5 ms·
We have a lot of good technologies already, the problem is they just don't scale well. I can envision older warehouses in an industrial district being converte
by mjevans 11y ago
We have a lot of good technologies already, the problem is they just don't scale well.
I can envision older warehouses in an industrial district being converted in to vacuum flywheel storage sites where power fed in to the grid earlier is buffered and then released back to it.
Changing our culture is another possible approach. Power is used in the evenings because that's when most people get off work/home/etc and they tend to have /that/ time to do cooking and cleaning (thermal cooling / heating are more solvable with changes in materials and building shape than culture change).
- pc2g4d 11y agoPrice electricity differently through the day according to its scarcity and people might eventually adjust their routines to reduce evening usage.
- derefr 11y agoThat seems backwards. The aggregate preferences and habits of humans should be seen as an incentivizing force for the creations of new technologies, not the other way around.
- msellout 11y agoYikes. Yes, of course technology is driven by human preferences. But, No, humans must occasionally accept that certain habits are not sustainable given current and near-future technologies.
- icanhackit 11y agoI generally agree with your position but in this particular scenario the people with the greatest capacity to adjust their behavior are the people who will be affected the least financially by a hike in peak prices and thus less likely to change or more likely to invest in solar at home, while those with the least flexibility in work arrangements and spending, e.g. lower income earners working in the services sector, will be affected negatively the most and unable to work around it.
- eru 11y agoIf the spot market was the status quo, and someone was suggesting a change to the current system of flat prices, one could make the same argument. (Ie already well off people are flexible enough to make use of the new system better.)
- msellout 11y agoMore variant pricing will better distribute usage. The unfortunate effects on the poor can be negated by a sales tax paid back to all citizens equally as a lump sum.
- yongjik 11y agoWell, in that case, pricing electricity differently through the day will encourage people to develop new technologies for cheaply generating and/or storing electricity for evening consumption peak.
- epistasis 11y agoThat's like saying market economies are backwards. We need to match resources to people somehow, and markets are a very popular way to do that fairly and efficiently. I'm not saying that markets should be unchecked but it's very strange to see such naked Marxism on this site.
- eru 11y agoI don't see any Marxism there. Marxism isn't just anti-market. It's a complex ideology.
- eru 11y agoIt's a two way street. Aggregating the preferences via price will drive new technology and business models.
- esturk 11y agoIt doesn't have to incentivize new technologies. It could just as easily incentivize new business models. Imagine a laundromat that sells "FREE DRYING" during the day. Heck, I bet you a lot more people will do laundry during the day time. Similarly, power companies can give incentives for more day time power usage. A lot of people already follow night time power usage today so its no reason to think it wouldn't work.
- SamReidHughes 11y agoVariable pricing would create those exact incentives.
- S_A_P 11y agoYou are correct- there are energy storage solutions out there, I should have clarified my statement above. The issue is that they cant store power grid levels of power in an efficient, compact, and scalable manner. This is the rub. Maintaining a giant battery bank or other measures require maintenance and large capital expenditures.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]