11 ms·
The Feed Is Dying
- yolesaber 11y agoI recently got the algorithmic timeline for one of my more popular Twitter accounts. The algo has rendered it completely useless - it prioritizes all the wrong stuff and the lack of chronological ordering made it literally impossible to use during the debates. I wanted the sharp minute by minute commentary of my friends and news outlets but instead I was getting memes and dumb retweets from days ago. At least give the users the option to have a full chrono timeline - I can handle the "information overload" just fine on my own TYVM.
- drdeca 11y agoSupposedly if it is enabled for your account it can be disabled through menus the "while you were gone" cannot be though. I don't know this firsthand because it doesn't seem to have been enabled on my account.
- ttam 11y agothe "while you were gone" feature is easily dismissed with a refresh
- plorkyeran 11y agoYeah, the main effect of "while you were gone" is just that I have to reload the page twice when it stops updating or when I restart my browser. Dumb and mildly annoying, but only mildly.
- majewsky 11y agoIt's always amazing how much shit people will put up with as part of their daily routine.
- slyall 11y agoI like the "whiule you were" gone thing. Useful for when I woke up in the morning and it shows me half a dozen overnight tweets. Usually a couple of these are good. A few months ago the "gone" time got reduced to just a few hours which was a little annoying but survivable. I don't really want to go 100% algorithmic though. If I just wanted to see the popular stuff I'd follow buzzfeed or something.
- JoshTriplett 11y ago"While you were gone" breaks completely when it grabs one tweet out of a series of tweets, out of context. And it has far too subtle a break (a tiny bit of vertical whitespace and no new heading) to indicate the end of the "highlights" and the start of the content I actually want.
- oneeyedpigeon 11y ago'Series of tweets' pretty much break everything anyway. Twitter should discourage them, IMO.
- JoshTriplett 11y agoSure; and while they're at it, they could get rid of the "reply" button and the notion that people are talking to each other rather than at each other.
- Jgrubb 11y agoOn the web version go Settings -> Account. Under the "Content" section uncheck "show me the best tweets first". iOS app has a similar setting, and it stays synced with whatever is set there so however you disable it.
- yolesaber 11y agoYou are a Golden God!
- md224 11y agoI don't know... I unchecked that a while back and I still get annoying "while you were gone..." curated shit. Maybe I have to log out/in or something?
- iLoch 11y agoNo that's just Twitter trying to jam bullshit down your throat.
- zippergz 11y agoYou should unfollow the people who are posting bullshit. That's all stuff from people you chose to follow.
- majewsky 11y agoHe's talking about the ordering, not the content. Even a carefully curated list of followers will be resulted in a timeline that's destroyed by Twitter's bizarre attempts to drive your attention towards the paid content that's forced on you.
- zippergz 11y agoWhile you were gone is different from the algorithmic feed. It's a short section you can easily scroll past to get to the main feed. The algorithmic feed re-sorts the whole thing.
- dk8996 11y agoI agree with you for live stuff but for other things where you were away for 3 hr, I think I would want something that gives me the best Tweets.
- joelrunyon 11y agoUse tweetbot instead of twitter. It's so much better in every way.
- gue5t 11y agoWhen users don't own their technology, they get jerked around by whoever does until they jump ship for greener pastures. You can claim the market will solve this (users will sell their time and speech to a higher bidder, now that Twitter's prices no longer seem competitive), but if people were empowered to have their computers do what they want, it never would have happened in the first place.
- PretzelFisch 11y agoWhat user owned communication network ever caught on en mass and is used by most of the establishment?
- meric 11y agoEmail.
- AndrewKemendo 11y agoNot even close - at least not for consumers. See: @aol, @yahoo, @hotmail, @comcast, @gmail etc.... Enterprises usually own their servers, so I would grant that caveat, but even that is going away with cloud providers.
- dangerlibrary 11y agoEmail is an open protocol that many providers have implemented. That's an important distinction. Try sending a tweet to a Weibo user and see how that works out.
- AndrewKemendo 11y agoI would argue that it doesn't matter if the bulk of use is though closed interactions like web mail providers. Usage defines the capability. Just like anything.
- k2enemy 11y ago
- partiallypro 11y agoThe Feed is fantastic for live, on going events. I don't see how it can be replaced. Of course Twitter has meandered in using an algorithm in their timeline, which is just a huge mistake. The entire point of Twitter is that it's the world as it is happening now; it's still shocking that Jack, etc don't understand this fact and are continually trying to take the very things that made Twitter unique out of the platform.
- askafriend 11y agoIt can't be replaced but it can be made easily mutable. For example, imagine a quick-switcher that flips the feed from algorithmic to time based with a single tap. That's a powerful feature and adapts twitter to different use-cases fast. I think the key here is to give users options instead of trying to shepard them into a particular direction, especially with their bipolar userbase (e.g. people use Twitter for various, seemingly disjoint use cases)
- partiallypro 11y agoBut making the algorithmic feed the default, alone, is enough to kill the platform. For the mere fact of nudging, and human laziness. It will just make the shit rise to the top, instead of the hidden gems that make Twitter golden. Twitter has to be one of the most poorly run tech companies, outside of Yahoo. They changed their API token limits, and destroyed 3rd party clients. They bought TweetDeck and then utterly destroyed it. Live data is their product, but they bury it with stupid business decisions; utterly baffling. They tout MAUs during their conference calls (which they always miss), but that has nothing to do with their product. Their product has some of the top content providers, providing unique content in real time. Facebook can't say that, no other platform sans Snapchat can say that. Facebook has figured this out and that's why they are rolling out offerings like Paper. Twitter doesn't get it.
- askafriend 11y agoI completely agree with you on all counts. Why they forced the algo as a default is a mystery to me. I mean...the old Discover tab was fantastic and if they filtered that with their new algos, then I think people would love the result! Instead we get a static list of top news (Moments) that you can find on Yahoo's homepage.
- vonklaus 11y agoSearch Engine wars are incoming. End of 2017.
- d02 11y agoIf The Feed dies, will The Seed supplant it?
- Animats 11y ago"Enter the curated feed" We could call it a "blog", and the people who curate the feeds could be called "bloggers".
- dk8996 11y agoThis would work but in this case the "bloggers" (who curates the feed) doesn't create the content. There is still blog, bloggers (creating content), and the thing that curates the content.
- andrewstuart2 11y agoInevitably there will be too much content to digest, though. At that point we might create services that offer smaller "blogs," with limited-length content. Maybe call them "microblogs."
- wpietri 11y agoI follow quite a number of people more for what they select than what they say. So we could call it Twitter, and the people who curate could be called "retweeters".
- ilamont 11y agoThe other thing about the transformation of my Twitter feed is it is now mostly oriented toward images - photos, dancing GIFs, videos, or logos associated with accounts being retweeted. Sometimes the people I follow append the images, but most of the time Twitter attaches the images to individual tweets or RTs. It's possible to disable most of the images on my phone (via the Twitter app settings), but on the Web the images cannot be stopped. Even if autoplay videos are disabled, the preview image will still show up. It's irritating and lowers the value of the feed I have created on Twitter. Most of the time I just want to read opinions or retweets of the people I follow without an image or logo getting in my way.
- intrasight 11y agoFilter out the images. They don't fit in 140 characters and thus shouldn't even be there.
- sbierwagen 11y agoTwitter rolled out the algorithmic TL to my account the other day. Of the first 12 tweets on my TL, 8 were really badly targeted ads,[1] and the other four was one of my friends liveblogging a TV show I don't care about. Twitter shuffled the order of her tweets in doing so, of course. The promise is that algorithmic TL will show you the best organic tweets, and relevant ads. In practice, the ads are trash and the organic tweets are just as bad as usual, but in the wrong order. 1: Diapers, cars. I don't have kids, and while I've been looking at cars, I sure as hell won't buy a new one.
- equalsnil 11y agoOh wow, your recall rate is excellent. Thank you, Citizen! The advertising is working!
- tschellenbach 11y agoI think there is a place for both chronological and personalized feeds. Chronological works well if the realtime component is absolutely essential to your app. For apps that have a lot of content or users visiting infrequently you will often want to show the best content, not the latest content. That's where the personalized feeds come in. I believe Twitter and Instagram are doing this because the chronological feeds don't work well for a large portion of their users. You do wonder why they don't disable it for their most active users. (why try to reorder something if the user sees it all anyway?) We provide both chronological, ranked and personalized feeds over at getstream.io Demand for personalized feeds is definitely picking up rapidly, also among smaller apps.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- zatkin 11y agoWhat other ways are there to present content to users if it's not through a feed?
- emmab 11y agoTopic hierarchy involving either vote based sorting, temporal sorting, or personal relevance sorting. e.g. forum -> subforum -> thread; HN's comment system. You can extend it to allow multiple topic parents via a tagging system, but this usually seems to complicate things. facebook has wall -> post -> comments, but could add richer hierarchy above post
- dredmorbius 11y agoThe algorithm is an idiot. My social medium of choice is, despite my many and loud gripes about it, Google+. It's not even nearly awesome (none of the major options are), but, for a while at least, it offered two compelling features. The first is Notifications. Action on your own posts, posts with which you've interacted, and (selected) people mentioning you, will show up in your Notifications list (which ought be a stream in its own right). This is, if you think about it, one of the highest possible signifiers of relevance: something you've already indicated an interest in in which others are interacting, often directly with you. The other was Search. After a couple of years, even the vast wasteland of G+ had accumulated a catalog of interesting posts, and via Search those could be found. Search was always a bastard child, and it's considerably worse now than it had been for a long time, but given a keyword signifier, it would, sometimes, return relevant content. I actually wrote a really embarassing mash note to G+ management -- Vic and the project's then product manager -- highlighting this. The response of Google was, of course, to kill both features, or attempt to do so valiently. The problem with the algorithm is that at best it can guess or assume intent. But it never fucking bothers to ask you directly, or to allow you to indicate your preferences. I've likened this to a good salesperson. These exist, and I've on occasion, despite my anti-commercial tendencies, encountered and appreciated them. The good one will size you up as you enter a store, compose a good idea of what you're looking for, consider elements (say size or measurements for clothing), and match these with stock. Then they'll ask you what you're looking for. They'll return with a selection of items and, often, a few others. They'll read your responses, even subtle, on what's been offered and take a "no" as a "no". That is the one feature that is missing from virtually all current electronic information interfaces. I wanted, an hour or so back, to tell Amazon to show me only books published matching a subject from 1990-1999. Actually, filtering by cover colour would also have been useful. No can do. For media streams, the thing I most want to do is filter crap. Again, G+ offers no such capabilities. There are websites I never want to see (say, WSJ at HN), topics or people I don't care to hear about, etc. The best option I've got is to uncircle or block crap, which actually works quite well. But finer controls would be hugely useful. Twitter's experiment seems to be headed the same way. And it's not going to work. Because the algorithm is an idiot.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- nikanj 11y agoThis is get for having psych majors optimize the feed for an optimal mix of reward/stale to achieve maximum addictivity. Skinner box, now available in Facebook
- swrobel 11y agoThis is not news. We feeble humans cannot continue to drink from the ever-growing reverse-chronological firehose. Algorithms will only get better. Progress marches on.
- jcoffland 11y agoThe "X is dying" article is dying. But seriously, I know every journalist wants to be the first to call the end of a trend but this is like calling the end of sentences or puppies. Time organised lists are here to stay.
- settsu 11y agoAny journalist that "wants to be the first to call the end of a trend" has ceased being a journalist and has become a marketer.
- deanclatworthy 11y agoThere is a giant possible Game Of Thrones spoiler from last night's episode in the image of this article. Be warned. I haven't watched the episode yet but now I'm rather annoyed.
- petepete 11y agoThank you for this, I haven't clicked.
- mrweasel 11y ago>Unfortunately, chronological order doesn’t scale well. True, I guess, but what if my feed is already curated, by me. Facebook, for instance is annoying to use, because it can't seem to remember that I just want everything, in chronological order. I don't have a ton a people on Facebook, nor do I care to, but I do want to see everything these people post. It won't amount to more than 30 minutes of content a week anyway. If you had to enable "curated feed", would you turn it on? For most people, even those who have a large number friends or follow a ton of people/companies, I suspect the answer would be no.
- rdslw 11y agoI see two big problems with algorithmic/curated feeds: * conflict of interest between reader and (algo) curator. FB (as an example) wants reader to stay as long as possible on its site and to make the reader to regular comeback to FB, including preferring by the reader FB and not others. This is done by (algo) curator playing with our dopamine levels (read novelty seeking preference of human brains) presenting things which create 1 (stay) and 2 (comeback). In fact feed is curated based only on 1 and 2 with constantly run A/B experiments by FB. This is WRONG to reader. * all this 'feeling connected' being 'within circle of similar to you people' etc, puts you in a closed circle of opinions/views. This cramps critical thinking of the reader. Whats' more dangerous, it distorts (humans are really weak on this) our view how world is composed. We see too much of sth, and dont see (curator removed them) things we don't agree with. We conclude how world is constructed (e.g. everybody supports some presidency candidate, because 80% of "likes" and "shares" in my stream are about him (concluded by curator because I clicked on some of them). This has WRONG influence on our learning and critical thinking and forms untrue perception of world impairing our reasoning. p.s. sorry for my english.
- hebbarp 11y agoHow about time being the best curator? I see what is live. I have a choice to see the past by scrolling back. I can't see the future, well for obvious reasons. For news/event based content, chronological is the best bet, IMHO. For content of archival value, one can apply various curation techniques. So the assertion that the feed is dying is wrong. It can't and it won't.
- sambe 11y agoI've really felt like there's been a large decrease in feed quality of the last six months to one year on Facebook and Twitter. Feed is now dominated by adverts, endlessly shared click-bait, repeat content (especially if conspiratorial/shocking/fake - a variation on click bait), and the "you interact with this person sometimes, here's everything they ever do". And begging me to follow Zuckerberg. Compared to a couple of years ago it seems boring and shallow. FB is particularly bad, but partly seems my friends are part of the problem (and/or click bait is hugely on the rise; it works). Twitter maybe a bit less so, but this out-of-sequence stuff is terrible. Also miss the early Twitter days when I found interesting randoms to follow from the public firehose, now all celebrity focussed.
- Yhippa 11y agoIt would be nice if they could prioritize things by letting the user indicate "I want to see more/less of this stuff" and then build the algorithm based on that. I bet they did their testing on that and realized that users never end up doing that so they're going to try to come up with their own strategy. I agree with you, my feed has really dropped in quality even after blocking clickbaity sources like BuzzFeed and other content farms.
- staticelf 11y agoI disagree, the curated feed sucks and spending time on facebook proves it.
- ThomPete 11y agoHmm I don't understand the point of this article. A feed is a feed. It doesn't matter how it's created. There is utility to the chronological feed as there is the the algorithmic. Curation has been happening for a very long time. The problem is that it's not enough even to curate. For those who experience the problem, the issue really is that they have so much information of potential relevance but still can't read more than one feed item at a time (unless it's just pictures) http://000fff.org/wp-content/uploads/2009/12/model_01.png http://000fff.org/wp-content/uploads/2009/12/model_01.png This wont be solved by it being curated because that introduces another problem which is whether you trust the curation. Not sure it can ever be solved. But the feed isn't dying. It's fundamental.
- r721 11y agoI wish services would be clearer with how much of content the user I follow produces on average. Let's say, I consume 1000 tweets per day on average, therefore I shouldn't follow someone who produces 500 tweets per day, and really think about following someone with 100 tweets per day.
- tehabe 11y agoI actually get confused when I see something on Facebook which has been posted three days ago. Also I'm not really sure Facebook knows what I want to read. There is no "I don't want to read those posts right now" button.
- takno 11y agoWhat's even better is that I've almost always seen the 3 day old post (and often even liked it) 3 days ago, but it's apparently still the "most relevant" thing for me to see. I do wonder if I'd appreciate the algorithmic model better if the algorithms weren't just so damn bad
- inthewoods 11y agoIt'd be nice if there was any form of data to support the position of the article. I know that among my non-technical friends there seems to be no worry about algo feed vs time-based feed - and there doesn't seem to be any slow down in their scrolls through their Facebook/Instagram/Twitter feeds. I get wanting to call a change, but lacking any data it's hard to take seriously.
- mrmondo 11y agoI've seen a lot of this recently yet I find myself using and enjoying Twitter and RSS more than ever, not saying it's wrong - but it is an interesting outlier if correct en mass.
- karmacondon 11y agoGoing to use HN for some quick market research... would anyone be willing to pay for a human curated news feed? Say $10 or $20 a month for someone to go through news sources and pick out the stories that will be interesting to you, and potentially summarize them? I'm thinking of curation based on a personal relationship instead of an algorithm. You would indicate that you're interested in machine learning, libertarian politics and cooking (or whatever), and people would check hn, new york times, etc and compile lists of those items. I know it's not the same thing as this post, but it's a problem and I'm wondering if anyone else feels it strongly enough to pay for a solution.
- berberous 11y agoFYI, this is what Jason Hirschborn does with a number of verticals (fashion, media, tech, etc): http://recode.net/2014/05/01/read-this-jason-hirschhorns-newsletter-business-just-raised-a-seed-round/ http://recode.net/2014/05/01/read-this-jason-hirschhorns-new... I personally have unsubscribed as I favor RSS feeds, but I recommend them highly for people looking for someone else to weed through the crap for you. He does a great job. I don't think he's begun charging yet. I wouldn't pay. I suspect he could get a decent niche to pay though.
- notduncansmith 11y agoThat's still an algorithm, you just have humans executing it (and introducing some entropy in the process). Cue Minsky empty-room koan.
- a_small_island 11y agoNo, because I find I'm interesting in many things I wasn't aware of before reading about them.
- overcast 11y agoAll the more reason I've felt better about closing my "social media" accounts. The little that was useful, has been rendered worthless.
- erichocean 11y ago[DELETED]
- mynegation 11y agoAsk your friend if they have a patent.If they do not - tell them to get it first. Then try to do something with it, they can always sell it if that does not work.
- WWKong 11y agoSo feed is dying or not? Seems it is thriving with curation?