5 ms·
It's almost like cities (or more specifically, voters in municipal elections) don't realize that the only sustainable way to reduce prices is by increasing supp
by jseliger 11y ago
It's almost like cities (or more specifically, voters in municipal elections) don't realize that the only sustainable way to reduce prices is by increasing supply: http://www.amazon.com/TheRent-Too-Damn-High-Matters-ebook/dp/B0078XGJXO http://www.amazon.com/TheRent-Too-Damn-High-Matters-ebook/dp.... We know what to do, we have the technology, and we only lack the political will to make it happen.
- DasIch 11y agoBerlin is a poor city. In fact it's former mayor famously described it as "Poor but sexy". It doesn't have the liberty of increasing supply on it's own to a large extent. You also can't increase supply, no matter how much you want to, in the districts everyone wants to live in. Getting a place outside of it can be accomplished fairly easily.
- mafribe 11y agoIt would be rather easy to increase supply of housing. Berlin is full of brown-field sites that could be stacked with housing. 1. Remove density and height restrictions (e.g. "Berliner Traufhoehe"). 2. Remove unnecessarily strict building requirements (e.g. "Daemmungswahn"). 3. Remove legislation that is too tenant-friendly (e.g. "Mietbremse"). All three serve as breaks to increasing housing supply, the first is a legal impediment, the other two reduce investments.
- thesimon 11y agoI guess when you remove 3, you would increase the supply, but only with what you see for example in London: Mostly luxury flats Doesn't really help getting more affordable flats on the market.
- mafribe 11y agoBerlin has an extremely affordable rental market, unless you want to live in Mitte or nearby. Even Mitte would be more affordable, if 50-100 floor skyscrapers could get building permission. I'm not sure how familiar with the London property market. London is currently seeing a large amount of real estate being built, mostly studio, 1, 2 and 3 bedroom. Hardly luxurious. Prices are commensurate with London income levels. Otherwise people wouldn't live in London.
- DasIch 11y agoBefore you talk about how affordable Berlin is you need to take the income of people living in Berlin into consideration. You can reasonably live in Berlin but it's by no means extremely affordable. You also can't arbitrarily increase density of a city as you need infrastructure to go along with all those people. Not to mention that Berlin has many old buildings that are under protection, so you can't just demolish buildings and replace them with skyscrapers.
- thesimon 11y ago>Prices are commensurate with London income levels. Otherwise people wouldn't live in London. I feel like most people are moving to the outer zones. Buying flats in zone 1-3 is obviously out of reach for most people, even for most developers not working in The City. From what I've seen, even 1-bedroom flats cost at least £310k near Seven Sisters (Zone 3). I have to admit though that I was mostly looking for flats to rent, not for sale in the last few months so I'm not an expert.
- mafribe 11y ago£310k near Seven Sisters That's not expensive relative to London income levels, given that property is typically financed over 25 years or so, basically over the most productive phase of one's working life, so it's paid off roughly when one retires. Most young people don't think long-term: they just look at the price and their current annual salary, and see a mismatch. Maybe it's good this way, because unless you realise that a property is a serious long-term investment, and that the target is to save for retirement, they probably don't have the financial maturity to make such a large purchase and should stick to renting. Note that property always reflects income-levels of the working population. That's because they are the ones that buy / rent property. Rent and property prices are strongly correlated, because it's fundamentally a risk/reward trade-off: when you buy you take on a fair amount of risk: heating may break down, the roof may leak, you might not find tenants in time, tenants may ruin the property, not pay rent etc etc (From bitter experience I can tell you that "may" really means "will"). Tenants don't carry this risk, hence need to compensate for this risk transfer. That's why renting appears to be more expensive. Focussing on foreign billionaires who buy-to-leave-empty distorts how the property market works. The real question is: what percentage of their income is the average person willing to invest in property / rent. This is remarkably constant.
- DasIch 11y agoThe problem isn't supply, it's supply in Prenzlauer Berg, Friedrichshain, Kreuzberg and Neukölln. If you want a place outside of these districts, you can get a place quite easily. Increasing supply outside of them, which would be easy because Berlin is surrounded by land you could build on won't change that. At least not without billions of investments in public transport infrastructure, maybe. Any regulation like building requirements is probably federal, I doubt Berlin has any extra regulation. So there is nothing Berlin can do here. Removing regulation that is too tenant-friendly isn't popular with voters, it's not going to increase the supply of apartments for students and poor people. This kind of regulation including but not limited to the Mietpreisbremse is also federal law and not something Berlin can do all that much about.
- mafribe 11y agoThere is no human right to rent a 100m2 flat in Mitte for €200 per month. Even central Berlin is full of brown-field sites that could be developed -- Flughafen Tempelhof most prominently. If you go for Hong Kong style density there, a lot of housing problems would be solved ... Laws can easily be changed if there is political will at the local, regional or federal levels. However, all this requires a bit of long-term thinking and planning, of which there is little evidence. Instead we get populist measures like "Mietpreisbremse" which hinder new developments.
- doener 11y agoTempelhof cannot be developed because of a plebiscite. What else is there to develop?
- mafribe 11y agoBerlin is jam-packed with undeveloped brown-field sites. Get rid of the restrictions on height, and build 50 - 100 floors Hong Kong style, at least in the center. Tempelhof shows the stupidity of the Berlin voter. The refusal to develop even a small part of the airfield was almost exclusively justified with fears of "gentrification". Congratulation voters, you have just voted yourself into higher rents. (Also, one could have a new "Volksbefragung", in the light of the dire need for more housing in Berlin.)
- bogomipz 11y agoBut in the article it says towards the end that Berlin in building 50K new units in the next 10-15 years. So in addition to banning AirBnB they are also increasing supply. I am unsure how or why "technology" plays into it unless you mean construction technology?
- losteric 11y agoHow many units were torn down to build those new units, and how desirable are they compared to the old units? What is the price range? How does the quality compare? Where are they located? One number doesn't capture the whole story. Seattle has a similar problem where we do have a large number of new units going up, but some places are still seeing upwards 50% vacancy after 3 years... because the new units aren't aligned with market demand. I'm talking luxury apartments downtown when the growing demographic is frugal-minded mid-20s/30s interested in neighborhoods 10-20 minute away from downtown. Even constructions in the right neighborhood end up being a net loss of desirable units when the rent is sky high.
- mahyarm 11y agoSounds like they have to start reducing the price to fill the oversupply...
- dzhiurgis 11y agoApparently London is suffering from similar issue. A lot of new appartments are luxurious and sold to foreign investors. In the end they are just sitting there unoccupied.
- makomk 11y agoThis is why loosening building restrictive is not a solution - builders always want to charge a premium over the existing market price, which means building expensive luxury flats and leaving new homes empty if necessary rather than reducing their prices.
- arximboldi 11y ago
- paulmd 11y agoRemoving residential units from the long-term lease market and turning them into overnight units does not increase supply, it actually reduces the number of units available for lease. This raises the equilibrium for lease units: less units available, higher prices. Not to mention the fact that leasers are now competing against people paying higher nightly rates.
- ptaipale 11y agoYes, but removal of units from the long-term lease market is not a reason for the problem; it is the consequence of imbalance caused by regulation (of zoning and now also rent control in Berlin). Berlin overall is an anomaly in Germany; during the Cold War division of Germany to BRD and DDR, living in Berlin was heavily subsidized, and that still shows up in the planning, the structures and the market. But the impact of a 40-year "siege" is going away now 25 years after it ended, and at the same time the capital has moved to Berlin, along with lots of administration and related jobs and businesses.