17/the_citicorp_t...
- pif 11y agoRead the note at the end of the article...
- asmithmd1 11y agoAnother example of a change made at time of construction that compromised the design and wasn't caught is the Kansas City Hyatt walkway collapse: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hyatt_Regency_walkway_collapse https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hyatt_Regency_walkway_collapse
- eternalban 11y agoNot sure this can be called a "bug". This was a design error.
- digler999 11y agothey built something to take a particular input (hurricane-force winds) and produce a specific output (keep standing). Their calculations and over-engineering led them to expect that output all the way through production. Further investigation revealed that another output was more likely. I call that a bug.
- tantalor 11y agoBugs are found in many different places in software (or hardware). Some examples that come to mind, 1. Design 2. Implementation 3. Configuration 4. Deployment I'm sure other people might think of some more.
- Natanael_L 11y agoMaintenance too. Faulty maintenance routines can break stuff, anybody who's got a car knows that very well.
- HeyLaughingBoy 11y agoI've encountered Requirements bugs due to the requirement being flat out wrong. Those are usually easy to find. Contradictory ones can hide until you try to implement them. But one of my favorite tricky ones was an apparently very clearly written Requirement. It passed all the Requirements reviews, design passed design review, code passed, etc. Then the original writer of the requirement went to use the product and said "but that's not what I meant" Sure, I implemented exactly what he very clearly said (wrote) but that turned out to be very different from what he meant to say.
- EdHominem 11y agoIf all bugs were in code my job (as a programmer) would be so easy. It's all the squishy human-worded requirements that cause the problems.
- samscully 11y agoFor anyone interested in this sort of thing "Why Buildings Fall Down" [1] is a good related book. I did civil engineering at university and you'd be surprised how many beautiful and interesting buildings only ended up that way because of constraints forced on the engineers and architects by the surrounding environment. [1] https://www.amazon.co.uk/Why-Buildings-Fall-Down-Structures/dp/039331152X https://www.amazon.co.uk/Why-Buildings-Fall-Down-Structures/...
- thesehands 11y agoLikewise "To Forgive Design: Understanding Failure" [1]. [1]https://www.amazon.co.uk/Forgive-Design-Understanding-Failure-ebook/dp/B00838XLJI/ https://www.amazon.co.uk/Forgive-Design-Understanding-Failur...
- cgriswald 11y ago> ... you'd be surprised how many beautiful and interesting buildings only ended up that way because of constraints forced on the engineers and architects by the surrounding environment. I recently did a major remodel of my home and many of the decisions made were ultimately directed by things outside my control (e.g. physics, availability of materials, environmental conditions, etc.), which resulted in me getting not exactly what I originally wanted, but yielding a result better than my original imagining.
- bobbylox 11y agoIf the author is here, there's a typo: "catastrophy" should be "catastrophe."
- kqr 11y agoI genuinely did not know that was the correct spelling. Thanks! 10/10 bug report.
- gumby 11y agoI encountered concern about unorthodox approaches when building my house: the code says that if you have a central support for the stairs and it is a rectangular pipe of cross section X then it's OK. My staircases floated on a set of plate struts -- basically climbable sculptures designed by the architect. In order to get the permit approved we had to pay someone to write a 15 page book full of differential equations to determine that indeed they wouldn't collapse. A pain, but worth it.
- kpil 11y agoI think the author underestimates the inherent complexity in large scale systems. Yes, incidental complexity makes us skip tests that might have been good, but it is the inherent complexity that explodes in our face when totaly apparently unrelated issues causes emergent behaviour. It has nothing to do with that it's a young field, it's just that we can create complexity that is not bound by laws of physics. I usually show 'business people' Conway's game of life, and they are always fascinated, and then I ask them how many rules WE have.
- TrevorJ 11y agoThe fact that they prolonged the fix in order to carry it out in secret seems pretty damming. I wonder what the justification for that was?
- digler999 11y agoThe building wasn't in imminent danger of collapsing. One would assume that had a gale-force storm been forecast for the city, someone would have ordered an evacuation. However, had they tried to explain the situation, many people would have over-reacted and refused to step foot inside, causing huge losses for everyone.
- EdHominem 11y agoRight, and it wasn't "in secret" - they notified the authorities, etc. An evacuation plan was developed and would have been used if the storm had gotten closer to the city.