5 ms·
As an AirBnB customer (which I was) you have no idea what it's like to be an Airbnb neighbor. There are parties with hundreds of kids on the roof, weed smoked
by nailer 11y ago
As an AirBnB customer (which I was) you have no idea what it's like to be an Airbnb neighbor.
There are parties with hundreds of kids on the roof, weed smoked in the hall outside our apartment, a broken front door that can only be closed by smashing as hard as possible or not at all, stains all over the carpet outside the Airbnb, people breaking into our house because they're drunk, people buzzing every apartment because they've locked themselves out and it's 4AM. The place is a 365 day Airbnb, which is illegal, and Airbnb know that too and don't care.
AirBnB refuse to take any responsibility, even just to raise issues with the person running the BnB. They have even repeatedly said they can't find a listing by address - seriously, not that the address is wrong, but they they simply do not have the capability. We can't speak to the neighbor because they don't live there, they just rent out their apartment on Airbnb. They got journalists to write stories about how they'd soon have an app for neighbours last year - it still isn't rolled out in Europe despite all the press.
Love airBnB as a customer. 95% of guests are fine. 4% do stupid shit because they're drunk, which is understandable, but having continuously drunk 'neighbors' sucks. 1% are deliberately anti social. But the company absolutely does not give a damn about their impact on the people around them.
Tip for anyone else: call your police non-emergency number or your council. Avoid Airbnb support. They can't help and they won't take responsibility for the source of their income.
- dang 11y ago> But the company absolutely does not give a damn about their impact on the people around them. You can't know that and it by no means follows from what you've said. It's fine to describe your specific experiences, but not fine to cross into overgeneralized denunciation. Especially not to gin up indignation, which is pretty much the sole purpose of overgeneralized denunciation.
- nailer 11y agoDan it's really unusual you're coming into the conversation like this. I'm recounting a year of very direct, repeated personal experience: if they do care, they've had every opportunity to show it. Other Airbnb neighbors may have a great time, but that doesn't mean I'm 'generalising' about them in a 'not fine' way when recounting my honest feelings after repeatedly dealing with them. It's an odd coincidence my comment went from the top comment on this article to far down the thread in a single reload.
- tptacek 11y agoI think I disagree with Dan here (on the substance, not the process). But it's not unusual for him to wade into conversations like this. What he's objecting to is an instance of a pattern that he has consistently been objecting to over the the last 9 months or so: commenters extrapolating the public policy intentions of organizations based on reporting about the behavior of those organizations. There's a term for that kind of reasoning: fundamental attribution error. Given a couple minutes with the HN search bar, you can quickly find several other recent places where Dan has raised the same objections with respect to other companies. I think "not attributing unproven intentionality to organizations" is a pretty good norm for HN to adopt. That doesn't mean you can't make the argument that Airbnb is having a toxic effect on particular cities! It just means you can't make the lazy emotional appeal that Airbnb is run by people who don't care about toxicity.
- throwawaymaroon 11y agoBut it's not clear--and it should be--whether Dan is advocating for a norm yet to be instated, policing a norm he happens to think is a good idea, or just taking part in conversation. Opens up some really ugly, probably baseless speculation ("It's an odd coincidence my comment went from the top comment on this article to far down the thread in a single reload") for no real reason. Does he have his moderator hat on? I'd say not, I'd say he's raising an objection as his own opinion, for the simple reason that as far as I can tell there isn't actually a guideline he can cite. And he's certainly within his right to enter a conversation this way. But he should have the political acumen to know that when he disagrees with someone as dang, he's not just another person with an opinion, he's The Moderator, and the first response is to disagreement (particularly about tone) is "Am I being punished?" And if he actually was putting on the moderator hat, he'd do better to actually build the guideline rather than try to enforce it with this meager display of non-authority. I'm surprised he doesn't have another account for conversational posting; but then, you Reputation Enforcement types tend to cling to attributing ideas to names. >Given a couple minutes with the HN search bar, you can quickly find several other recent places where Dan has raised the same objections with respect to other companies. I find this objectionable. I consider myself reasonably skilled with the search bar but don't know exactly what to search for. The only thing I can think of is "overgeneralized denunciation" but that sure doesn't work. If you're going to say "Fuck off until you know how to search HN" like this you should maybe provide an example of a relevant search query. But frankly that's a pointless objection, because your real argument is that there's some Community Knowledge about Dan's position that you think is public knowledge. Guess I disagree, but as the more reputable community member it is of course your opinion that matters.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoDan, I downvoted you accidentally (my apologies), but I still disagree with you. I have yet to see any proof that AirBnB cares for anything other than to expand their reach and profitability. They'll partner with local governments to support tax collection, as its in their best interests (and costs them little but engineering time, as the tax is passed through to the customer/host), but its also in their best interest to disregard externalities such as that caused by less than desirable AirBnB customers. EDIT: They're the less abrasive version of Uber. Disruption needs to be balanced with societal benefits. Your startup does not exist in a vacuum, and you are one piece of legislation or court decision away from being regulated out of existence. Behave accordingly.
- danielweber 11y agoI've seen lots of people get upset because AirBnB is causing a problem and AirBnB is ignoring it. Like this guy, just a day ago, where someone made a fake listing for his house and they won't answer him. https://www.reddit.com/r/legaladvice/comments/4h5yo0/fl_someone_created_a_fake_airbnb_listing_of_my/ https://www.reddit.com/r/legaladvice/comments/4h5yo0/fl_some... Maybe it's the Upton Sinclair quote, "It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends upon his not understanding it!" Or it's just the New Economy. Twitter has 2300 employees. Microsoft, hardly the picture of perfect customer service, has almost 120,000. Guess which one you can get on the phone. You can't get valuations of millions of dollars per employee if you have employees trying to do things like answer complaints. Dealing with complaints is money-losing business, not money-making business.
- tptacek 11y agoMaybe it's the Upton Sinclair quote, "It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends upon his not understanding it!" To me, I feel like you know you're in trouble on an HN thread when someone invokes that Upton Sinclair quote. There are very few conversations you can't shut down with it.
- troisx 11y agoI think it's pretty awful for a YCombinator employee to come into the comments and chastise a commenter for bashing a YCombinator company. In this case especially, as lots of abuse stories exist about Airbnb.
- tptacek 11y agoI think if you're going to make an accusation like that, you should sign your name to it.
- grapehut 11y agoThat's hardly fair. It's one thing to make an anonymous accusation like: "He touched me inappropriately", but troisx follows more of a "I think <these facts> are pretty awful", and does not rely on him or his experience to any extent. I really don't think Dan acted out of a conflict-of-interest, and in general I agree with the substance of his reply -- but a public chastising was out of place here.
- dang 11y agoI've addressed this many times. When YC companies are being discussed we apply moderation less, not more—but that doesn't mean we stop moderating altogether. That's the way HN has always worked, and I think it's a good balance. It wouldn't be fair for people to be exempt from HN's rules and standards just because they're criticizing YC or a startup YC funded. There's no substantive point about Airbnb or any other company that can't be expressed in the way my comment above is recommending. That ought to be obvious to anyone who reads it dispassionately and is familiar with HN.
- nailer 11y agoDan as mentioned upthread, if you think my repeated contact with AirBnB over a year, and the impression I've had as a result, isn't substantive, could you explain why or email me if you prefer? I've been on Startup News / Hacker News for eight years, so I'm pretty familiar with the site.
- spriggan3 11y agoWell did you report them to the proper authorities ? ( the organization managing the building, the city the cops ), because I can assure you it will shut down any illegal hotel quite fast.
- nailer 11y agoYep, exactly as recommended to others: police and council. This is why you need to invoke them early: you'll need to establish a documented history of anti social behaviour.
- nommm-nommm 11y agoThere's plenty of news stories on the Web of neighbors complaining of houses advertised as "party houses" on Airbnb with multiple parties a week many with police involvement including a police helicopter. Clearly Airbnb has doesn't do much to discourage this activity, even when the problem is well known.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- simoncion 11y ago> But the company absolutely does not give a damn about their impact on the people around them. Nor should they. This is a matter for local police and regulatory enforcement staff. If the local district's enforcement forces are too feeble to handle the workload, then they should be beefed up until they can handle it. If someone uses a kitchen knife to murder another human, the manufacturer of that knife is under no obligation to assist in any way with the investigation of that crime and the prosecution of the murderer. This is right and proper. This ever-intensifying cry to press private companies into service as investigative and police forces (rather than properly staffing and funding the relevant governmental offices) is deeply disturbing.