10 ms·
Google AI has access to huge haul of NHS patient data
- foxhill 11y agoso, i'm not generally one for low brow insults, alas, here we are; fucking ignorant cunts. i'm in a position to have a pretty good grasp on (a) what deepmind are doing with this data, (b) who is working on this data (i.e the primary career researchers in this job have), and (c) the difficulty required to get any significant amount of patient data from any health organisation. but yeah, let's just assume this anonymised data will get to google and they'll somehow figure out who is who, then use it to spam us with more ads. pathetic.
- halhodson 11y agonot entirely clear what you're cross about here, but perhaps the original story (which I reported) might be useful - https://www.newscientist.com/article/2086454-revealed-google-ai-has-access-to-huge-haul-of-nhs-patient-data/ https://www.newscientist.com/article/2086454-revealed-google... happy to address any criticisms
- DanBC 11y agoYours is a much better story. It'd be nice if mods could change the link from Vice to News Scientist.
- halhodson 11y agoAgree. Mods can this happen?
- buro9 11y agodang (https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=dang https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=dang) can make it happen, unsure how to signal him but perhaps he searches his own mentions
- halhodson 11y agoemailed him. don't care massively, but the Vice piece is just a shallow re-write and it doesn't even link to us ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- dang 11y agoYes. Url changed from http://motherboard.vice.com/read/uk-hospitals-are-feeding-16-million-patients-health-records-to-googles-ai http://motherboard.vice.com/read/uk-hospitals-are-feeding-16....
- pdkl95 11y ago> will get to google The data "got to" Google when it was sent to Google DeepMind. > anonymised I expect a HN to understand how this is usually impossible. Correlating data may seem hard to the layman, but Google is experience at data analysis. Arguing that Google's AI division - who are trying to find subtle correlations in the medical data - somehow cannot correlate those same records back to their "personally identifiable information" laughable. > use it to That's not the only reason to not want your medical data spread around. A better reason might be not wanting your data in more places where it could be stolen or leaked. edit: > pathetic The "pathetic" part is the complete disregard for the people that generated that data. It doesn't matter if Google is talented at what they do, or if the data might be used for something that you might think is useful. I may even agree about the utility of the data, but if you aren't getting explicit informed consent from the people involved, you have a serious ethics problem.
- foxhill 11y ago> The data "got to" Google when it was sent to Google DeepMind. it did not. google own deepmind, but the restrictions on data usage are pretty tight. > I expect a HN to understand how this is usually impossible. Correlating data may seem hard to the layman, but Google is experience at data analysis. yes, but then again, i don't expect you to know what data it is that deepmind are working with, and what their primary motives are. whilst i don't know for certain, i heavily doubt the data is leaving deepmind. > who are trying to find subtle correlations in the medical data that is not what they are doing. > That's not the only reason to not want your medical data spread around. A better reason might be not wanting your data in more places where it could be stolen or leaked. oh please. i trust google far more than my own government for data protection; we're talking about an orginisation who leaves sensitive literally just lying around (http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk/7449927.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk/7449927.stm). > The "pathetic" part is the complete disregard for the people that generated that data. It doesn't matter if Google is talented at what they do, or if the data might be used for something that you might think is useful. I may even agree about the utility of the data, but if you aren't getting explicit informed consent from the people involved, you have a serious ethics problem. an aside; it's funny that people are far more concerned about their medical data than they are their personal history. my medical data doesn't define me, but my actions do. if only such zeal existed for governments indiscriminate collection of personal data. oh well. but back on topic, the data deepmind has (and i want to make that distinction that google does not have it, because they do not). it is anonymised sufficiently such that short of heavy analysis (which i concede is probably possible) very few inferences about the identity of the patient can be drawn. further, deepmind has absolutely no interest in correlating this data with people, and less than zero interest in targeting adverts to patients.
- DanBC 11y agoPeople in the UK who want to complain about this could try the ICO who strongly regulate health information. They could also look at any advertising material and report that to ASA (if it meets the criteria for being regulated). That trust has a Caldicott Guardian who will be responsible - legally - for keeping patient data safe. I would have liked a quote from them, although I guess that quote would be something like "No patient identifiable data has been shared with DeepMind". That would be scary, I have no doubt that DeepMind would do a very good job of de-anonymising data, but I know that Google would have to be monumentally stupid to try that. There are other data projects happening in the NHS - care.data (that dot isn't a typo!) is one that got a lot of attention. That allowed (after some fuss) people to opt-out. (It didn't allow people to specifically opt in to show their support, which is something I would have done.) I'm a bit wary of Vice's reporting here. They don't seem to know what they're talking about (there's nothing about controls over patient data in the NHS, for example); they don't seem to have approached the Trust involved; they haven't done a good job of explaining what's going on. There are some really bad failures or data protection in the NHS (especially around mass email! People using CC instead of BCC to a group of people using an HIV clinic, for example) and there are some historic abuses (selling data to insurance companies) that led to changes in the law. So I don't know if this is terrible and deserving of anger, or okay and poorly reported, or a good thing with misleading reporting.
- nezumi 11y agoTerrible reporting. Improving health outcomes by AI analysis of patient data is a much bigger prize - morally and commercially - than anything which could be achieved through ad targeting. Google is far too smart to squander such an opportunity by abusing patients' trust.
- buro9 11y agoThe big problem is the precedent it sets for data access. What are the criteria for who gets access? What are the constraints of that access? This story covers the latter being blown apart, the constraints were poorly defined and implemented and thus even if the criteria is well defined access to far more data was made possible. I'm sure that few patients desire an end to research, or would argue that such access isn't a good thing... but what of the insurance industry? Should they have access? Would the NHS be able to define and enforce those constraints? Perhaps that's an obvious no. What then of an insurer partnering with a medical research company, from the viewpoint of "This costs insurance a lot of money, we'd like to fund a way to reduce that financial exposure". The grey areas emerge immediately. If we cannot control access to patient data, data that would be trivial to either strip anonymity or just to have in aggregate enough to still produce net-negatives (i.e. correlated by post code would reveal enough with little extra work)... and if we cannot define and enforce the constraints of access... then we really shouldn't be sharing what is highly sensitive and personal information that was originally only disclosed between a patient and a Doctor under the premise that what is shared is covered by the explicit and implicit confidentiality of that conversation. It's always worth remembering: Data was acquired under doctor patient confidentiality. If we considered that data to have a licence, it is the most restrictive licence possible. One could consider what has happened here as a re-licensing without permission. Such an act could have a chilling effect on the relationship between the doctor and patient.
- chris_va 11y agoYou are making some implicit assumptions that they data access isn't highly controlled. I have seen a few of these sorts of deals killed because of data access concerns, and/or computation requirements ("you can have access to anonymized data, but you have to run your code in a sandbox on our health servers"). And, this is why we have legislation.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ocdtrekkie 11y agoThis is probably one of the reasons some may be opposed to nationalized healthcare... The government making a widespread decision to send your medical data somewhere without your permission.
- halhodson 11y agobut we don't really have the consent-at-scale technology for anything else, do we? tbh it's just this specific NHS Trust that made the call in this instance. Personally, I see potential in ResearchKit to solve the consent problem re medical data
- lbhnact 11y agoResearchKit may be part of the solution for some things, although the auth and data management will be barriers for commercial providers for the near future. I have a small team that is working with leaders in the space[1] to help many of the major EMR vendors support an open-standards based approach to medical record sharing. We'll be seeking public feedback when some of the preliminary work is ready, but are very excited to get input from the community as we make progress. [1] https://dbmi.hms.harvard.edu/news/more-power-patients https://dbmi.hms.harvard.edu/news/more-power-patients
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- CaptSpify 11y agoAlthough that is a valid concern, we can have nationalized health-care without the government sending data elsewhere. Those two aren't inclusive of each other.
- ocdtrekkie 11y agoTrue, but when the data is in private hands, the government sets regulations, like HIPAA here in the US, to regulate those companies' actions. Meanwhile, the government can and often does do what it wants with what it has.
- cromwellian 11y agoI think this situation nicely juxtaposes positive externality with private rights. As an individual, you may wish to hoard all of your personal medical information. Doing so may provide marginal benefit or protection against some theoretical harms. However, much of medical science relies on large population studies. Is knee surgery worth it? Are breast exams? Do COX-2 inhibitors increase heart attacks? Enormous amounts of good could be done by having large datasets of entire patient histories available for analysis by all, assuming they could not be de-anonymized (if not, then the datasets have to be analyzed under contracts) Whenever I visit the doctor and I am given a form asking if my data can be sent to some group to participate in a study, I always answer yes. Never once have I had any negative repercussions from doing so, and it is my hope that the data was used to publish scientific papers that added to net knowledge of humanity. However, I have to wonder if asking me for permission actually interferes with random sampling. Are people who give permission vs people who refuse statistically more likely to have other behaviors that may influence the results?
- rtkwe 11y ago> assuming they could not be de-anonymized That's where the problem is anonymizing data is really difficult and it takes only a few bits of info to associate that data with a name. It takes only 3 pieces of information to uniquely identify 87% of people, Zip code, birthday, and sex. http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2009/09/your-secrets-live-online-in-databases-of-ruin/ http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2009/09/your-secrets-live... http://dataprivacylab.org/projects/identifiability/paper1.pdf http://dataprivacylab.org/projects/identifiability/paper1.pd...
- cromwellian 11y agoRight, which justifies the government signing closed source deals to analyze this data, with the threat of legal action for violations. They can stipulate that the results of such analysis should be made public.
- Houshalter 11y agoOn the other hand anonymization destroys useful data (along with already poor record systems.) There was a Kaggle competition with medical data that had been so thoroughly damaged that 5 year old boys were listed as pregnant.
- ggggtez 11y agoAs an expert in machine learning, I don't see how someone would expect this to work. Actually to predict a disease, you need true positives and true negatives. If you only had access to the true positive data, it would be a lot harder to predict accurately.
- askldfhjkasfhd 11y agoCan you explain what you mean a little more? It seems like by having complete medical records, there would be a great deal you could infer statistically. Do you mean that it's not sufficient to have a medical record that doesn't indicate knee issues? That you would need a medical record that confirms there are no knee issues?
- throwanem 11y agoIf you want a reliable result, yes. Consider: I may have a medical record that doesn't indicate knee issues because I have correctly been diagnosed with no knee issues. Or I may have such a record because I have been incorrectly so diagnosed, despite the presence of knee issues. Or I may have such a record because I haven't been to a doctor about my knee issues in the years since they've developed, and so no opportunity has arisen for my knee issues to be documented. Simply from a medical record reflecting no evidence of knee issues, you cannot know which of these, if any, is true. As I mentioned in a reply to your neighbor comment, clinical studies are designed to exclude such confounders as these - and that's a considerable part of why such studies are so expensive to design and carry out. It's very difficult to see how such exclusion could be achieved with data of the quality which seems to be involved here.
- chris_va 11y agoSeems pretty simple, really. 1000 patients come in with symptoms that look like cancer at year 0. 100 actually get diagnosed with cancer at some point between year 0 and year 5. Presumably, the remaining 900 didn't have cancer at year 0.
- throwanem 11y ago
- VeejayRampay 11y agoThe National Health Service (NHS) is the publicly funded healthcare system for England (source: Wikipedia) Putting that here because I was confused about what NHS was in the first place (I'm French).
- njs12345 11y agoThe world's 5th largest employer (just after McDonald's)..
- arethuza 11y agoThere isn't really a single NHS - there are four National Health Services for the four parts of the UK (England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Health_Service https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Health_Service
- grillvogel 11y agobest part of this is when we reach the skynet robot uprising they'll know exactly how to kill us the fastest
- aub3bhat 11y agoWhy are people astonished? For more than a decade researchers have been able to get access to large deidentified datasets. As a PhD student I have access to data on 150 Million visits by 45 Million patients. In some ways the data and access I have is superior to that of Google & NHS (since UK is a tiny country in comparison to USA), and I am just a PhD student. Though I have been working on it for last 5 years. Recently there is a new qualified entity program run by CMS which provides access to Medicare data. You can read more about my research and see the demo of the system in my past submissions and at http://www.computationalhealthcare.com http://www.computationalhealthcare.com Also for the actual govenment program http://www.ahrq.gov/research/data/index.html http://www.ahrq.gov/research/data/index.html Actually when it comes to Medical information its a much much more complex problem legally. This paper gives a good overview on issue of "Patient ownership of data" http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1857986 http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1857986 I am by no means minimizing the concenrs that people have. But I think the article paints Google in negative light while ignoring current standard practices. I wish the discussion would be more rooted in the facts about how such data sharing systems work currently.
- fweespee_ch 11y ago> Why are people astonished? Because politicians keep making promises in regards to privacy that they don't keep in regards to "confidential" information. Similarly, most of the medical value from such information [e.g. Frequency of X within a given population fitting certain characteristics] would likely deanonymize people.
- DanBC 11y agoNo politician was involved in this decision.
- fweespee_ch 11y agohttp://www.bbc.com/news/uk-16021240 http://www.bbc.com/news/uk-16021240 > "All necessary safeguards would be in place to ensure protection of patients' details - the data will be anonymised and the process will be carefully and robustly regulated. > "Proper regulation and essential safeguards need to be in place when it comes to patients data," he said. "It cannot be done in a way where essential rules are threatened." The legality of these data sharing laws start off with public promises of anonymization, robust regulation, safeguards, and privacy. https://www.england.nhs.uk/2014/01/geraint-lewis/ https://www.england.nhs.uk/2014/01/geraint-lewis/ > Amber data are where we remove each patient’s identifiers (their date of birth, postcode, and so on) and replace them with a meaningless pseudonym that bears no relationship to their “real world” identity. Amber data are essential for tracking how individuals interact with the different parts of the NHS and social care over time. For example, using amber data we can see how the NHS cares for cohorts of patients who are admitted repeatedly to hospital but who seldom visit their GP. In theory, a determined analyst could attempt to re-identify individuals within amber data by linking them to other data sets. For this reason, we never publish amber data. Instead, amber data are only made available under a legal contract to approved analysts for approved purposes. The contract stipulates how the data must be stored and protected, and how the data must be destroyed afterwards. Any attempt to re-identify an individual is strictly prohibited and there is a range of criminal and civil penalties for any infringements. The problem with psuedonymous data is the NHS basically admits it can be used to identify people given sufficient effort. --- That is why people are "astonished" by these decisions. The politician provides the initial promises that imply anonymity, the implementation doesn't provide true anonymity but provides criminal penalties for pulling off the mask, and then the data is handed to enough 3rd parties if such data is leaked its likely impossible to know by whom unless the data was tampered with to provide a per-contract identifier. I understand this specific decision did not involve a politician but the conversation was why people are surprised. How many people do you think really know the anonymity originally promised became a permeable pseudonym?
- superkamiguru 11y agoThere is no equivalent of HIPPA in the UK?
- aub3bhat 11y agoHIPPA stands for Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act. The "Privacy" component of HIPPA is very limited in scope. Even with HIPPA the data being shared would be consistent with definition of "Limited" dataset.[0] At least in United States there is significant precedent for sharing such data, including even for marketing purposes as decided by Supreme Court case (IMS Health vs Sorrell). [0]http://www.hopkinsmedicine.org/institutional_review_board/hipaa_research/limited_data_set.html http://www.hopkinsmedicine.org/institutional_review_board/hi...