7 ms·
An interview with Scott Aaronson touches the some subject: "Scott Aaronson on Philosophical Progress" [1]: Luke (interviewer): [...] I’ve previously called p
by weinzierl 11y ago
An interview with Scott Aaronson touches the some subject: "Scott Aaronson on Philosophical Progress" [1]:
Luke (interviewer):
[...]
I’ve previously called philosophy a “diseased discipline[2],” for many reasons. For one thing, people working in philosophy-the-field tend to know strikingly little about the philosophical progress made in other fields, e.g. computer science or cognitive neuroscience. For another, books on the history of philosophy seem to be about the musings of old dead guys who were wrong about almost everything because they didn’t have 20th century science or math, rather than about actual philosophical progress, which is instead recounted in books like The Information[3].
[...]
Scott:
[...]
You’re right that these “old dead guys” didn’t know all the math and science we know today, but then again, neither did Shakespeare or Dostoyevsky! I mean, sure, the central questions of philosophy have changed over time, and the human condition has changed as well: we no longer get confused over Zeno’s paradoxes or the divine right of kings, and we now have global telecommunications and the Pill. I just don’t think either human nature or human philosophical concerns have changed quickly enough for great literature on them written centuries ago to have ceased being great.
[...]
[1] https://intelligence.org/2013/12/13/aaronson/ https://intelligence.org/2013/12/13/aaronson/
[2] http://lesswrong.com/lw/4zs/philosophy_a_diseased_discipline/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/4zs/philosophy_a_diseased_discipline...
[3] http://www.amazon.com/Information-History-Theory-Flood-ebook/dp/B004DEPHUC/ http://www.amazon.com/Information-History-Theory-Flood-ebook...
- superobserver 11y agoOne might say this is something of an over-generalization when one realizes that there were monumental figures like Charles Sanders Peirce -- but then one recalls he has ironically only but recently come in vogue in philosophy-the-field, such that many of the old heads schooled in even today's philosophy can barely fathom his work. Philosophy-the-field is indeed a dead end. One can merely step back and be awed with the romantic ideal of architectonics as dimly intimated by most today.
- takno 11y agoI think the question asked of Scott badly mischaracterizes Philosophy as I've seen it taught and studied. Philosophers interested in mind and cognition tend to take a great deal of interest in developments in CS and neuroscience. On the other hand it is entirely typical of a subset of researchers in fields like CS to think that 20th century science gives them all the answers and to demean anybody who wants them to think about whether they are even asking the right questions.
- empath75 11y agoIt's hard to argue that cutting edge CS like category theory and homotopy type theory isn't philosophical in nature.
- Xcelerate 11y agoI can't tell if you're being sarcastic, but I actually agree with your statement.
- 78666cdc 11y ago>Philosophers interested in mind and cognition tend to take a great deal of interest in developments in CS and neuroscience. And they tend to mangle it by inserting rigorous scientific results into a nonrigorous framework that often ends up being a game of word association played using misunderstandings of basic science.