3 ms·
Am I missing something, why there is so little attention to this? Because if this is not revolutionary, I don't know, what else deserves the term ... Sure, it
by hutzlibu 11y ago
Am I missing something, why there is so little attention to this?
Because if this is not revolutionary, I don't know, what else deserves the term ...
Sure, it seems not to be working perfect, yet, with "only" 45 of 60 "programms" working in a actual cell, but it just sounds amazing to me.
But I don't know much about verilog or genetics in general, so I actually might miss out some huge limitations ... but it still seems like a great success, with so many potential applications ...
I mean actual programming like you're used to, but you don't target silicon, but a living cell!
(and a cell can reproduce itself ...)
It probably still takes great knowledge of genetics and cell structure in general, to make something that works ... but I think, I start learning that now.
- sklogic 11y ago> Because if this is not revolutionary, I don't know, what else deserves the term ... DNA computing was known and well-developed from around the late 90s. This work only adds a tiny layer of abstraction to simplify building circuits - something that previously was done with raw schematics. Given how simple those circuits are, there is not that much difference, really.
- hutzlibu 11y ago> Given how simple those circuits are, there is not that much difference, really. So this might be the real limitation, but if I don't have to build those circuits by hand, couldn't I build much more complex circuits with that "tiny layer of abstraction"? And as I said, I don't know much about verilog or genetics, but from a quick overview, it seemed to me, that I could define variables, flow-structure, etc. (modules?) so pretty much classic programming?
- sklogic 11y agoYou're not building any distinct conductive "wires" in a cell - each wire is a global chemical signal, therefore there is a hard limit on how many of those you can put into a single cell. And, behavioural is not supported (i.e., no flip-flops, and definitely no clock signal), so you can only have combinational logic.
- hutzlibu 11y agoThanks for your input. So it seems, there are indeed huge limitations ... Could you give a rough number "on how many of those you can put into a single cell"? Anyway, I still think, this is a great step forward, but maybe not as revolutionary, as I thought at first look (I think basic info like this, belongs into the news article).
- gravypod 11y agoCould you not split the computation up across multiple cells? IE: Don't only create 1 cell, create 4 cells that do different parts of the task an do message passing to each other.