5 ms·
Being a manager at a large power company for 30 years is both an advantage and a disadvantage. For the past 30 years, the energy industry has changed incredibly
by epistasis 11y ago
Being a manager at a large power company for 30 years is both an advantage and a disadvantage. For the past 30 years, the energy industry has changed incredibly slowly, so ones expectations of what is possible in the way of innovation is far far lower than it should be.
The "duck curve" that your friend is referring to will be solved in a variety of ways, from wind to storage to HVDC interconnects to the rest of the nation, to peaker plants.
In the future, coal is dead. No need to build any more of it. Nuclear is too expensive to build anymore. (Unless somebody actually does thorium innovation, but I'm not holding my breath...)
When storing a kWh costs $0.10, and there's also adaptive pricing to match supply and demand better, these problems will melt away.
It does require a huge mental shift, but the cost savings will make that happen
- jobu 11y ago> When storing a kWh costs $0.10, and there's also adaptive pricing to match supply and demand better, these problems will melt away. If the math and assumptions in this article are correct, then that's exactly the (wholesale) price point Tesla is aiming for with the Powerwall: http://cleantechnica.com/2015/05/09/tesla-powerwall-powerblocks-per-kwh-lifetime-prices-vs-aquion-energy-eos-energy-imergy/ http://cleantechnica.com/2015/05/09/tesla-powerwall-powerblo... There are a couple other (not yet released) energy storage solutions mentioned there that might get the cost down even lower - Eos Aurora and Imergy Flow Battery
- ssmoot 11y agoIt'd take over 1 BILLION Powerwalls to store half the daily usage in the US (using old usage numbers off Wikipedia). I wonder if there's enough raw materials to make that realistic. And how to you manage recycling, repair, replacement, end-of-life concerns for all those batteries on that scale? Not asking a sarcastic hypothetical. Genuinely curious. It's hard to wrap my head around numbers that big. For reference I used this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_electricity_consumption https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_electrici..., divided it by days, then the Powerwall's 6.4kwh capacity and then halved that number. 4,686,400,000,000 / 365 / 6.4 / 2 == 1,003,082,191.8 Powerwalls.
- epistasis 11y agoJust throwing around "BILLION" doesn't make it seem big, you need to compare it the unit size. A single gigafactory is going to produce 35 GWh in a year, which is about 5.3 million power walls a year. If their lifespan is 10 years, than we need to produce 1e9 power walls / 10 years = 100 million powerwalls/year to maintain that capacity. So we'd only need 20 gigafactories worth to do this. And with wind and proper grid interconnects we won't even really need much storage at all to keep the electricity going; the national weather is very very consistent. We will need enough lithium for our ~300 million cars and their batteries, which are probably going to be 50-100kWh each, which is far far more than storing half a days worth of electricity.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoWhat if we used tens of millions of electric vehicles on the road as grid storage? Tesla has already planned on it: https://i.imgur.com/oLBNeW4.png https://i.imgur.com/oLBNeW4.png | https://i.imgur.com/pectzXn.png https://i.imgur.com/pectzXn.png
- ssmoot 11y agoThat's over 3 Powerwalls every second. And I've got to think you're not going to see more than 75% original capacity in ten years as a best case? I'm not as concerned about the factory as the supply chain, can we actually supply that much raw material, and what will mining it do to the environment? I assume lithium is much rarer than iron or copper. But I don't really know. For reference 16 million vehicles were sold in the US in 2013, but many (most?) of those were trucks and large SUVs, which AFAIK aren't on the roadmap for any EV manufacturer right now. And then there's fleet/work vehicles, single car families in states without long distance transportation or quick chargers (like TX). It makes me wonder if 20 years from now fuel cells won't completely obsolete batteries?
- gpm 11y agoThe number actually needed is a bit lower than that (I estimate half a billion), but the general question still stands. Variable electricity needs already mean we use less electricity at night time [0]. Shift electricity expensive processes preferentially run at night to the day and using 80%/120% seems like a reasonable rough approximation. So we need 4,686,400,000,000 / 365 / 2 * 0.8 ~= 513,5780,822 kwh in the '12 dark hours' Between current supplies nuclear hydro and wind we account for approximately 30% of electricity generation [1], on the assumption that electricity generation from these is constant, but can't be ramped up during the night, we get about 4,686,400,000,000 / 365 / 2 * 0.3 = 1,925,917,808 kwh. Leaving 3,209,863,014 kwh needed from storage, or 501,541,095 powerwalls. [0] http://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.cfm?id=13131 http://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.cfm?id=13131 [1] http://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.cfm?id=427&t=3 http://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.cfm?id=427&t=3
- coryfklein 11y ago> Being a manager at a large power company for 30 years is both an advantage and a disadvantage. He is definitely biased against solar, but is acutely aware of the costs it presents to traditional power generation and definitely well qualified to comment on them.
- epistasis 11y agoRight, and my point is kind of that the entrenched energy interests have been wrong time and again about solar, wind, and now storage. As well as HVDC. They don't understand these things, they see less than half of the equation because they don't want things to change, and they only see the problems and have no interest in solving them. IT wasn't that long ago that they were saying that solar was impossible, or that wind would never be affordable. They were wrong about that and they will be wrong about how difficult it is going to be to adapt to lots of intermittant renewable energy powering the grid. They will complain vociferously, and they may be able to talk about some of the difficulties, but we can't trust their perspective on the big picture.
- jimmcslim 11y ago> In the future, coal is dead. What about coking coal, for the production of steel from iron ore?
- tdyen 11y agoI've heard the claim it's indespensible but that's not true from a chemical point of view. But possibly from an economic point of view.
- eru 11y agoNuclear could be made cheaper (even with Uranium) by updating regulations. Fission plants are held to a much higher standards of safety in terms of eg decrease in quality adjusted life-years per Gigawatthour than any other form of producing electricity. Even solar. (Though most deaths and injuries from solar come from people slipping off their roof when installing residential capacity. If memory serves right.)
- kazagistar 11y agoThe problem is they have a huge spinup and spindown cost. So as long as we have solar, we need power that we can use at those times when solar is unavailable.
- Spooky23 11y agoA nuclear plant today would cost something like $6B that's not a regulatory tweak. The problem with nuclear is waste disposal (still not figured out, and a will be a problem for decades/centuries after the plant is closed) and amortization of billions of capital costs. With the price disruption potential of other technology, it's a bad bet, and has been so for many years.
- jessaustin 11y agoNuclear was only ever "viable" for political reasons. We had to have enough nuclear weapons to extinguish mammalian life nineteen times over. Eighteen times would have been pathetic. It was all a boondoggle anyway, so the war pigs were happy to spread a bit of cash on the civilian side...
- pyre 11y agoThere are nuclear plants that generate isotopes for medical purposes.
- jessaustin 11y agoThose are not the same plants that generate power for the grid.