3 ms·
Indeed, improving a single criteria holding all others constant is always an improvement to well being. This i true, but irrelevant. If people choose a good no
by yummyfajitas 17y ago
Indeed, improving a single criteria holding all others constant is always an improvement to well being. This i true, but irrelevant.
If people choose a good not measured by your index at the expense of a good in the index, it lowers their index value but raises well being.
Another example: a food lover might choose to eat delicious pudding rather than playing soccer. If the index includes health but excludes hedonic pleasure from food (which I believe the HDI does), the food lover's choice might reduce HDI in spite of improving his well being.
It's much the same problem as with a man marrying his maid; utility and well being increases but the index (GDP in that case) decreases.