4 ms·
Okay, first of all, that's bullshit. ISDS (Investor-State Dispute Settlement) is a sane concept. The implementation might have problems (for example closed cou
by pas 11y ago
Okay, first of all, that's bullshit.
ISDS (Investor-State Dispute Settlement) is a sane concept. The implementation might have problems (for example closed courtroom "trials"), but it's not about protecting profits. It's about protecting equality and fairness for all before the law, and in case of States, holding them accountable to make fair and egalitarian laws.
What's the typical example? A random Company invests in a country, sets up a nice subsidiary starts doing business, everything is legal. But the country (the State) sees that it's taking up the market, uh-oh,
a) better make a law against whatever they are doing, or
b) better make a law against (that specific or all) foreign companies doing whatever.
Which one(s) is (are) problematic?
Also, the other thing, fairness, comes in when a State wants to buy out a company but doesn't want to pay market price. Basically eminent domain without unfair compensation.
The same goes for ending tax breaks (or other investment incentives) sooner than promised. Because that's a breach of agreement.
Your link (publicfinanceinternational.org) refers an article from globaljustice.co.uk which has a list of problematic ISDS arbitration cases, that's the real data, anything else is just fluff. ( http://www.globaljustice.org.uk/sites/default/files/files/resources/taxes-on-trial-how-trade-deals-threaten-tax-justice-global-justice-now.pdf http://www.globaljustice.org.uk/sites/default/files/files/re... )
Let's look at the big bully US agribusiness vs Mexico (the rules of arbitration are set by NAFTA).
http://www.state.gov/s/l/c42198.htm http://www.state.gov/s/l/c42198.htm
http://www.italaw.com/sites/default/files/case-documents/ita0133_0.pdf http://www.italaw.com/sites/default/files/case-documents/ita... the concrete "award" (findings of the tribunal).
It turns out that these tribunals are looking at laws and apply them. Like courts. And they are much likely more objective than any court in either host country. And then that award was reviewed by the courts of a place chosen by the parties (the Ontario court system).
Seems quite like due process to me.
I'm not saying all of the cases are jolly good and there was absolutely no problematic awards, but just looking at the Vodafone vs India one, the "retrospective capital gains tax" hits us and makes you wonder, what the fuck were the Indians thinking, first rule of how to legislate. ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legal_certainty https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legal_certainty )
But enough on ISDS. There are big problems with TTIP, but not this one.
- mikemoka 11y ago"A random Company invests in a country, sets up a nice subsidiary starts doing business, everything is legal. But the country (the State) sees that it's taking up the market, uh-oh," when this has been done and when it has happened not in the interest of public well being? on the other hand here is an example of what some corporations actually do in the present https://youtu.be/6UsHHOCH4q8?t=6m54s https://youtu.be/6UsHHOCH4q8?t=6m54s
- pas 11y agoYes, I watch LWT, I'm familiar with the Philip Morris' crazy carnival through arbitration tribunals, but they are just grasping at straws. http://theconversation.com/big-tobacco-vs-australia-philip-morris-scores-an-own-goal-4967 http://theconversation.com/big-tobacco-vs-australia-philip-m... The Uruguay v Philip Morris is the same, they claim that they have a right to use their trademark on packages. Might be true, the tribunal will find out. Still Uruguay can still ban tobacco altogether. This is the equivalent of a frivolous lawsuit. It's part of the system, and it's okay. It gives transparency to the whole big companies (investors) and even bigger organizations (states) interactions, and tries to keep things equal and fair, all in all objective and unbiased. Eventually Philip Morris will lose. (Though there might not be a loser-pays scheme in force for this case, but in general it's up to the treaty to establish the rules of arbitration, plus usually the tribunal itself has such powers, but in the future more and more cases will follow the UNCITRAL model, which do require the loser to pay for the costs of litigation. https://books.google.com/books?id=h1H8Er1Y8X8C&pg=PA108&lpg=PA108&dq=UNCITRAL+loser+pays&source=bl&ots=gPaVdpBLF3&sig=VULPXK7osAzDbx1gLqgCNZsL5tA&hl=en&sa=X&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q=UNCITRAL%20loser%20pays&f=false https://books.google.com/books?id=h1H8Er1Y8X8C&pg=PA108&lpg=... )
- Silhouette 11y agoThis is an interesting article I remembered from a few months ago about the analogous provisions in a similar international trade deal, the Trans-Pacific Partnership. The legal experts commenting there don't seem to share your optimistic view of how these kinds of laws work in practice, so unless all of the issues they raise have been differently addressed in the TTIP wording, it appears there is cause for concern. http://www.theguardian.com/business/2015/nov/10/tpps-clauses-that-let-australia-be-sued-are-weapons-of-legal-destruction-says-lawyer http://www.theguardian.com/business/2015/nov/10/tpps-clauses...