4 ms·
The interesting thing is going to be the potential for "free as in speech" hardware. Before the problem was that hardware was vertically integrated. If you want
by AnthonyMouse 11y ago
The interesting thing is going to be the potential for "free as in speech" hardware. Before the problem was that hardware was vertically integrated. If you wanted a state of the art processor you had to use a design from a company with a state of the art fab because nobody else had the resources and inclination to update their design for every new process node.
If we get to the point that TSMC has the same technology as Intel and IBM and it never changes then some hardware hackers will eventually publish something like a 250MHz processor that uses 10 watts on that process, which will be "good enough" for some embedded devices to justify a fairly large production run. Then you have a community and people make incremental design improvements for the same reasons Google and others do for Linux and in a few years the free hardware design is above 2GHz and below one watt.
- bhouston 11y agoIsn't this was raspberry pi is?
- azernik 11y agoRaspberry Pi does not use open source hardware. The processor core (ARM) is proprietary. The GPU (VideoCore IV) is proprietary hardware, and even includes proprietary software in the form of microcode. And so on and so forth. Open source hardware refers to the silicon itself using open source designs.
- kyzyl 11y agoIndeed, Broadcom doesn't even allow you to buy their proprietary SoC (at least, last I checked), so you can't make a knock off RPi board, or integrate the SoC and peripherals into a custom application board. You need to use an RPi directly or get some other Cortex-A53 chip with a comparable architecture.
- dietrichepp 11y agoOpen source hardware refers to both the system level design and the IC level design. Credit where it's due, Raspberry PI is open hardware on the system level. You are right that it is not open on the IC level.
- adapteva 11y agoNonsense. It's not open at any level by normal definitions (although some of the software is open source). The Raspberry Pi is a wonderful thing. It's cheap and it works great...but it's not open.
- LukeShu 11y agoThe VC4 GPU is a lot worse than microcode! It's running the complete (proprietary) ThreadX operating system, regardless of what you choose to run on the ARM core.
- chongli 11y agoNo, but it is what RISC-V is! I'm really excited about RISC-V after reading Andrew Waterman's PhD thesis[0] on it from earlier today. [0] http://www.eecs.berkeley.edu/Pubs/TechRpts/2016/EECS-2016-1.pdf http://www.eecs.berkeley.edu/Pubs/TechRpts/2016/EECS-2016-1....
- code5fun 11y agoWill the US allow something like that happen? The future is developing towards hardware backdoors in all processors and this would make it really hard to implement such system. There is no way this is going to happen.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoI really doubt that's going to happen given that I've been pushing various parties to do it who have skills, EDA tools, and some academic funding. And it's still not done. My advise is still the same, though: put Gaisler's Leon3 SOC w/ key I/O on fab at 180nm-90nm using shuttleruns like Tekmos. Its been GPL with no action forever. Already has OSS software on it, too. SPARC compatible trademark only costs $99 if you wanted to be official. So, if there's such a will or demand, where's our open-source SOC that uses Leon3? It's been one MPW, packaging, and PCB run away forever. Still don't have one...
- adapteva 11y agoNot sure I see what the purpose of taping out Leon at 180nm? Is it just to have an open source CPU? Hardware is only useful if it's competitive.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoThe parent was satisfied with a low-performing chip that was fully open. There's a niche of people that want fully-open, inspectable hardware they control totally. I keep calling out proponents with Leon given they've been able to accomplish that at 350nm w/ visual inspection and 180-130nm affordably at least with OSS HW. Plus, there's quite a few open, cell libraries at 0.13nm. Anyway, you know what I wanted: open-source, 28nm FPGA w/ key I/O already included so I could synthesize my own CPU's and such on it. Verify one design in hardware, worry about the rest in simulation. You never got back to me on that one. Whether it was a good idea to solve most people's open-hardware concerns or what it might cost? (I'll say a Virtex-6 amount of slices or memories with USB 2.0, DDR3, PCI-E, SATA, and 10/100/1000 Ethernet onboard. Should do.)
- visarga 11y agoWe might not need full trust. We could just add a secondary processor isolated from the system which can run encryption and store its keys inside, like the iPhone does, but one that we are sure is not corrupted. Maybe the security processor could also run a firewall to filter out which app can communicate what.