7 ms·
You can be compelled to provide fingerprints based on a warrant; I'm unsurprised (and not particularly bothered) that you can be compelled to use them on your o
by JoshTriplett 11y ago
You can be compelled to provide fingerprints based on a warrant; I'm unsurprised (and not particularly bothered) that you can be compelled to use them on your own device. If you care about security, don't use a fingerprint alone; at most, only use it as a second factor for two-factor authentication. More generally, don't use anything that removes your ability to make a choice under duress, in whichever direction you see fit, based on what you're protecting and what you're being threatened with.
I find the ongoing case of someone being jailed indefinitely for refusing to supply a passphrase far more concerning than someone being compelled to supply a fingerprint.
- JadeNB 11y agoYou've described the state of the law as it is, but surely that doesn't address the issue of the law as it should be. I think that it is possible to be an intelligent but non-technical person and (EDIT: forgot the word 'not') realise that, all technical issues aside, the "something you know" and "something you have" parts of a password are on completely different legal footing; and I think that it is reasonable even for a technical person to wonder whether it should be so. EDIT: I know that complaints about downvotes are not welcome, and it's quite possible that I'm wrong in what I say, but I'd like to be told how rather than just downvoted! My comment was meant to be a constructive contribution. EDIT 2: Wow, these many replies help a lot! Thanks!
- JoshTriplett 11y agoI agree with the comments below: a fingerprint is a username, not a password. I don't have a problem with compelling the provision of identification given an appropriate warrant; I do have a problem with compelling the provision of information held only in someone's head, with or without a warrant.
- EdHominem 11y agoBut it's not being used as a username, it's being used as a password. (Or rather, a username and a password.) It's hacking to bypass even a trivial password, so similarly it should be unreasonable to compel disclosure of even a trivial password... They don't need your usename - your phone assumes it's you and only asks for the password... The fingerprint that they're seeking is not a username, it's a crappy password.
- dragonwriter 11y ago"Something you have" isn't part of a password, its an alternative, non-password factor; passwords are always "something you know". There is a trend to use biometrics in place of passwords, which is a convenience feature which compromises security, even though it is often misrepresented as a security feature. (Using biometrics as a second factor helps security, but there is a big difference between "and" and "or" security measures.)
- m_eiman 11y agoA fingerprint can improve security in at least one way: it makes it impossible to shoulder-surf your password since you're not entering it.
- pc86 11y agoCourts are not (and should not be) interested in "the law as it should be." They are to interpret the law as it is written.
- JadeNB 11y ago> Courts are not (and should not be) interested in "the law as it should be." They are to interpret the law as it is written. I agree, but then neither are we the courts; and it is precisely the role of the commons to discuss the law as it should be, so that the legislative branch can, hopefully, enshrine that communal wisdom in the law as it is.
- pc86 11y agoYou are right, I misinterpreted your comment.
- gruyere 11y agoper your edit, you seem to forget you're at HN.
- eganist 11y ago> but I'd like to be told how rather than just downvoted! It's probably in the tone of your comment, which (though it isn't the case) implies that there's something wrong with the laws. I'd edit and rephrase in your position, especially since your criticism isn't of the law but is rather of the education of users. To your point: if users of devices could be educated in-device about the security of different identification and authentication schemes, the user could take better ownership of the security of said user's device.
- JadeNB 11y agoThank you for your response! > It's probably in the tone of your comment, which (though it isn't the case) implies that there's something wrong with the laws. Rather than endorsing or decrying the law, I meant only to suggest that a simple, factual description of the state of the law, while non-controversial, also doesn't address the question of whether the law is appropriate. I am not at all sure that it is; but I am also a naïf in these matters, which is why I appreciate the many users who responded to my request for clarification. > I'd edit and rephrase in your position, especially since your criticism isn't of the law but is rather of the education of users. To your point: if users of devices could be educated in-device about the security of different identification and authentication schemes, the user could take better ownership of the security of said user's device. Indeed, I think that the point you make (and generously attribute to me) is a good one orthogonal to any questions of the law; whether the law is good or bad in any particular sense, it is as it is, and will be so enforced, and users should be educated as far as possible about this when choosing whether and how to secure their devices.
- DannyBee 11y ago"You've described the state of the law as it is, but surely that doesn't address the issue of the law as it should be." Fingerprints and other things like them are 100% non-testimonial. The fifth amendment does not cover non-testimonial evidence (because it only covers being a witness against yourself). This has been law since the amendment was enacted, was the purpose of it, etc. So I suspect if you want the law to be something else, your problem isn't even with the courts or judges, it's with the founders :)
- spdustin 11y agoNot true. There is an adage that the government can force you to produce the key to a lock, but not the combination to a safe. It just so happens that, today, the government can compel you to perform a physical gesture that, by proxy, happens to be used as a key on a device that normally accepts a combination. If it's been 48 hours since your finger was last applied to the Touch ID sensor on an iPhone, that "key" doesn't work any more. So, until the fingerprint is accepted by the courts as a "combination" (effectively, that's how the "common man" sees it, and which the courts treat as testimony-by-proxy) rather than a physical gesture (not testimony at all, and currently easily compelled), the only defense one has (if using Touch ID) is to stall for 48 hours.
- DannyBee 11y agoYour adage is based on random supreme court dicta in Hubbell and Doe, and you know courts have gone either way. ;) So let's just both agree we are suggesting the world is a little more black and white than it is. I would not try to predict what would happen square-on today, given the splits involved.
- maxerickson 11y agoThe OP states their opinion a couple of times, so surely that doesn't address the issue of the law as it should be. isn't a very good reply to what they said. That was my reasoning.
- JadeNB 11y agoThank you for the explanation. Aside from saying once that he was not bothered by this state of things, I took the poster to be mainly explaining the consequences of the law (don't act as if your fingerprint is as secure as your password) rather than specifically endorsing it.
- JoshTriplett 11y agoI definitely wasn't just giving the current state of the law; I was offering the opinion that out of the pile of problems we do have with government overreach, surveillance, and lack of understanding of technology, this case seems perfectly reasonable and not worth worrying about. I'm not bothered by the compelled production of a fingerprint, given the due process of a warrant; I don't see any obvious reason why someone should expect otherwise from the law, nor any right or reasonable expectation this violates, and I don't think the law needs to change in that area. (I do see other issues associated with fingerprints, such as the retention of fingerprints from non-criminals cleared of all charges, but I don't see an issue that applies to this case.) I am bothered by (attempted) compelled production of a passphrase. And I see those as significantly different cases.
- djsumdog 11y agoThe person who is being held indefinitely for not giving up his password is really frightening. They should either let him go or charge him with contempt of course/obstruction and issue time served! Even if you /know/ you don't have anything illegal on any of my encrypted devices, it's better to take a contempt of court charge than give up a password...because of what they might /find/ or possible things unrelated to an investigation that they can link to a crime (or what they can then plant).
- JoshTriplett 11y agoContempt is a terrifying charge, because under current law, you can be jailed indefinitely for the same contempt charge for as long as you refuse to cooperate with whatever the court thinks you should cooperate with. There's no upper bound there. So that wouldn't solve the problem.
- bitJericho 11y agoI don't think its a problem for someone actively breaking the law to be held indefinitely for contempt until they stop breaking the law. I thought being compelled to reveal a passphrase was no longer required.
- themartorana 11y agoThat's a problem for me. Charge and prosecute them or let them go. Indefinite detention without a fair and speedy trial is unquestionably unconstitutional.
- bitJericho 11y agoWell imagine a criminal is holding a piece of your property or even a person and not revealing where that is. Do you think it's reasonable to hold them for 30 days and then let them go and say "ah well I guess you can return that/them if you want cuz you did your time." A charge of contempt is still a charge.
- maaku 11y ago> You can be compelled to provide fingerprints based on a warrant; I'm unsurprised (and not particularly bothered) that you can be compelled to use them on your own device. 5th amendment.
- eganist 11y agoDoesn't apply, and this isn't the first opinion to come to that conclusion either. http://pilotonline.com/news/local/crime/police-can-require-cellphone-fingerprint-not-pass-code/article_25373eb2-d719-5a6e-b677-656699a50168.html http://pilotonline.com/news/local/crime/police-can-require-c... 5th amendment appears to be restricted to what you know based on all available rulings thus far. A password would fall under "what you know."
- curt15 11y agoIn the era of fast 3d printers, what stands in the way of just fashioning a suitable fake finger from the fingerprint?
- msbarnett 11y agoNothing. The 3d printer is overkill. A fingerprint and a pack of gelatin is more than sufficient.
- r00fus 11y agoHave you personally done or seen this done this then? Quality of the print production seems pretty important...
- hengheng 11y agoLaser printers are perfectly fine. CCC demoed this a few years back: https://youtu.be/aGjGzqYgz0c https://youtu.be/aGjGzqYgz0c
- berdario 11y agohttps://www.ccc.de/en/updates/2013/ccc-breaks-apple-touchid https://www.ccc.de/en/updates/2013/ccc-breaks-apple-touchid http://www.heise.de/video/artikel/iPhone-5s-Touch-ID-hack-in-detail-1966044.html http://www.heise.de/video/artikel/iPhone-5s-Touch-ID-hack-in...
- stcredzero 11y agoMythbusters did it.
- r00fus 11y agoNot on an iPhone.
- mikestew 11y agoYou might have noticed that ABS plastic doesn't have a lot of similarities with human flesh. That's not to say that it can't be faked, just maybe not with a 3D printer: http://arstechnica.com/security/2014/09/fake-fingerprint-fools-iphone-6-touch-id-why-its-not-so-serious/ http://arstechnica.com/security/2014/09/fake-fingerprint-foo...
- ianopolous 11y agoThis is why we need plausibly deniable dual login on all accounts, ala truecrypt.
- MichaelGG 11y agoThe issue there is that if you aren't really being plausibly deniable (using the fake login), then the court will realise this. For instance, if they know you were using that laptop 1 day ago, but the timestamps on the instance you unlock are all from 2 months ago, they may deduce you are pulling this stunt.
- paulddraper 11y agoAnd spoliation is illegal.
- stcredzero 11y agoYou can be compelled to provide fingerprints based on a warrant; I'm unsurprised (and not particularly bothered) that you can be compelled to use them on your own device. I thought that fingerprints were to be provided to: 1) establish biometric proof of identity 2) establish the presence of a person in a particular place 3) establish a person handled a particular object Or does the law establish that the authorities can use fingerprints for evidence in any fashion? Could they use a scan of a fingerprint to etch a fake-fingerprint latex sheet to open your locked device?
- swyman 11y agoWhere does that list come from?
- stcredzero 11y agoI am not a police investigator or lawyer, but those are what I understand as a layman to be the uses of fingerprints in practice.
- swyman 11y agoSorry, I guess I just read your phrasing to have more authoritative intent than you were going for. As I (also not a lawyer) understand it, there's nothing in particular that limits how intermediate/circumstantial pieces of evidence can be used/combined to find more evidence as long as each piece of evidence in the chain was acquired legally.
- niij 11y agoI'm not sure where you're getting this list from. But, I think that #3 would be relevant in this case, as the person would have needed to handle the device to register their fingerprint.
- spdustin 11y agoProviding a fingerprint (identification) is different from imprinting your finger to unlock a device. It's been upheld in the past that passwords/passphrases used to unlock encrypted content are considered to be testimony (because it leads to the acquisition and collection of possibly protected "testimony"), and thus protected by the fifth amendment. In my opinion, there is no reason to see imprinting your finger on a sensor used to unlock your phone as anything other than an equivalent form of "testimony", and it should enjoy fifth amendment protection. I don't think it will be long before this exact definition finds its way to the U.S. Supreme Court.
- drags 11y agoMy understanding is that the "testimony" would be in the text of the password: compelling someone to reveal the password could be self-incriminating if _the password itself_ led them to additional evidence (e.g. a password of "I hid the revolver in the Conservatory"). [1] I can't think of a case involving a fingerprint where there's a similar risk since the fingerprint is arbitrary data. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Hubbell#Summary_of_the_Act_of_Production_Doctrine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Hubbell#Summa...
- spdustin 11y agoThe case law thus far has stated that compelling the decryption of a data storage device really hinges on this: What evidence is known by the prosecution to exist? In several cases, when the defendant makes known that incriminating evidence exists, or when the prosecution is independently aware of the existence of incriminating evidence (they saw the screen before you locked it, and testified that what they saw was evidence of a crime), the defendant was rightfully forced to decrypt the storage device. However, when the prosecution has no specific knowledge that the evidence they seek exists, US courts have ruled that the defendant cannot be compelled to decrypt the storage device, since doing so would be forcing the defendant to reveal that incriminating evidence actually exists. Applying your fingerprint to an iPhone is an act that, without argument, decrypts data on an encrypted storage media, as the act of applying your finger to the sensor instructs the device to retrieve the actual cryptographic information necessary (your passcode/passphrase, plus other hardware-specific data) to access the cleartext of the data. The more and more I think about this, the more confidant I am that a fingerprint, while "something you have", forces you to disclose, by proxy, "something you know" to your phone. I guess the question then is twofold: If you have a combination safe that may contain incriminatory evidence, and a safety deposit box that contains only the combination to your safe, can the courts compel you to give them the key to the safety deposit box? And if so, should they be able to?
- samstave 11y agoFuck you. (The state, not you user: JoshTriplett) But I do NOT agree with your comment. Fuck the state. A state who is trying to use terror and fear and war and crime as an excuse for power is a fucked state - and I want no part of it. The fact is that it is a lame excuse for "security" to use ginger-prints as a "secure" access method to a device such as a phone and then for the state to force people to take finger prints as a sure-identity method, which, ostensibly, could then provide access to all their data and phones, etc. Tell me how that is fucking secure???? So the real argument is about privacy. DO I HAVE ANY OR NOT????