4 ms·
A cold shower lowers your skin temperature, which in turn causes your body to restrict the blood flow to save heat. When you get out of the shower and back in t
by onion2k 11y ago
A cold shower lowers your skin temperature, which in turn causes your body to restrict the blood flow to save heat. When you get out of the shower and back in to the warm you start pumping blood back to the surface again. There is no additional work done to warm you up. Your physics approach is betrayed by biology. We've had thousands of years to evolve an efficient solution to the problem of heat conservation.
- ljf 11y agoSo having a cold shower has no effect on core temp? What about a cold bath? What about being in the sea after an accident at the higher latitudes?? Also I think you will find that returning your skin to a normal temperature after chilling in in any way (water, aircon, etc) temporarily decreases core temperature after which you expend energy to return it to normal. We may have had thousands (if not millions) of years to evolve solutions to heat conservation but they aren't perfect, or people would never die in freezing water or conditions.
- Hondor 11y agoIf your core temperature drops, it's probably because you're losing heat faster than you can generate it. That kind of points to how effective this could be in the limit of being nearly fatal - If you can lose more heat than your body can produce, you're surely doing a pretty good job of burning calories! Yes, I agree we're far from perfect at conserving heat. We're optimized for other conflicting purposes instead. We don't even have fur.
- Hondor 11y agoGood point, but it looks like there's still a big effect. Vasoconstriction causes up to an extra 10 degC temperature gradient across the skin compared to when they're dilated (less than 1 degC). [ http://www.healthyheating.com/Thermal_Comfort_Working_Copy/downloads/http___repositories.cdlib.org_cgi_viewcontent.pdf http://www.healthyheating.com/Thermal_Comfort_Working_Copy/d... p572 ] So that halves heat flow rate from what I described. It's like being in a 10 degC environment instead of 0 degC. You could double the length of the cold shower to 5 minutes to compensate.
- joncrocks 11y agoSo we can't get hypothermia? Agreed there will be a reduction in blood flow, but there will still be some warming up required. And I would imagine that the longer you're in the water, the longer you'll get cooling just from a pure conduction basis, irrespective of blood flow. Not saying that I buy the whole "You'll lose weight based on physics alone!" in so much that it'll be significant, but the effect will be non-zero.