8 ms·
The person who is being held indefinitely for not giving up his password is really frightening. They should either let him go or charge him with contempt of cou
by djsumdog 11y ago
The person who is being held indefinitely for not giving up his password is really frightening. They should either let him go or charge him with contempt of course/obstruction and issue time served!
Even if you /know/ you don't have anything illegal on any of my encrypted devices, it's better to take a contempt of court charge than give up a password...because of what they might /find/ or possible things unrelated to an investigation that they can link to a crime (or what they can then plant).
- JoshTriplett 11y agoContempt is a terrifying charge, because under current law, you can be jailed indefinitely for the same contempt charge for as long as you refuse to cooperate with whatever the court thinks you should cooperate with. There's no upper bound there. So that wouldn't solve the problem.
- bitJericho 11y agoI don't think its a problem for someone actively breaking the law to be held indefinitely for contempt until they stop breaking the law. I thought being compelled to reveal a passphrase was no longer required.
- themartorana 11y agoThat's a problem for me. Charge and prosecute them or let them go. Indefinite detention without a fair and speedy trial is unquestionably unconstitutional.
- bitJericho 11y agoWell imagine a criminal is holding a piece of your property or even a person and not revealing where that is. Do you think it's reasonable to hold them for 30 days and then let them go and say "ah well I guess you can return that/them if you want cuz you did your time." A charge of contempt is still a charge.
- weaksauce 11y agoConvicted of a crime is different than suspicion of a crime.
- randommodnar 11y agoSo do you think it's reasonable that contempt of court can carry a life sentence without even being convicted by a jury of your peers? Is contempt of court a worse crime than assault or manslaughter? You have the right to not divulge information from your mind that would incriminate yourself. In the US this is called the 5th amendment.
- koenigdavidmj 11y agoBefore you're given contempt for not divulging information you are given immunity from criminal charges as a result of that testimony.
- tanderson92 11y agoSource? That is certainly not true in general.
- koenigdavidmj 11y agohttps://www.justice.gov/usam/criminal-resource-manual-780-direct-contempt-witnesss-refusal-obey-court-order-testify-trial https://www.justice.gov/usam/criminal-resource-manual-780-di...
- spdustin 11y agoAs GP said, that's not true in general. Immunity is offered when the prosecution believes your testimony will result in further arrests or in prevention of future crimes. That circumstance is exceedingly rare outside of episodes of "24".
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 11y agoThe contempt power is in the Judiciary Act of 1789, so it's hard to say that the founding generation would have considered it unconstitutional. Moreover, what exactly would she be tried for? Do we need a trial to establish that she has in fact continued to disobey the judge's order to unlock the phone?
- bsder 11y agoYes, we probably would need a trial in that instance. The courts really don't get to hold someone indefinitely without charging them with something. Contempt is generally used as a quick and dirty hack for someone disobeying the procedures of the court. Not providing a fingerprint to unlock evidence is WAY beyond that scope and probably should require a hearing and trial. Now, she could be detained while that hearing is proceeding, but that's different that just being jailed for contempt.
- rayiner 11y agoA trial for what?
- cmdrfred 11y agoIf you can't charge her with a crime then why are you holding her?
- tptacek 11y agoIn order to compel her to obey the orders of the court.
- bsder 11y agoIf that order is lawful, then it probably has a chargeable crime behind it. If it doesn't, then there should be limit. Compelling someone to open a phone with a fingerprint is far from settled law. It should be litigated properly as part of the trial rather than with a "contempt" charge. In this instance, it is the court that is attempting to end run an unsettled area of the law using "contempt".
- headShrinker 11y agoProve that they broke the law!
- spdustin 11y agoWould you mind terribly quoting the law that requires me to submit to the physical act of unlocking my phone? Since it's not a two-factor system, it is equivalent to a passphrase, which (IIRC) has been upheld to be a form of testimony, and therefore the fifth amendment SHOULD allow the suspect to refuse to "utter their fingerprint", so to speak. In any case, if the fingerprint isn't the same "testimony" as a passphrase, the suspect is not in violation of the law after 48 hours has elapsed, since "uttering their fingerprint" (as I'm choosing to style it) after 48 hours wouldn't unlock the phone any more anyway.
- khedoros 11y agoProviding a fingerprint isn't considered testimony, and the law doesn't currently make an exception for a fingerprint used as the equivalent of a passphrase. The fifth amendment protects knowledge, but not physical constructs like a fingerprint or DNA swab[1]. So, you can be compelled to provide a fingerprint, and the use that the fingerprint is put to is outside the scope of 5th amendment protections. http://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/12pdf/12-207_d18e.pdf http://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/12pdf/12-207_d18e.pdf
- taneq 11y agoIt's gonna get really interesting if/when neuroscience advances to the point where we can just read a passcode out of someone's brainwaves. I don't see any legal difference between the fingerprint case and the brain-scan case (both are measuring a physical aspect of the person) but it's going to completely bypass the fifth amendment.
- rayiner 11y agoMerriam-Webster defines "testimony" as "something that someone says especially in a court of law while formally promising to tell the truth." The Supreme Court has interpreted this very broadly, to include anything that requires accessing information from the mind. That's why some courts have held that passwords are testimonial. But to read it to include touching your thumb to a fingerprint sensor obliterates any meaning the word has.
- koenigdavidmj 11y agoContempt in this case would be impossible after a couple days, when the iPhone will refuse to accept the fingerprint and instead require the passphrase. She is no longer capable of fulfilling the court's demand (use your fingerprint to unlock the phone) at that point.
- basch 11y agonot if they charged it? wouldnt it last forever?
- koenigdavidmj 11y agoThe iPhone requires a password after a couple days of inattention, and does not accept Touch ID logins.
- khedoros 11y agoContempt is only supposed to be for when someone's action brings the mechanism of a trial to a halt. Refusing to do an action that the court thinks it's allowed to compel you to do is an example. Say she waits two days. The phone won't be unlocked with a fingerprint now; it requires a passcode, and the court can't compel someone to provide a passcode in the same way that it can compel them to provide fingerprints. Contempt wouldn't be a valid charge anymore, at that point. If the judge won't recognize that, the prisoner/suspect could appeal. The above is my understanding of the theory of how it works. Maybe I'm wrong. Maybe it works differently in practice.
- chris_wot 11y agoProbably a ridiculous thought experiment, but I know folks have done similar things before, what if she cut off her thumb and disposed of it in such a way that it was irretrievable? Or something less permanent like dipping her thumb in acid to destroy the fingerprint surface - which would take weeks to heal. Would would the court do then? It sounds to me like fingerprint authentication is not something a criminal should use if they don't want to get caught. Apparently a passcode is protected under the Fifth Amendment but not a fingerprint. [1] But it's ridiculous really. All that a criminal needs to do is restart their phone to prevent their fingerprint from being used. And there are good reasons for doing so other than to escape incrimination! And that can be done from the lock screen... Imagine the criminal held down the power off button for three seconds then swiped, is that a crime? Perhaps that falls under spoliation of evidence, but then again how is not giving a passcode not considered spoliation? Apple should require a user configurable timeout for requiring of a passcode. I'm sure it normally takes more than two hours to interview and charge someone. 1. http://www.macrumors.com/2014/10/31/fingerprints-not-protected-by-fifth-amendment/ http://www.macrumors.com/2014/10/31/fingerprints-not-protect...
- CobrastanJorji 11y agoContempt is a weird power in general, especially when it's used for reasons like "disrespecting the judge." If I am disrespectful to the governor of my state, or if I'm disrespectful to a police officer, or if I'm disrespectful to a fireman or a bailiff or a legislator or a district attorney or a teacher or the President, that is a thing that I can legally do. But for some reason it's not outrageous for a judge to send me to jail because I showed them insufficient respect.
- tptacek 11y agoContempt is appealable, so it's not as if a single judge could ever detain someone indefinitely.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- derefr 11y ago"Contempt of court" isn't supposed to refer to contempt of the judge, though. It's supposed to refer to contempt for the mechanism of a trial: not respecting the time or the (legally-required) duties of anyone there, basically making it impossible to go on with the work of the court system. A lawyer attempting to "filibuster" a jury into agreeing with them, for example, would be in contempt of court for wasting the jurors' time. The "contempt of court" charge basically serves as a court-private time-out box to send people to whenever they can't handle being in court, until they learn to stop, erm, "blocking the cooperative event queue from pumping messages." It's not that the charge has to be indefinite—but it has to be capable of sticking as long as the trial's progress is halted. The charge should definitely cease to apply if the trial manages to resume through some other route—and especially if it manages to conclude. Remember, "contempt of court" isn't about malfeasance, either. Experts who lie on the stand are not in contempt. Lawyers who introduce non-cross-examined evidence are not in contempt. Random audience members getting up and saying things during court are not in contempt. It's only when one of these things causes the trial mechanism to grind to a halt, and then the person refuses to yield to let the trial resume, that they are in contempt. It's a process-control mechanism, and in that respect, it's quite necessary. (That's not to say it can't be abused—especially in smaller courts in non-jury trials. But it has a well-defined good usage, and can't really be redefined without losing that usage.)
- kayamon 11y agoI realize this isn't exactly the point, but couldn't he just tell them he 'forgot' his password? It's not like they'd be able to prove otherwise.