3 ms·
F-35 could splash any harrier derivative from afar And an X-wing could take out an F-35, I mean, if we're talking complete hypotheticals. The Harrier is battl
by gaius 11y ago
F-35 could splash any harrier derivative from afar
And an X-wing could take out an F-35, I mean, if we're talking complete hypotheticals.
The Harrier is battle-proven everywhere from the Falklands to Afghanistan. Marry it up with modern radar and air-to-air missiles and you will have a very capable platform - one that the F-35 - if it ever flies in combat - which it won't because no-one will risk those mind-bogglingly expensive airframes in a shooting war - won't see coming because its radar has rebooted again.
- Someone1234 11y agoI love the Harrier and agree that a modern one would be a better buy than the F-35. However, the argument you're making is silly. A Harrier won't beat an F-35 in combat. The F-35 would shoot down the Harrier before the Harrier had even detected it. The argument you SHOULD be making is one of cost, performance at roles (e.g. CAS, bombing missions, etc), proven for naval operations, extremely flexible, and would likely be delivered sooner (even if they started today, if only one manufacturer was involved, it will likely ship before the naval variant of the F-35 in 2022 or whatever they're guesstimating now). The core problem with the F-35 and F-22 is that they're the most advanced air to air combat aircraft ever built, so advanced in fact that they have nothing to fight, and worse still will arrive right before swarms of drones take over from manned aircraft (e.g. 10x drones Vs. 1x F-35, the F-35 would literally run out of munitions).
- engi_nerd 11y agoPlease tell me what a modern Harrier would look like. Here is an (admittedly contrived) list of some design goals: * Greater STOVL performance, without the limitations imposed by needing to carry water for thrust augmentation * Low observability (certainly lower than a Harrier, which has a big RCS) * Greater sensor capabilities. Built-in electro-optical targeting so that radar can be used less, or not at all * Reduce pilot workload by filtering information presented in an intelligent way * Reduce STOVL cognitive errors created by differing control schemes between STOVL flight and conventional flight This sounds an awful lot like an F-35B. My point is, saying you want a "modern Harrier" isn't enough. Because in many important ways the F-35B is a "modern Harrier". You have to figure out how whatever it is you're going to build will be different, if you hope to avoid the same problems.
- KineticLensman 11y ago>> The Harrier is battle-proven everywhere from the Falklands to Afghanistan This doesn't translate into a tactical capability today: Falklands: Harriers fighting Mirage III, which were 20 years old, 34 years ago. Afghanistan: dropping dumb bombs on adversaries who didn't have a SAM capability
- toyg 11y agoIsn't that the point, though? Who are these jets going to fight -- pretty much any realistic hypothesis of conflict today would consist of asymmetrical warfare, especially if waged by the US or US allies. Asymmetrical warfare with existing weaponry, let alone next-generation planes. The only scenario where the US would face significant resistance is vs China or Russia, where planes wouldn't even get the chance to take off before Midnight is upon us. Given the situation, it would make more sense to invest in something cheaper that will do the job just as well.
- setra 11y agoI am not convinced than an X-wing would beat an F-35. Do you notice that the cannons on the X-wing have a slow rate of fire, and the beams move slowly through the air. Not to mention the limited missile capabilities.
- gaius 11y agoThere's that but the X-wing's repulsorlift gives it superior V/STOL capability to the F-35 remember.