12 ms·
To make it work you'd have to take whatever the amount is and extract it from all other government benefit programs. You get $700 / month from the government f
by brightball 11y ago
To make it work you'd have to take whatever the amount is and extract it from all other government benefit programs.
You get $700 / month from the government for basic income. Your social security, welfare, unemployment, disability, etc is reduced by $700 / month. Reducing all of those programs by the first $700 would effectively gut each of them enough to finally make some reforms without inducing panic in everyone who uses them.
If you were to implement the Fair Tax, which includes a stipend for basic needs, you'd get bipartisan support as well. The only difference is that you increase the stipend to the level of the BI.
For kids, you give the parents their basic income until they hit school age and then the BI goes towards funding their school. This would also enable people who wanted to utilize private schools a much easier choice by essentially becoming a voucher.
No loan could utilize the BI as security...except for student loans. That would allow driving down of interest rates as well as default aversion too. Payments could be automatically extract from the BI since student loans would finally be secured against something other that expected future earnings.
- goda90 11y agoOr instead, give it universally to children, but require a certain percentage be saved in some sort of fund that they are given full control of when they turn 18. That way the parents don't have to shoulder all of the expense of a child, but the child isn't screwed over by irresponsible parents either.
- brightball 11y agoWhen they turn 18 they are already going to have access to the BI. I'm not sure of the benefit of a fund rather than directing it to school funding. Prior to school it would allow parents to pay for daycare, diapers, food and subsidize paternity/maternity leave.
- nojvek 11y agoI know of folks who end up many kids to maximize on the welfare per kid. Can you really trust all parents? I've seen some abuse of welfare in my days in Australia.
- Unklejoe 11y agoCool idea. I'd advocate for an age of 25 though. An 18 year old these days is still a child. Give them a couple years into the drinking age to get their bad decisions out of the way.
- cujo 11y agoSounds like you should advocated for a drinking age of 25 instead. Or move all those other things you get to do at 18 to 25 also.
- PietdeVries 11y agoLet me know when you have this thing in place: I will start a "Spring Break Holiday Park" somewhere in the south where beer is $20 and a Rum&Coke goes for $40. Only people from 25 are allowed in.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Unklejoe 11y agoI think we should actually lower the drinking age. It's currently 21 here. In fact, being 18 really gains you nothing here other than the ability to join the military and get into trouble with the law. My main point is that a few years should go by after a child enters into the adult world before they have access to a fund left for them. There's usually a short "reckless" period immediately after graduating high school and college. However, this usually calms down after the initial shock of having sudden freedom wears off. I have two friends who inhereted $20,000+ sums of money from relatives when they were in their late teens, and both of them pissed it away in under a year. Looking back, both of them seem to regret it. (Me and my friends are all around 25 years old).
- slavik81 11y ago> I have two friends who inhereted $20,000+ sums of money from relatives when they were in their late teens, and both of them pissed it away in under a year. Looking back, both of them seem to regret it. Would they have learned that lesson without making that mistake? Are you even sure they really wouldn't do the same again? To quote Time, "About 70 percent of people who suddenly receive a windfall of cash will lose it within a few years, according to the National Endowment for Financial Education." Just to make the anecdotes match the statistics, I inherented roughly 30k. It remained in my education fund until I finished undergrad. At 22, I opened an investment account. It's been paying dividends for the better part of a decade now.
- notahacker 11y agoWhy would you get bipartisan support for the FairTax? Redesigning the tax structure to favour millionaires (massive net beneficiaries because their US consumption expenditure is usually a tiny fraction of their capital gains tax and/or income tax bills) over the middle classes (no matter how high the stipend is someone has to pay for the millionaires' tax cut) isn't exactly a popular proposal even on the right That said, agree with your main point that making BI deductible from [mostly] retained existing benefit entitlements is the least messy way of introducing it, but it also makes it more politically difficult since it's paid for purely by tax increases.
- criley2 11y agoPoster is crazy to think liberals will EVER support a hugely regressive tax scheme. Consumption taxes destroy the middle class by acting as vehicle to transport wealth from the middle to the ultrawealthy, which makes it surprising that people continue to suggest it. Now perhaps a consumption tax combined with a large capital gains tax and inheritance tax -- to keep taxes going in the oligarchs economy AND the regular economy, and prevent capital from being tied up between generations in the least productive way possible, then you might get some of them on board.
- clarkmoody 11y agoWhat about the consumption taxes we have on the books? Gas tax? Hugely regressive. Wouldn't liberals support additional carbon taxes? Value-added tax? Wouldn't those continue to "destroy the middle class"? What about the tax of inflation that serves to redistribute wealth from savers to debtors? (middle class -> government) Also interesting how you know better than others how they should arrange their financial lives. Would like to hear your thoughts on the "productive ways" the "oligarchs" could better deploy their capital.
- marknutter 11y agoOr cigarettes? Or lottery tickets? Or the AMA penalty?
- 11y ago
- throwanem 11y ago> You get $700 / month from the government for basic income. I thought the idea was that it be enough to live on.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- skybrian 11y agoDoesn't have to be. You could start it out any level. That might be better, giving the system time to adjust.
- brightball 11y agoDepending where you live 'enough to live on' will vary. I lived on about $700 / month pretty happily for 4 years in college. Doesn't need to be a desirable long term amount but it does need to solve the problem of the unemployment trade off, namely that if you're getting unemployment and you get a job you lose it. A BI needs to simply ensure that you have a base level and if you get some work, you make more money...period.
- ThrustVectoring 11y agoIMO social security is too much of a hot button issue to touch. I'd market UBI as "social security for everyone" - that sets both the level that people get, and neatly removes the issue of giving both UBI and social security to retirees.
- dragonwriter 11y ago>I'd market UBI as "social security for everyone" - that sets both the level that people get No, it doesn't. Social security isn't a fixed amount, its based on prior earnings, adjusted by a wage index since the time they were earned, put through formula to get a base benefit amount in the year you start drawing them, and then inflation adjusted after retirement. So calling a UBI "Social Security for everyone" does not, in fact, tell you what the benefit amount would be -- if the benefit amount is calculated anything like Social Security, the program is nothing like a UBI.
- ThrustVectoring 11y agoSorry, I wasn't as clear about the plan as I could have been. To be more specific, I'd set UBI at a level that everyone who is currently getting Social Security based on age would rather switch to getting UBI instead. Then I'd discontinue SS and call the UBI program "Social Security", and pretend that I didn't get rid of the entire SS program. Wrap that change up as a package deal along with taxes to fund it, and call it "Social Security for Everyone".
- forgotmysn 11y agoim not sure people are happy enough with the implementation of social security to be sold with that premise. id sell it as a solution to social security, rather than an expansion of it
- dragonwriter 11y ago> If you were to implement the Fair Tax, which includes a stipend for basic needs, you'd get bipartisan support as well. No, you wouldn't. Flat tax proposals and national sales tax proposals like the "FairTax", have support almost exclusively on the right (and each particular such proposal has minority support on the right.) You won't get bipartisan support for any of them.
- nightski 11y agoJust to be clear however, the Fair Tax and a Flat tax are very different things that would have wildly different consequences to different people.
- brightball 11y agoI've noticed an increasing number of friends who are very left leaning, promoting the Fair Tax lately. Most of the issue with support for Fair Tax is that it's enough of an overhaul that people believe it to be an unrealistic pipe dream, which is may well be. One of the big perks of the Fair Tax is that it makes it easier for people to pay off debt and would actually encourage it. That gets a lot of support from many different angles.
- MikeHolman 11y agoBoth flat tax and sales tax disproportionately tax the poor. The very rich spend less money relative to how much they make, which puts higher burden on the poor than with our progressive tax. Flat fax is bad, because 40% of the guy making 20k per year is going to severely change quality of like. 40% from the guy making $40 million has much less impact on his quality of life. This is the whole reason for having a progressive tax... Impact of money on quality of life doesn't work on a linear scale, so neither should our taxes.
- T2_t2 11y agoIf the rich paid taxes... That's the missing element, not paying. As much as IN THEORY I agree with these ideas, in practice, rich people find all sorts of ways to not pay tax.
- prostoalex 11y ago> You get $700 / month from the government for basic income. Your social security, welfare, unemployment, disability, etc is reduced by $700 / month. What happens to Medicare under that scenario? Some medical procedures, particularly for old people, can exceed that. Current federal government revenues top out at $3 trillion. Dividing it by a rough population number of 300 million (and ignoring the fact that portion of it comes from corporate income tax, excise taxes, etc.), the revenues collected stand at $10,000 a year a citizen. Distributing $8,400 a year back requires rather deep cuts to every single entitlement program and then some (defense, USPS, air traffic controllers, national parks, etc.)
- coolspot 11y agoGet rid of old people completely. Problem. Solved.
- Grishnakh 11y agoMedicare and UBI would have to be separate programs, just like Social Security and Medicare are today. Poor old people living off of Social Security don't pay their medical bills out-of-pocket, they have Medicare to pay for them. In a system with UBI, we'd really need to have universal healthcare ("Medicare for all"). Someone making only the basic income isn't going to have any money for sky-high Obamacare premiums, and would likely be on Medicaid. But that whole system is a complete mess, with a lot of people unable to afford Obamacare because their state didn't expand Medicaid enrollment. And now with one of the biggest insurance companies pulling out of the Obamacare exchanges, rates are going to skyrocket even more. There's only two solutions to this: 1) repeal Obamacare and change to a system where people who have no insurance are denied healthcare and are left outside the ER to die on the street, or 2) universal healthcare. The way politics are going in this country, I predict we'll see #1 before we see #2.
- prostoalex 11y agoIf one is keeping the largest entitlement program of them all, the originally quoted $700 a month is a bit pie in the sky number.
- mmanfrin 11y agoIf you were to implement the Fair Tax, which includes a stipend for basic needs, you'd get bipartisan support as well Poe's Law is pinging.
- chadzawistowski 11y agoI think the comment was earnest. Check out this article: http://www.vox.com/2015/4/2/8332115/rubio-lee-basic-income http://www.vox.com/2015/4/2/8332115/rubio-lee-basic-income It's called the FairTax, and it would replace nearly all federal taxes with a 30 percent national sales tax. That on its own is a regressive idea — low-income people spend more of their incomes than the rich do, so would pay a greater share of their incomes in sales tax — so the FairTax would give each household a "prebate" equivalent to the sales tax they'd pay on poverty-level spending. For example, in 2013 the FairTax "consumption allowance" for a family of four (two parents, two kids) was $31,020. If you spent that much money in a FairTax world, $7,135 of it would go to federal sales taxes. So the FairTax provides a $7,135 annual rebate to families of four, distributed monthly. Make no mistake: this is a basic income. There is no work requirement. You get it regardless of whether you make any money. It is a straight-up basic income. FairTaxers object to this characterization, saying that because the prebate is meant to compensate for taxes you pay on necessities, it's "your money being returned to you." But if you live below the poverty level, you come out ahead from the rebate. It's just a cash transfer program.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- phkahler 11y ago"fair tax" is the stupidest thing ever. How do you implement a progressive tax on consumption? You'd have to keep track of every purchase a person makes to know how much they've spent. It's worse than keeping track of income, and it's also a massive surveillance tool. Then there's the whole problem that people who have lower income will pay a higher percentage of it in tax. There is nothing good about that scheme.
- pvnick 11y agoHow come it has to be progressive? Wealthier folks consume more and therefore pay more.
- taurath 11y agoWealthier folks consume less as a percentage of their income than poor people do. If you add a 10% sales tax on food, the poor are hit harder, as a percentage of their income.
- tstrimple 11y agoThis is such an important point that so many seem to miss. The more income you have, the higher your disposable income. A person who earns $20k per year probably spends $20k per year. A person who earns $50 million a year isn't going to spend $50 million every year. Even if their income skyrockets to $150 million, they likely aren't going to spend $50 million in a year. It's just not feasible. Therefore, any sort of FairTax or FlatTax is hitting the poor a lot more than the rich and is regressive by definition.
- taurath 11y agoIts a basic fallacy of the fairtax/nonprogressive tax movements that consumption equal to income. It is true, until you have your basic needs met. Go around to your local rich neighborhood - not everyone has the latest Maserati, because their transportation needs are fully met by a cheaper vehicle. If you're well off much more of your income is going to go to investments and savings.
- djd20 11y agoThe main issue with giving people basic income/kid is that people will have lots of kids to get more money and ... do nothing with it other than watch tv and eat chips. They won't spend it on their kids. There are a tonne of examples exactly this happening in the UK where a single mother has 6 kids and £50k income from various govt child support schemes. The kids learn from their mum that they have to have lots of kids to get free money. Don't get me wrong - I think this is an excellent idea overall, but as it is with these things, it can't be oversimplified.