3 ms·
Free and unimpeded travel is not a basic right for any people, in any place. It's supposed to be within the US, though, just like in Schengen. That's due to la
by pessimizer 11y ago
Free and unimpeded travel is not a basic right for any people, in any place.
It's supposed to be within the US, though, just like in Schengen. That's due to law, not some magical "right", though.
edit: what is a "basic right" supposed to be, anyway? I missed that day in philosophy class.
- malchow 11y agoIt's not even due to law; it's due to the founding nature of the Republic. Arguably not even a constitutional amendment could permit restrictions on Americans' interstate travel.
- gumby 11y ago> Arguably not even a constitutional amendment could permit restrictions on Americans' interstate travel. You might think it would be arguable but John Gilmore discovered you can't even argue it -- the law is secret and cannot be discussed in open court, thus he had no standing to sue over it: https://papersplease.org/gilmore/ https://papersplease.org/gilmore/ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gilmore_v._Gonzales https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gilmore_v._Gonzales The wikipedia entry is slightly misleading on one point: the ninth circuit said he could travel without ID (this case came about because I had been flying without ID and discussed it with John) -- his suit was that he had no choice due to a law he was not permitted to read (yet ignorance of that law is no defense!) and he argued that that was a violation of free speech + free assembly. Without being able to discuss the law in open court, the justification for the decision was a fig leaf.
- gumby 11y ago> what is a "basic right" supposed to be, anyway? I missed that day in philosophy class. Fundamental rights that are inherent to all humans by birth and cannot be justly alienated. It's a major philosophical topic you've probably seen reflected in the universal declaration of human rights, american declaration of independence, french revolutionary declaration of the rights of man etc . There's a terrible and anglocentric wikipedia page devoted to this topic: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_and_legal_rights https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_and_legal_rights
- wallabout 11y agoa right against "unreasonable search and seizure" applies at all times, including travel. Is the search "reasonable"? I personally don't think so, given that it's more symbolism than substance. But there is a right to be "unimpeded" to some extent. To say otherwise is disingenuous.