3 ms·

48 up-votes in 54 minutes? Why isn't this on the front page?

• clevernickname 11y ago
  Same reason why every vaguely pro-Trump comment has been flagged or downvoted into oblivion.
  • dang 11y ago
    It isn't that it's pro-Trump, it's that it's pure politics. Such posts always get heavily flagged, and it's hard to disagree with that, since they're typically not posted to gratify intellectual curiosity.
    • clevernickname 11y ago
      On the contrary, purely political stories are constantly upvoted and allowed on HN. They're just almost always left leaning stories. A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing 542 points by warrenmar 17 hours ago | flag | past | web | 718 comments I can almost guarantee that if/when Bernie drops out, a submission on it will be allowed to stay and hit hundreds of points.
      • tptacek 11y ago
        Not if I can help it. Politics on HN are toxic, no matter what their valence.
      • dang 11y ago
        Basic Income stories are political, but they aren't purely political. There's an intellectual interest in thinking about and debating such a major social change. Political horse race stories are the opposite. People tend to see HN as ideologically biased in favor of whatever they disagree with—that's a classic cognitive bias in its own right. Indeed there are some biases on specific issues (Snowden detractors don't do well here), but I'm not sure I agree they cut left or right overall. The community is pretty divided, much as the larger population is.