4 ms·
What it will take is creating a new system of research and development that ignores the traditional academic system. Because this has been a problem for a while
by moron4hire 11y ago
What it will take is creating a new system of research and development that ignores the traditional academic system. Because this has been a problem for a while and they clearly are not hearing the message.
The reason academic research works is because it takes risk on potential failures, because it's only donated or grant money anyways. But academic institutions fetishize academic papers, which is the problem from the article.
We need to legitimize research outside of the academic institution. Pay people to do research on their own time, if they perform it in an open-source, reproducible fashion. Incentivize it based on the reproducibility factor, but avoid attaching a profit motive.
Look at what Xerox PARC and Bell Labs were able to do before the penny-pinching bean counters took over.
Otherwise, it just sounds like "we want all this risky work done, and we don't want to pay for it."
- dinkumthinkum 11y agoThose academics at Bell labs, you mean the ones that published fundamental papers? I'm not sure that's an example of academics not writing papers.
- moron4hire 11y agoThe end result was not papers. The point was products. The papers were a byproduct. For most academic institutions, the entire point is the paper, whether it's useful to anyone or not.
- PeterisP 11y agoThe useful end result was definitely the papers. The products offer a proof of concept (that it works) and a demonstration (how the details add up). Then in future, others throw away the product (or observe it a bit) and make the next nice things (products for industry adaptations, or further research) mostly based on their papers.
- nycticorax 11y agoMaybe I've drunk the kool-aid, but saying "academic institutions fetishize academic papers" seems wrong to me. It's like saying that developers fetishize working applications. It's not a fetish, it's the whole point of the thing. The output of research is research papers. Yes, sharing raw data and code are both good things, and should be promoted. But no one is going to take the time to look at either unless the paper presents good evidence for some novel result.
- moron4hire 11y agoPapers don't do anything. Papers aren't executable. Papers are largely only useful in regards to writing other papers. To make the whole point of the exercise to be something that is inert and self-referential is the fetishization part.
- Retra 11y agoPapers teach people things. You can't really hand someone some working code and expect them to iterate on it to produce something novel and insightful, because it won't be written in a high-enough language to express the core concepts flexibly.
- moron4hire 11y agoI don't see how open source software is at all compatible with the view you've just expressed.
- throwaway2048 11y agohow much undocumented, uncommented open source code have you contributed to?
- mcguire 11y agoOut of curiosity, have you ever tried to learn say, networking by reading the Linux stack?
- 11y ago