3 ms·
That's a lot of hassle for what is little more than a placebo. In the 40y that terrorists have been targetting planes, I am not aware of a single major terroris
by cm2187 11y ago
That's a lot of hassle for what is little more than a placebo. In the 40y that terrorists have been targetting planes, I am not aware of a single major terrorist attack that has been stopped by passenger checks.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoThe theory is, because of the checks no further attempts will be made. Its one thing to die for your cause; another to be arrested for your cause and disappear forever anonymously.
- cm2187 11y agoI can also carry a clown hat all day long and it will keep the pink elephants away. But there are not pink elephant! Then it means my hat is working! My theory on planes hijacking is rather that if you have a bunch of arabs taking over a plane today (after 9/11, the Paris attacks, etc), the passengers will think that doing nothing will lead to certain death, and therefore it will be impossible for the terrorists to contain the passengers. The only rational reaction for the passengers is to over power the terrorists at all risks.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoThat's been tried - that was the plane that crashed on 9/11 heading for Washington(?) Not an ideal outcome.
- cm2187 11y agoOne can argue that the passenger have reacted too late, after hearing what happened to the other planes.
- gerbilly 11y ago>I can also carry a clown hat all day long and it will keep the pink elephants away. Not if you just _carry_ it it won't. Everyone knows you have to wear it.
- mikeash 11y agoPeople do occasionally try to blow up airplanes and such. The tactic of hijacking an airplane to crash it into something isn't the only possibility. If your assertion is that security checks prevent no attacks, then you're implying that no attacker has been discouraged from making an attack due to the presence of security screening. This strikes me as absurd. There are good arguments to be made that many aspects of security screening are useless, and even that the useful aspects aren't worth what they cost. I would tend to agree with many of those arguments. But to argue that the security screening process as a whole does not prevent any attacks is taking it way too far. Just look at how incredibly frequent hijackings were in decades past, and how rare they became after basic screening was instituted. It does work to an extent. If you want to attack it, attack it on a cost/benefit basis or attack the more ridiculous bits of it, like banning liquids or screening shoes.
- cm2187 11y agoI am not arguing that security checks do not prevent any attack. I am arguing that the additional security checks introduced after 9/11 are not preventing more attacks than there were before 9/11, they are just introducing a way to persecute grannies for having a pair of scissors in their bag.
- mikeash 11y agoReally? That's not at all what you said in your original comment at the top of this thread.
- spdustin 11y agoAnd the reality is, physical screening measures will always result in the "bad guys" getting more clever with circumvention methods.
- jMyles 11y ago...and regardless, it's quite easy to simply switch to a different target for future plots.