3 ms·
There are a large number of places with densely packed people. The unique thing about airports is their access to airplanes and their capacity to be used as wea
by jerf 11y ago
There are a large number of places with densely packed people. The unique thing about airports is their access to airplanes and their capacity to be used as weapons. (I'm taking a broad view of "weapon" here; even old-school hijack-and-divert is still a political "weapon".) If it weren't for that, they wouldn't be particularly interesting and wouldn't need special security. If someone blows up the line, well, they didn't get control over a plane.
Thoughtful terrorists... and thank goodness, a lot of them really aren't... would not choose an airport line, just because it's an airport.
It's also why when we hear about the TSA claiming they need to secure trains, it's a sign that politics has 100% overtaken their supposedly-core mission; trains don't have any of these characteristics that make them any more dangerous than any other large groups of people.
- ibejoeb 11y agoI know what you're saying, but disagree that the point of these operations is to weaponize vehicles. The airport itself is a distinct target. A successful attack at an airport would disrupt travel and commerce for weeks, as we just saw in Belgium. Nothing immediately comes to mind to mitigate this. We can only push so far upstream. We can move the screening to empty fields a mile away from airport structures and require that passengers walk themselves over lest the shuttle bus be appropriated...
- bsder 11y agoActually, there is a very good solution. Process people instantly. If there are no lines at all, then there is no target. If people are used to effectively walking straight onto the plane, they aren't hanging around for several hours clogging up the system. And, anyone hanging around automatically becomes suspicious and worth a casual conversation.
- AnthonyMouse 11y ago> The unique thing about airports is their access to airplanes and their capacity to be used as weapons. That problem was solved on 9/11 the instant the public realized the possibility. Before people wouldn't fight back because they would rather be ransomed than killed. Now that everyone knows their choices are fight or die, every person on the plane would fight to the death to prevent a terrorist from taking control over it, which solves the problem more effectively than anything the TSA could ever hope to do. It actually makes everything the TSA does entirely counterproductive, because it's no longer possible to hijack a plane using a knife, but allowing all the other passengers to have knives would make it easier for them to fight back. The entire TSA is a farce that should be disbanded and replaced with nothing.
- MichaelGG 11y agoIt shouldn't have been a problem in the first place. In many cities, you cannot access the driver's portion of a taxicab. Yet airplanes had less separation. Pilots should never give controls over, and there should be strong, locked, doors. The lack of toilet sorta ruins the whole design. There's still a critical window where the door is open to the cabin, even though blocked by a food cart. But I suppose you'd need to be Bruce Lee to jump over it and get into the cabin while taking out two pilots and a FA.
- aianus 11y ago> Pilots should never give controls over, and there should be strong, locked, doors. They have that now; it resulted in a pilot deliberately crashing his own plane into the ground while the co-pilot banged futilely on the door outside. [0] Unintended consequences and all that. [0] http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/europe/france/11496066/Andreas-Lubitz-Everything-we-know-about-Germanwings-plane-crash-co-pilot.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/europe/france/1149...
- aquadrop 11y agoIt's absolutely unrelated matters. There always was a possibility for one pilot to barricade in the cabin. And in any case, he could just bash his co-pilot with something and do whatever he wants. If you got pilot who wants to crash the plane on board, you already screwed up, good thing it's very rare occasion.
- dclowd9901 11y agoIf the point (if there is a point) of terrorism is to "terrorize", I can't think of a better way than making me sweat for 3 hours in a huge line wondering if some maniac's going to come in and start spraying bullets or exploding, or perhaps opting out of traveling altogether. OP has it exactly right. Airplane hijackings get a lot of attention, but being afraid of even mundane activities is downright terrifying.