3 ms·
Ask HN: Assassination Robots
Looks like slow news day to me, so I have a question to the HN community.
Last week there was a story about a hit team in Dubai that got tracked from multiple CCTV cameras as they did their job. It was a large team and performed a very-well coordinated assassination.
It occurs to me that such hit jobs with big teams are a thing of the past due to constant surveillance, and we've probably seen the last one. That means that a shift might be coming, with lower-cost disruptive technology doing the work that highly-trained paramilitary people used to do.
We're already seeing a lot of recon being done by man-portable UAVs in Iraq and Afghanistan. In addition, we're seeing some very complex IEDs being created by insurgents using off-the-shelf technology.
So, without getting into the politics of assassination, what do you guys think the next step in technology will be? Small UAVs with sniper rifles? Pre-positioned automated sniper rifles? Robot bombs disguised to look like ordinary street items?
If speculating makes you uncomfortable please don't participate, and I'm not crazy about working all the bugs out of these ideas, but I am interested in what sorts of unique ways you guys can come up with for whacking somebody. Note that effectiveness and anonymity are the scoring criteria. And let's stipulate that the goal has to be to whack one person with a very low chance of whacking anybody else by accident, so IED's aren't going to work.
- Semiapies 17y agoI think your premise is wrong - constant surveillance did jack-all to prevent this assassination and will continue to be little deterrent. Surveillance doesn't often detect crimes/attacks before or even during their commission. It's primarily good for piecing events together after-the-fact. Until behavior-analysis and/or facial recognition become ready for primetime so that a hotel security's gets an alert saying, "possible organized covert activity by these people", such operations will only continue.
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoReally? I was under the impression that something like 25 agents had their covers blown by having their pictures in every major newspaper in the world. If the Israelis did it (which looks very likely), they sure are acting like it was a major disaster for their intelligence services. There have been calls for people to resign, editorials about what went wrong, etc. The problem as I read it is that this was conducted like a military operation -- probably very similar to the way operations are conducted in the Gaza strip. Only in a modern western city, you leave a lot more dirt behind you than you do in a poor slum somewhere. That's just what I've gathered from half a dozen articles or so, though. Perhaps you are right: perhaps these same guys can be effective in other operations. I doubt it, though.
- johngunderman 17y agoThis Scheier article discusses how useless security cameras were/are in cases such as the recent assassination. Its a good read. http://www.schneier.com/essay-309.html http://www.schneier.com/essay-309.html
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoNyah. Not so good a read, unfortunately. Scheier is making a case about CCTV cameras being effective at preventing crime. If you're organizing a hit, it's not the same as knocking off a liquor store. Completely different scenario. Look at it this way: the CCTV cameras got enough of the faces of the agents to blow their cover. That means that facial recognition software, which is being used to scan passport photos, can easily pick up these guys if they try to travel anywhere to do it again. They lost all the resources that went into training 25 people; all for one hit. Sure the cameras aren't going to prevent the assassination, but that's not the danger to teams like this. discovery is. Look at it this way: countries will always have the ability to assassinate people in other countries. The question is whether or not you can insert a large team and act precisely, or if you have to use a car bomb or cruise missile. If the only thing you have to be precise is large specialized teams, and border agents all know the identities of your teams, you're out of business. Here's a better link (I think) http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748704479404575087621440351704.html?mod=WSJ_LifeStyle_LeadStoryNA http://online.wsj.com/article/SB1000142405274870447940457508...
- Semiapies 17y ago"Really?" Is the target dead? Were they stopped? Really. "I was under the impression that something like 25 agents had their covers blown by having their pictures in every major newspaper in the world." And their names are...? Considering that a number of analysts point out that the involved people appeared aware of, but not concerned by, the security cameras, it seems unlikely that any exposure was unexpected.
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoConsidering that a number of analysts point out that the involved people appeared aware of, but not concerned by, the security cameras, it seems unlikely that any exposure was unexpected. I think that's the key question. From what I've heard, the assumption is that they never expected the Dubai authorities to connect up all the videos. After all, the hit was staged to look like a natural death. Remember the goal isn't just to kill the guy. It's to kill him preferably by making it look like a natural death and definitely by not getting your face on the nightly news. Ideally nobody ever suspects anything so nobody goes back and pieces together the video.