4 ms·
Dan it's really unusual you're coming into the conversation like this. I'm recounting a year of very direct, repeated personal experience: if they do care, they
by nailer 11y ago
Dan it's really unusual you're coming into the conversation like this. I'm recounting a year of very direct, repeated personal experience: if they do care, they've had every opportunity to show it.
Other Airbnb neighbors may have a great time, but that doesn't mean I'm 'generalising' about them in a 'not fine' way when recounting my honest feelings after repeatedly dealing with them.
It's an odd coincidence my comment went from the top comment on this article to far down the thread in a single reload.
- tptacek 11y agoI think I disagree with Dan here (on the substance, not the process). But it's not unusual for him to wade into conversations like this. What he's objecting to is an instance of a pattern that he has consistently been objecting to over the the last 9 months or so: commenters extrapolating the public policy intentions of organizations based on reporting about the behavior of those organizations. There's a term for that kind of reasoning: fundamental attribution error. Given a couple minutes with the HN search bar, you can quickly find several other recent places where Dan has raised the same objections with respect to other companies. I think "not attributing unproven intentionality to organizations" is a pretty good norm for HN to adopt. That doesn't mean you can't make the argument that Airbnb is having a toxic effect on particular cities! It just means you can't make the lazy emotional appeal that Airbnb is run by people who don't care about toxicity.
- throwawaymaroon 11y agoBut it's not clear--and it should be--whether Dan is advocating for a norm yet to be instated, policing a norm he happens to think is a good idea, or just taking part in conversation. Opens up some really ugly, probably baseless speculation ("It's an odd coincidence my comment went from the top comment on this article to far down the thread in a single reload") for no real reason. Does he have his moderator hat on? I'd say not, I'd say he's raising an objection as his own opinion, for the simple reason that as far as I can tell there isn't actually a guideline he can cite. And he's certainly within his right to enter a conversation this way. But he should have the political acumen to know that when he disagrees with someone as dang, he's not just another person with an opinion, he's The Moderator, and the first response is to disagreement (particularly about tone) is "Am I being punished?" And if he actually was putting on the moderator hat, he'd do better to actually build the guideline rather than try to enforce it with this meager display of non-authority. I'm surprised he doesn't have another account for conversational posting; but then, you Reputation Enforcement types tend to cling to attributing ideas to names. >Given a couple minutes with the HN search bar, you can quickly find several other recent places where Dan has raised the same objections with respect to other companies. I find this objectionable. I consider myself reasonably skilled with the search bar but don't know exactly what to search for. The only thing I can think of is "overgeneralized denunciation" but that sure doesn't work. If you're going to say "Fuck off until you know how to search HN" like this you should maybe provide an example of a relevant search query. But frankly that's a pointless objection, because your real argument is that there's some Community Knowledge about Dan's position that you think is public knowledge. Guess I disagree, but as the more reputable community member it is of course your opinion that matters.
- rolux 11y agoWell, to be fair: Airbnb is run by people who intend to profit from the toxicity of their business -- for places like Berlin, where what they "disrupt" is not so much the hotel industry but the city's housing politics, and many local communities.
- nailer 11y ago> commenters extrapolating the public policy intentions of organizations based on reporting about the behavior of those organizations I am recounting a year of direct personal experience, no reporting is involved.