15 ms·
There's, at this point, nothing to worry about. The insanely dedicated people who maintain the ad blocking lists are the real heroes here, the client that uses
by Spivak 11y ago
There's, at this point, nothing to worry about. The insanely dedicated people who maintain the ad blocking lists are the real heroes here, the client that uses them is completely replaceable.
If/When ABP goes over to the dark side people will stop using it. There are plenty of replacements, uBlock Origin being the current winner.
- Fundlab 11y agoIs it impossible to deliver ads natively ie serve ads directly from the publisher's platform instead of 3rd party? How do you skirts ad blocking applications without triggering an inconvenience on your readers?
- ascagnel_ 11y agouBlock and it's ilk let you flag pieces of the DOM to block. I use it to block clutter on webpages as well as ad slots. Compare [0] (with DOM-based blocking) to [1] (without). [0]: http://i.imgur.com/5hlPhqx.jpg http://i.imgur.com/5hlPhqx.jpg [1]: http://i.imgur.com/TrxMlkz.jpg http://i.imgur.com/TrxMlkz.jpg
- paulmd 11y agoI normally surf with uBlock Origin and most of the filters turned on (anything that's not experimental or a subset of a larger filter), and I get a shock every now and then when I use a browser without filtering and see what the internet has turned into. What the shit, that looks nothing like the Guardian that I am used to seeing. Youtube ads are a real shocker too. About the only time I ever actually notice advertising is when some site sets up an aggressive anti-adblock or airs 2 minutes of dead air where an ad spot would have gone.
- danieldk 11y agoI normally surf with uBlock Origin and most of the filters turned on (anything that's not experimental or a subset of a larger filter), and I get a shock every now and then when I use a browser without filtering and see what the internet has turned into. Indeed! I got this experience every time I used Chrome (rather than Firefox) on Android. The web has become quite horrible. I am now back on iOS and the author of uBlock has made a great blocker for Safari on iOS: https://www.purify-app.com/ https://www.purify-app.com/
- Raed667 11y agoIt is possible, but it requires that ads people trust publishers. Otherwise publishers will just say they served a million ad that day, and cash on it without any proof. Everyone is putting their own tracker in the ads because they can't trust other people data (unless you're Google or Facebook, or other giant)
- losteric 11y agoAds themselves are an inconvenience on readers. It's possible for a website owner to directly publish ads, and those ads would be harder to block (but still trivial). Site owners trade screen real estate in exchange for ad revenue, just like billboards of old. This used to be the model in the early 2000s and I actually OK with it... though it probably wasn't the best model, a bit like running a diner on revenue from ads in the menu. The problem is centralized publishers. They offer higher revenue through highly targeting ads from thousands of advertisers. It's a race to the bottom where all websites are incentivized to use publishers and consumers are forced to use ad blocking tools against the publishers (hurting content creators)... undermining the long-term sustainability of the internet as a content publishing medium. As with many things, both consumers and producers are acting justifiably. It's the man in the middle that needs to go. He's just skimming a short-term profit and hurting both sides in the long-run.
- cookiecaper 11y agoIt is still not clear to me whether uBlock or uBlock Origin should be preferred. It seems that the original author of uBlock had a falling out with some contributors and decided to fork it and go do his own thing his own way with uBo. People assert that this makes it "better", but I'm not sure. I've tried both and they do appear to have substantially differing featuresets. Can anyone finally clarify the situation, and the pros/cons of each?
- deprave 11y agoUse uBlock Origin, see my other post. The author of uBlock Origin makes it clear that no donations are sought for the development of the extension. That is not the case with the other version.
- cookiecaper 11y agoYour post (here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11622316 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11622316) seems to address ABP v. uBo, not uBo v. uB. Furthermore, non-solicitation of donations is a political reason to prefer uBo. I'm curious about the technical reasons. As a side note, I personally have no problem whatsoever with an extension creator soliciting donations as long as they're not doing so in a deceptive or annoying manner.
- AdmiralAsshat 11y agoThe donations are what caused the rift: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UBlock_Origin#uBlock_.28ublock.org.29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UBlock_Origin#uBlock_.28ublock...
- cookiecaper 11y agoI understand that a political issue is what drove them apart originally. However, people continually assert that uBlock Origin is the better extension. Is there anyone who has done an objective, non-political comparison of their featuresets and/or technical properties to really evaluate which one is superior for end users? I can say anecdotally, that I found plain uBlock more featureful for everyday usage, but I haven't done a thorough review. I currently use uBlock Origin.
- deprave 11y agoABP already is part of the dark side with their "acceptable ads." It boggles the mind why a program whose sole purpose is to block ads would not do so out of the box. Anyone who hasn't yet switched to uBlock Origin should do so ASAP. It's super fast, has a much smaller memory footprint, has a strict policy against "acceptable ads" (https://github.com/gorhill/uBlock/blob/master/MANIFESTO.md https://github.com/gorhill/uBlock/blob/master/MANIFESTO.md), licensed under the GPLv3, and hosted in a very active repository on GitHub (https://github.com/gorhill/uBlock https://github.com/gorhill/uBlock).
- coldpie 11y agoI've never understood the backlash against the acceptable ads program. They state clearly what policies the ads must adhere to, and review them manually for compliance. Sure, if viewing absolutely no advertising is important to you, then you'll want to turn that feature off or use a different client. But why do you think they're part of the "dark side" for trying to encourage inoffensive ads?
- deprave 11y agoBecause of the default setting that shows ads in a program called "ad block."
- coldpie 11y agoYour definition of "dark side" seems borderline sociopathic.
- deprave 11y agoBoth the Interactive Advertising Bureau and Ghostery accused ABP of extortion due to their business practices. A program that labels itself as an "ad blocker" yet allows, by default, ads from companies who pay money, is part of the dark side.
- basch 11y agogood thing they didnt name it "completely ad block"
- jessriedel 11y ago> The insanely dedicated people who maintain the ad blocking lists are the real heroes here, the client that uses them is completely replaceable. Who are these people and why do they do it? The wikipedia article on uBlock Origin didn't help much.
- kozhevnikov 11y agohttps://easylist.github.io/pages/about.html https://easylist.github.io/pages/about.html
- FussyZeus 11y agoThe performance bump alone sold me on uBlock. Switched a year or so ago and never looked back.
- coolsunglasses 11y agoABP have been extortionists for years. They'll let anybody show the ads they want as long as they pay protection.
- kobayashi 11y agoWho are those dedicated individuals?