4 ms·
> And they fear that a basic income would, in the end, be less than what many people get when all the federal government's cash and social-service programs are
by aidenn0 11y ago
> And they fear that a basic income would, in the end, be less than what many people get when all the federal government's cash and social-service programs are combined.
Note that the poor will obviously get fewer benefits if BI is only funded from cuts to programs the benefit the poor.
Example: lets say we eliminate program X that currently has a means test limiting it to the poorest 20% of the population. If we, as the article suggests, use that money to fond some fraction of BI for the poorest 80% of the population, then one can trivially see that we have distributed 3/4 of the money for program X away from the poorest 20%.
Now there are significant savings from reducing overhead, but unless program X is 75% overhead, it's still a net loss in realized benefits for the poor.
In order to make BI palatable to the US left, you will need to fund it at least partly through raising taxes.