14 ms·
I'm apparently in the minority, but, after reading the article, I still maintain that there is never a reason to steal from your fellow man. The potential for a
by stronglikedan 11y ago
I'm apparently in the minority, but, after reading the article, I still maintain that there is never a reason to steal from your fellow man. The potential for abuse due to hunger being subjective notwithstanding, there are social programs in place to accommodate the needy. Do they not have these programs in Italy? I am a very compassionate, empathetic (to a fault) person, but I just don't see the justification for the theft. Ask me for help, and I'm there, but please don't steal from me and think that it's okay. I am, however, open to enlightenment.
- rootlocus 11y agoBeggars ask for help in the streets, but I personally can't help each and every one of them. You may be sympathetic, but how is the homeless man supposed to find you when he needs your help?
- sethhochberg 11y agoIn theory that is the whole point of taxpayer funded support programs... we can't all be there, but we do all pay taxes for the specific purpose of having a better society (including things like food banks, soup kitchens, etc for people in need).
- celticninja 11y agoFood banks and soup kitchens are predominantly provided by charities and religions. Not by tax payers. I would encourage you to look up what welfare is available for people like this in your local area to ascertain how much {if any] is tax payer funded.
- WalterSear 11y agoIn theory, sure.
- KingMob 11y agoAnd in America, the amount of those taxes set aside for feeding the hungry is below the required amount to cover everyone.
- protomyth 11y agoI would need to see the actual data on that because that is definitely not my experience with social programs in the US. There is money in the federal programs for the US even not counting private organizations and states. You don't actually have to provide income information when you first sign up for commodities programs these days (it is required later), and EBT provides a fair amount. Shelter is the bigger concern than food for US poor. We really need to look at the whole idea of housing. Training money is there, but its pretty useless without proper shelter and transportation systems.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> In theory that is the whole point of taxpayer funded support programs... we can't all be there, but we do all pay taxes for the specific purpose of having a better society (including things like food banks, soup kitchens, etc for people in need). Presumably, any legal finding of necessity by a judge is based on an awareness of an existence of these programs, such as they may be in the applicable jurisdiction, and a determination that they were not, in fact, sufficient to meet the need in the specific circumstance at issue. The existence of a government program intended in theory as a general solution to a problem does not logically imply (and, in fact, often falls very short in practice) that the problem is, in fact, adequately and sufficiently addressed in all concrete cases. > but we do all pay taxes for the specific purpose of having a better society (including things like food banks, soup kitchens, etc for people in need). And also including judges that review the specific circumstances of particular cases brought before them.
- nowprovision 11y agoI bet you've been pretty privileged in grand scheme of things, university, regular jobs, maybe the lowest point has been backpacking etc... Parent have at least one car, yawn yawn yawn.. No one is stealing from you, they are stealing from a supermarket. Privileged people always seem to think in black and white, theft is theft never an excuse blah blah, quite often making the cliche mistake of associating morality with legality.. I hope one day you don't need to learn this ain't always correlated..
- hueving 11y agoDiscursive ad hominem, yawn. Discuss the implications of theft being okay if you are hungry, not the background of the person who suggested they disagree with that notion.
- RodericDay 11y ago> Discursive ad hominem, yawn. What kind of environment do you partake in discourse in that this kind of condescending contribution is acceptable? It sounds like you're taking your cues from the Comic Guy from The Simpsons. "Tu quoque? yawn".
- homogeneous 11y agoThe "yawn" is a bit flippant, but I don't see why it's condescending, he's absolutely correct. Your comic book guy reference seems to suggest that you think he's using big words to sound smart or something, but it seems like a pretty cogent response to a post that completely skips over the substance of the topic at hand and parades around unqualified assumptions about the poster as an argument.
- hueving 11y agoIt was a direct response to the "yawn, yawn, yawn" in the parent. If someone is going to behave like a asshole, they don't deserve much better as a response IMO. Life is too short.
- ixtli 11y ago
- luso_brazilian 11y agoSome context from the article: > Judges overturned a theft conviction against Roman Ostriakov after he stole cheese and sausages worth €4.07 (£3; $4.50) from a supermarket. > Mr Ostriakov, a homeless man of Ukrainian background, had taken the food "in the face of the immediate and essential need for nourishment", the court of cassation decided. > Therefore it was not a crime, it said. (...) > In 2015, Mr Ostriakov was convicted of theft and sentenced to six months in jail and a €100 fine. Italian judicial system "does not try anybody by a jury of peers: everyone is judged by professional judges or by a panel of judges" [1]. Thus, the compassion reserved to the jury of peers (in the form of Jury Nullification) in systems like the american one would be absent from the Italian one if not for actions like the one by this judge. Not going to enter in the merit of the cause itself (as it's very subjective and personal experience can affect the judgement) but I agree that the judicial system can and must apply discretion in its judgements. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Italian_Code_of_Criminal_Procedure#Judges_of_the_trial https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Italian_Code_of_Criminal_Proce...
- ergo14 11y agoThat makes no sense for me. It IS a crime, however one that court could rule to not punish the convicted. At least that is how it would probably work in my country.
- dragonwriter 11y agoMany legal systems recognize a defense of necessity (either personal or in the service of others) against things that would otherwise be crimes (often in a general way, not defined explicitly as part of each crime), rendering them not crimes when done out of necessity meeting the applicable legal standard. So, this isn't that odd.
- kpil 11y agoYes. You are allowed to drive under the influence of alcohol if you are trying to save someones life. Or even shoot someone, as long as you could reasonably expect that your or someone else life was in danger. Even if it turns out that there was no real danger, for instance you where threatened with an unloaded or even a fake gun. If you are very hungry, and steel a sausage, the crime compared to the need is very low.
- dimino 11y agoAgreed -- I think we should, as neediness increases, lower the penalties per a judge's discretion, but I don't think we should ever completely eliminate the criminal aspect of theft. There is room in a justice system to convict a person of a crime without punishing that person in any meaningful way.
- vidarh 11y agoA conviction is in itself substantial punishment most places.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Agreed -- I think we should, as neediness increases, lower the penalties per a judge's discretion, but I don't think we should ever completely eliminate the criminal aspect of theft. We certainly complete eliminate the criminality of intentional homicide when there is sufficient need. Seems to me, that the case for doing so for mere theft of chattels is much stronger. (Also, note that this is separate from the issue of whether or not conversion of chattels ought always to be a tort creating a debt for compensation from the taker to the one deprived, which should be resolved through whatever system a jurisdiction has for the resolution of debts and which may requiring repayment when the taker is capable, with interest, unless the debt is qualified for discharge, e.g., through bankruptcy or similar proceedings. But that's a different issue than criminality.)
- eveningcoffee 11y agoI think you are right! We should provide aid for people who are in danger of starvation, but it does not give anybody right to steal from fellow human. I have a personal experience with possible abuse. I saw a man, probably a foreign (so he is probably not supposed to be familiar with local aid system), with a sign that he needs money for food because he is starving and he indeed did not look alright. After considering the situation (well, to be honest he can be pretending), I decided to give the man 10 euros because if he really is starving, he should not stay there to collect small coins, but also as a test, such that he could be given further directions when he really is in need. So, he took the money, hid it and continued his act.
- mbillie1 11y agoAs though 10 euros is enough to satisfy his hunger in perpetuity? Do you quit your job and stop working when you have 10 euros in the bank, or do you put it away and try to accumulate more? This "anecdote" is pretty short-sighted.
- eveningcoffee 11y agoStarving means that you have not eaten several days and are in desperate need for food immediately. 10 should give you an opinion to end this situation. If you choose not to then the changes are that you were actually not starving. Of course, like I told, this is a case of possible abuse. I have no idea what was actually going on.
- stronglikedan 11y agoI usually don't have cash, but if someone comes up to me in a parking lot of a store, I offer to take them in and purchase food for them on my credit card. They sometimes accept the offer, but the majority don't.
- coldtea 11y ago>After considering the situation (well, to be honest he can be pretending), I decided to give the man 10 euros because if he really is starving, he should not stay there to collect small coins, but also as a test, such that he could be given further directions when he really is in need. Not much experience with being poor/homeless, have we? For those not faking it (which can happen too), a "starving" sign doesn't mean "I'm literally starving right now, I just need a few dollars for a burger and I'll be on my way". It means I can't support myself, I'm dead-poor, and probably homeless, and can use all the money thrown at me to get by for a few days.
- ino 11y agoWhen you're starving and alone, you're not the same person. You can feel the civility, bon-ton and good education vanishing, you don't even think about it. People will give you food if they see you in this state. If you can't get it any other way, you will steal.
- Fuxy 11y agoSurvival and civility are not compatible. Until you have been forced to the brink of dying from starvation you will not understand. It's quite simple when you think about it would you rather die in the streets from lack of food or go into a supermarket and take some to live another day hell even if you get caught you go to prison where you get fed. There's no point in punishing these people the punishment is actually better then their current situation and any fines etc that you give them they will never be able to pay anyway all that does it prevent them from improving their situation since whenever they will start recovering a bit the debt collectors will show up to knock them down. Besides being a cruel and unusual punishment for someone trying to better their lives it's not good for the economy either.
- fosco 11y agojust to add.....it is not uncommon in certain cities for homeless to break windows or steal with the intention of getting caught as the weather gets extreme... for the sole purpose of having a 'comfortable'(everything is relative) jail to sleep in.
- adharmad 11y agoThere is an O'Henry short story on this exact theme: "The Cop and the Anthem"
- jemfinch 11y ago> I'm apparently in the minority, but, after reading the article, I still maintain that there is never a reason to steal from your fellow man. The Catholic Church would agree: stealing is intrinsically evil, and thus wrong always and everywhere. The way they handle situations like this is by defining "stealing when starving" as "not stealing at all, but reappropriating things according to God's design for them." They call this the "universal destination of goods": §2408 The seventh commandment forbids theft, that is, usurping another's property against the reasonable will of the owner. There is no theft if consent can be presumed or if refusal is contrary to reason and the universal destination of goods. This is the case in obvious and urgent necessity when the only way to provide for immediate, essential needs (food, shelter, clothing . . .) is to put at one's disposal and use the property of others. In other words, the right to private property does not trump the right to life.
- estefan 11y ago> The Catholic Church... are in no position to lecture anyone on morals. Read "The God Delusion" if this isn't abundantly apparent to you from studying history and/or reading the news.
- DanielStraight 11y agoJust in case it's not clear, you're getting downvotes because you are making an ad hominem argument rather than a logical rebuttal of the previous post. "Organization X is wrong about A, therefore they are wrong about B," is never a logically valid proposition. In fact, nothing about organization X is relevant when determining if their propositions are correct.
- estefan 11y agoIf "Organisation X" has acted in a morally corrupt and hypocritical manner for thousands of years, as far as I'm concerned it would be entirely irrelevant what their so called "morals" are. Therefore referencing them at all in this discussion is equally irrelevant.
- 11y ago
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- pizza 11y agoIt is probably slightly less wrong to steal for food when starving than it is to withhold food from a starving fellow human.
- steego 11y ago> I still maintain that there is never a reason to steal from your fellow man. * Stealing something back * Stealing Hitler's secret plans * Stealing a portion of everybody's property/income, but providing vital protection, infrastructure and social services in return. * Stealing the heart of a girl from a guy who abuses her. * Stealing land from the commons to efficiently put it to work * Stealing land at market value to create a public works project that benefits the rest of society In all seriousness, property rights are a critical component if you want to have a highly functioning economy, but as soon as you try to moralize the idea like it's a sacrosanct moral imperative (even at the expense of hungry people), you begin to sound like a foolish ideologue. The reason you sound like a foolish ideologue is because different moral ideas can very easily find themselves in opposition in common circumstances. If a situation forced you to choose between compassion and property rights (Maybe you're asked to steal a life saving medicine for someone else in dire need), which do you choose? Morally speaking, does property rights actually trump compassion, or do we let property rights trump compassion because that idea scales up to large societies better? Property rights is a critically important idea that helps to serve a society. It's not an end unto its own, nor is it an unimpeachable moral imperative.
- arethuza 11y agoThese kinds of discussions always make me think of this story: "A Scottish miner was walking home one night with a bunch of pheasants he had poached from a local landowner's estate when the landowner appeared and demanded that the miner hand over the pheasants. "Why should I hand them over to you?", asked the miner. "Because this is my land and those are my pheasants", the landowner replied. "OK", said the miner, "where did you get the land from?" "From my father", said the landowner. "So where did your father get it?", the miner asked. The landowner replied: "From his father, who got it from his father, and so on. This land has belonged to my family for 500 years!" "Well", the miner continued, "how did your family get it 500 years ago?" "Oh, they fought for it", answered the landowner. "OK then", the miner said, "take off your jacket and I'll fight you for it!" NB I first read this in The Poor had No Lawyers - described as "how this country was stolen from its people": http://www.andywightman.com/poor-had-no-lawyers http://www.andywightman.com/poor-had-no-lawyers
- coldtea 11y ago>I'm apparently in the minority, but, after reading the article, I still maintain that there is never a reason to steal from your fellow man So, never been homeless, poor and hungry, I presume? Here's some Brecht for you: You gentlemen who think you have a mission To purge us of the seven deadly sins Should first sort out the basic food position Then start your preaching, that's where it begins You lot, who preach restraint and watch your waist as well Should learn, for once, the way the world is run However much you twist, or whatever lies that you tell Food is the first thing, morals follow on
- pasquinelli 11y agoor billie holiday: You've got to have something to eat and a little love in your life before you can hold still for any damn body's sermon on how to behave.
- VLM 11y agoFinancial taxation of all forms and levels. Expensive government regulations. Participating in a market with a government tolerated monopoly. Ownership of land under zoning board control (essentially all land). Licensing fees on titled registered personal property (cars, boats, homes). Benefiting from government services (national defense, police, maybe some day medical care, all the way down to welfare) without having first paid your share in taxes. Any service ever provided to disabled or handicapped people, unless they were really rich and paid a lot of taxes before the accident. Public education either in schools or libraries. The "public" airwaves. Theft, all of it. By definition the only people playing the game, are those willing to hold their nose and wade into the cesspool anyway. Nobody currently in the cesspool can seriously convince anyone that they really thought they were wading into a Randian utopian swimming pool, they knew what they were getting into. Given that intentional acceptance of the situation they're voluntarily a part of, a bag of crackers isn't much of an additional theft. Deal with it. What is likely to happen, is when I was a kid cigarette cartons were like $10 and out on shelves for anyone to steal, but why would anyone steal a $10 carton of cigs? Now they're like $80 per carton and locked up in closets until after payment is made. So there will be changes in supermarket operations. Oh well, disruption happens.
- vidarh 11y ago> I am a very compassionate, empathetic (to a fault) person, but I just don't see the justification for the theft. I find it impossible to reconcile the two parts of this sentence. To me, there is nothing compassionate about even prosecuting a case like this. I understand that people don't want to be stolen from. Of course not. Nobody wants that. We all want better alternatives. But the world isn't perfect. To me saying there is "never a reason to steal" is equivalent to saying you value property over someones life. To me, that is cold and callous. No, that does not mean I think it would be good for hordes of starving people to descent on shops. But if the alternative if starvation, then society has a problem. And theft is the smaller part of that problem.
- pasquinelli 11y agowould a person who's starving to death ever follow a law preventing them from taking food? i can't believe they would. in fact, i think if a person starved to death when they could've just walked into a grocery story and gotten plenty to eat must have had something deeply wrong with them. i don't even think it's a matter of choice. so such a law is at odds with reality. and consider what the consequences are for the theft. maybe they get a fine. they won't pay it, of course, because they can't even pay for food. then the fines accumulate, which has no immediate effect on the thief and does nothing to stop them thieving, because if they can't pay for food then they can't pay a fine, no matter how much they owe. on the other had, they may, eventually, be thrown in prison for their crimes, where they'll get fed on the regular, which is practically encouragement to commit crimes. you could also kill them, but i feel that's problematic. if you don't punish the thief at all then, in the off chance they have the chance to get back on their feet, they won't have a pile of debt keeping them down, they won't have a criminal record because they were starving, and they won't be dead.
- bayesian_horse 11y agoIt's not explicitly stating that stealing while hungry is moral, it's just that modern justice systems are not set up for "deterring" people from survival. Nor would that be moral, either.
- fldrcr 11y agoIt's not about morality or property rights... Of course the man stole food. And when he gets caught he will go to jail where he will have a cover over his head, resemblance of a bed, and free meals... This is a case of economics. The courts are ruling they no longer want to foot the bill, send the homeless man back to the streets and let him beg, feed, and steal from the businesses.
- js2 11y agoJudiasm has the concept of ”Pikuach nefesh” which essentially commands that saving a life overrides almost all other considerations: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pikuach_nefesh https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pikuach_nefesh According to one source: ...The dominant view in Jewish law ... allows a person to steal or damage property of another to save his own life. Thus, one may break in to the house of another, or steal insulin if that was necessary to save his life. However, such a person must compensate the owner of the property. http://www.jlaw.com/Articles/ch_stealsavelife.html http://www.jlaw.com/Articles/ch_stealsavelife.html This source also says about American law: The issue is not whether a person can steal or destroy property to save his life or the life of others since it is accepted in American law that such an action is permissible. The issue is whether such a person must compensate the owner if he did not create the danger. There are few cases directly on point but the weight of such cases conflict with the position taken by sections 197 and 263 of the Restatements. These cases and the doctrines of admiralty law support the contention that when neither the actor nor those whose lives are saved are legally at fault for placing themselves in the perilous position from which they can only be saved by destroying the property of another, they bear no legal liability for destroying that property.
- kenko 11y agoSo compassionate and empathetic that you're concerned about people abusing this because of the subjectivity of hunger!
- dllthomas 11y agoMy views on the matter are complicated and probably a bit conflicted. But for a cute presentation of a particular alternate viewpoint: http://blog.ninapaley.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/08/NA_InventionOfWork_960.jpg http://blog.ninapaley.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/08/NA_Inve...