3 ms·
Yes, we probably would need a trial in that instance. The courts really don't get to hold someone indefinitely without charging them with something. Contempt
by bsder 11y ago
Yes, we probably would need a trial in that instance.
The courts really don't get to hold someone indefinitely without charging them with something.
Contempt is generally used as a quick and dirty hack for someone disobeying the procedures of the court. Not providing a fingerprint to unlock evidence is WAY beyond that scope and probably should require a hearing and trial.
Now, she could be detained while that hearing is proceeding, but that's different that just being jailed for contempt.
- rayiner 11y agoA trial for what?
- cmdrfred 11y agoIf you can't charge her with a crime then why are you holding her?
- tptacek 11y agoIn order to compel her to obey the orders of the court.
- bsder 11y agoIf that order is lawful, then it probably has a chargeable crime behind it. If it doesn't, then there should be limit. Compelling someone to open a phone with a fingerprint is far from settled law. It should be litigated properly as part of the trial rather than with a "contempt" charge. In this instance, it is the court that is attempting to end run an unsettled area of the law using "contempt".
- rayiner 11y agoShe was arrested based on probable cause that she had committed identity theft. The search warrant is the process by which evidence needed to support formal charges.