2 ms·
Shorter: Correlation does not Aristotelian-imply causation. Correlation probabilistically-implies causation. Aristotelian logic is a necessary step towards und
by jerf 11y ago
Shorter: Correlation does not Aristotelian-imply causation. Correlation probabilistically-implies causation.
Aristotelian logic is a necessary step towards understanding logic, but on its own it's not actually that useful because in reality we just don't have enough things that we can safely approximate as 100% true for it to work reliably.
Incidentally, this also means that the classic lists of "argument fallacies" often contain a few fallacies themselves, as an argument being Aristotelian-fallacious does not mean that it's practically- or probabilistically-fallacious. But I will agree that this is generally a distinction without a difference; I only rarely see someone accuse someone else of committing a fallacy where the accusation is Aristotelian-correct but not probabilistically-correct. But, rolling back around to the original point, most of them are indeed thoughtless recitations of the "correlation does not imply causation" mantra when, probabilistically, the correlation being observed can be reasonably interpreted as evidence.