3 ms·
> RISC instruction sets like PowerPC are usually expected to be highly regular [..] whereas the CISC style of instruction set is expected to be highly irregular
by mpweiher 11y ago
> RISC instruction sets like PowerPC are usually expected to be highly regular [..] whereas the CISC style of instruction set is expected to be highly irregular and full of oddities
No. Not true at all. Not even close. CISC instructions are expected to be complex, hence the name. MC68K was pretty regular, NS32032 highly regular, both CISC.
RISC are reduced, not regular, so for example you'd expect memory access to only occur with specific memory access instructions, whereas all arithmetic and other computation only deals with registers.
So CISC was usually more regular, not less. x86 is the exception, because it was just extensions heaped on top of extensions: 8080 8 bit -> 8086 segmented 16 bit + 20 bit addresses -> 80286 protected 16 bit segmented with 24 bit addresses -> 80386 semi-segmented/mostly flat 32/32 bit, etc.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoThat's a point I haven't seen before. Yes, many x86 haters who tend to like RISC architectures typically praise M68K's for their ISA. Clearly there's something else outside of RISC and CISC. You might have figured it out. Maybe not. Worth thinking on.
- raverbashing 11y agotrue, at least in x86 16-bit just notice the limitations and special uses between ax/bx/cx/dx, etc
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]