10 ms·
Rule 41 Proposes to Grant New Hacking Powers to the Government
- ___ab___ 11y agoThe Judicial Conference of the United States is neither a "little-known committee" or in any way secretive or shady, unless one is totally ignorant of how the judicial system works. The EFF certainly is not. The conference is composed of: "the Chief Justice of the United States, the chief judge of each court of appeals federal regional circuit, a district court judge from various federal judicial districts, and the chief judge of the United States Court of International Trade." [0] You can disagree with their decisions, but don't try and imply that they are duplicitous. I expect better of the EFF. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Judicial_Conference_of_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Judicial_Conference_of_the_Uni...
- mmf 11y agoLittle known implies that if you ask 100 randomly selected people if they know if it exists, what it is and what it does, a small number, say less than 10 or so (little) will know. Did you take your educated guess at that fraction?
- ___ab___ 11y agoMost concepts posted about on HN, and for that matter, discussed by the EFF, are "little-known." The inclusion of that description in the headline is obviously intended to make the reader believe that the committee is up to no good in secret, not that most people simply don't know of it.
- pdkl95 11y agoWhy are you pretending that the EFF is writing headlines for HN? We are not the (only) intended audience. I find it very unlikely that you don't understand this.
- justratsinacoat 11y agoOh well -- the EFF knows that if they write for themselves, there'll be lower-brow comment-threads full of 'lol wtf bbq' and no one will take them seriously because they won't understand. Write accessibly, and well-read nitpickers of a HN-like brow alignment will pick apart their clickbait headlines. Damned if you do, damned if you don't.
- studentrob 11y agoAgreed. Many things in news are little known. That's often what makes it news.
- rtpg 11y agoI don't think that's what it means in this context. I bet if you ask 100 random people, not 10 would know what Stripe is. Not 10 would know what Angular is. But would you ever describe either of those as "little known"? I think in this situation it implies that even if you're in the domain you aren't aware... and on this it's not really the case right?
- tommyman 11y agoand the top of this thread is now a stupid meaningless argument about a word in the title instead of talking about the issue. Well done. Can you guys take that rubbish to reddit or voat or somewhere crappy? I like reading HN, please don't make it a waste of my time. and since I'm here now I'll throw out my opinion on the meat of the story. I use Tor a lot and am not based in the US and am nor american. If America gives itself the legal ability to hack anyone, anywhere regardless of what they are doing then all american networks/nodes/people are open to hacking and posting publicly. That includes all private people, public people, everything from correspondence to baby monitor cameras. It calls for an open season against those countries whereby we air every single persons dirty laundry in as public a way as possible. It is similar to europeans like UK, where certain people there think they can hack all people everywhere, legally, with complete immunity. Excuse my parlance but fuck everything about that. That is a system balanced way too far in one direction. but hey, that guy said 'little-known' about the Judicial Conference of the United States. That's what is important to americans... Posted without Tor because I still live in a free country and am not afraid of speak up.
- anon1385 11y agoIf the EFF was able to write posts that weren't full of gross hyperbole and flat out untruths then every comment thread about an EFF statement wouldn't require discussion about how the EFF is misleading people. They know perfectly well what they are doing. They know it leads to people talking about the stuff they exaggerated rather than the actual issue. They know that it turns away reasonable people. They are gambling that they can whip up an ignorant mob as with SOPA. The difference there was that a bunch of high profile corporations and capitalists had a financial interest in that fight and were happy to fuel the outrage machine to get their way.
- rtpg 11y agoI agree with most of the goals of the EFF, but their blog is basically one misleading description after another for these things. A comment like yours ends up being the top comment for any links to the blog. Someone might comment that the gov't does the same thing, but that's no excuse for such intellectual dishonesty.
- vcarl 11y agoAgreed, as much as I support the ideals of the EFF, this kind of misleading scare tactic really rubs me the wrong way. It feels like they're compromising the moral high ground in order to elicit a larger response--which I understand might be the straightest path to accomplishing their goals, but it feels dirty.
- guelo 11y agoI consider myself well read and politically savvy but I had never heard of this body. When was the last time they made news outside of maybe the narrow interests of federal trial lawyers?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ___ab___ 11y agoMy point is that the EFF (and whoever was drafting this press release) certainly knows what the Judicial Conference is, and are (is) willfully misrepresenting them through careful word choice.
- pdkl95 11y agoThe only misrepresentation going on is this nonsense that a headline's language should be based on the knowledge of the author instead of the intended audience.
- rayiner 11y agoJava isn't something a guy on the street would recognize, but if you were writing to a lay audience, would you describe the Oracle v. Google as involving a "little known programming language? That wouldn't be good journalism. It would give the reader an inaccurate depiction of what the lawsuit is really about. It would be good lawyering, depending on which side you are on. A classic lawyering tactic is to use the most favorable (to your side) characterization of something you can justify.
- studentrob 11y ago> It would give the reader an inaccurate depiction of what the lawsuit is really about Yeah. Part of the EFF's job is educating us. When they add such slant they lose credibility in my book. They're still great at keeping tabs on government actions that impact tech.
- 11y ago
- DanielBMarkham 11y agoOk, ok. Let's get honest here. Bloggers exaggerate. And commenters like to point that out. Sometimes I hear that commenters even like to overreact to things. Got it. Now, I've been following this issue. I did not know about this committee. I daresay I could pull 100 hackers from a room and most of them wouldn't know of it either. So for purposes of "legal people", yes, you are correct. What a overstatement! But that's not the audience here, and the headline works -- and it is not an exaggeration.
- drivingmenuts 11y agoIf you're a lawyer, this committee is probably common knowledge. I'd bet 99 out of 100 non-lawyers wouldn't have a clue about this group of people.
- nxzero 11y agoHonestly, sounds like you might have a conflict of interest in the matter, or haven't done your research. Only 36 percent of Americans can actually name the three branches of government the Constitution created.
- maxerickson 11y agoThat lack of interest is what makes the EFF framing so ridiculous. There's nothing mysterious about the committee, it's just an implementation detail of the justice system. Calling it little known implies that people who don't even know what to call the judicial branch should for some reason know about the committee.
- nxzero 11y agoSorry, I missed where the meeting notes where posted online. Or maybe it's that you mean secrets, when legally kept, are not secrets. Please explain.
- esbranson 11y ago> The Judicial Conference of the United States is neither a "little-known committee" or in any way secretive or shady, unless one is totally ignorant of how the judicial system works. The Judicial Conference is currently the subject of a lawsuit for being secretive, shady and duplicitous. (A serious lawsuit on a serious issue, with a serious chance of success.) So I think this statement is a bit subjective.
- benevol 11y agoOfficial version: "grant new hacking powers" Reality: "Make legal what has been going on illegally for years" Ok, land of the free.
- maxerickson 11y agoWhat a great headline to attach to an action signed by the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court and sent to the leaders of both houses of Congress. Recent discussion of the rule change: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11594597 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11594597 A smaller one: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11604112 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11604112
- dang 11y agoWe've taken the distracting "little-known committee" bit out of the title. Normally we'd treat this thread as a dupe of the first one you linked to, but this seems to be one of those stories the community wants to discuss thoroughly, and this thread is pretty good, so we'll leave it up.
- JustSomeNobody 11y agoDecember, huh? This being an election year we all know this won't happen.
- linux_girl 11y agoDoes rule 34 apply to rule 41?
- pappyo 11y agoEvery US politician will side on the side of security. If they don't and some awful terrorist plot happens on US soil under their watch, their political career is over. If the argument is between fear and an abstract notion of freedom, fear will always win out. The only way it changes is if the US does away with career politicians, or fear of the government becomes > fear of terrorists.
- MichaelBurge 11y agoThe rules mention that the police must notify the owners of the computers or information, so police wouldn't be secretly hacking into your computers without telling you. That actually would be pretty bad. The malware one seems entirely reasonable to me. If you have malware, chances are you're aiding criminals by providing them with hardware to commit their crimes with. Why shouldn't a judge issue a search warrant or have your computer seized? The computer is literally part of the crime scene. If you don't like it, don't install malware. The first one I'm not really sure where it would be used. Is it just, say, "police are allowed to use TOR vulnerabilities to gain access to the servers serving .onion links in the course of their investigation"? I guess their point is that the changes should've been initiated by Congress, since it's more than procedural. I can buy that, even if the changes themselves seem innocent enough.
- tomku 11y agoAs I posted on the other thread about this news, the interpretation that this gives the government "new hacking powers" is just flat-out wrong, and shame on the EFF for using it to spread FUD. The ONLY thing changed by this proposed rule is the venue in which the government can apply for warrants, expanding it to include any jurisdiction involved in the crime under those two specific circumstances that the EFF blog post mentions. It does NOT change any of the rules of probable cause involved in getting a warrant. It does NOT grant any kind of "new hacking powers". It does NOT criminalize Tor or allow law enforcement to get a warrant simply because someone used Tor. There are reasons to not like this rule change based on what it actually means. Misrepresenting things that you don't agree with ultimately hurts your own side because it makes it trivial for people on the other side to dismiss your complaints as ignorant and wrong.
- mtgx 11y agoLeaving aside the "new hacking powers" thing, I still see two problems with this: 1) the FBI can go the same friendly judge over and over again for all hacking requests. We've seen this kind of problem before like with the DEA going to the same judge tens of thousands of times for what other judges considered illegal wiretapping. So at the very least, if this passes, we'll need to somehow improve the oversight on judges much more than how it currently works. 2) it allows the FBI to hack people from outside of the country as well, even without permission from other countries to do so, which can cause all sorts of problems on its own. I believe Russia sued the FBI for doing something similar about a decade ago.
- nxzero 11y agoIf the US is able hack other countries computers, then they shouldn't complain when their computers get jacked, which then calls into question why this law is needed. In all seriousness, not a stretch to believe a war might start due to somethings like this.
- rayiner 11y agoRe: 2, the FBI already has the authority to engage in world-wide hacking from Congress. Rule 41 applies to warrants, which are Constitutionally unnecessary for foreign targets.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 11y agoEFF's misleading summary aside (EFF's gonna EFF), I have a question about the substantive issue here. Specifically: How could the FRCP work otherwise? They're in effect saying: if the evidence pertinent to a crime is online, and is either (a) on Tor or some other service where we don't know precisely where it is, or (b) on a botnet or some other environment where it's spread across 100 different jurisdictions, a judge can issue a warrant to obtain that evidence. Judges can already issue warrants to obtain electronic evidence in, I think, exactly the fashion EFF describes here. The limitation they have today is procedural: they can only issue those warrants in their own court district. But if you don't know the right court district, or a search would effectively require you to get warrants in every district, procedural rules make it hard to get a warrant today. That seems... stupid. The fact that evidence pertinent to a criminal case is on a Tor hidden service shouldn't make it inaccessible to the courts.
- brians 11y agoIt might be someplace whose laws don't recognize the authority of that court---say, Beijing. And now the US FBI has put a NIT on a non-US computer. That's a problem. It might be someplace that doesn't let governments use NITs at all. There is another way to go: warrants for the Tor exit node, then middle node, then guard. And if you can't justify those---especially hard for the middle node---that's not just a procedural issue, but a substantive problem.
- tptacek 11y agoJust so I understand you here, your position is that simply by dint of having used a Tor hidden service, you are entitled to having your information shielded from a warrant unless the court can deliver and execute warrants to the entire Tor infrastructure?
- ryanlol 11y agoThat's how these things work in the physical world, why should the internet be treated any differently?
- csoghoian 11y agoThe FBI has been using malware since at least 2003 [1], probably a few years before that. Today, the FBI has a dedicated team, the Remote Operations Unit, based out of Quantico, which does nothing but hack into the computers and mobile phones of targets. According to one former top FBI official, among the team's many technical capabilities, is the ability to remotely enable a webcam without the indicator light turning on [2]. Although DOJ has been using malware for nearly fifteen years, it never sought a formal expansion of legal authority from Congress. There has never been a Congressional hearing, nor do DOJ/FBI officials ever talk explicitly about this capability. The Rule 41 proposal before this advisory committee was the first ever opportunity for civil society groups, including my employer, the ACLU, to weigh in. We, along with several other groups, submitted comments and testified in person. Our comments can be seen here [3,4]. Incidentally, it was while doing the research for our second comment that I discovered that the FBI had impersonated the Associated Press as part of a malware operation in 2007 [5]. Ultimately, the committee voted to approve the change to the rules requested by DOJ. In doing so, the committee dismissed the criticism from the civil society groups, by saying that we misunderstood the role of the committee, that the committee was not being asked to weigh in on the legality of the use of hacking by law enforcement, and that "[m]uch of the opposition [to the proposed rule change] reflected a misunderstanding of the scope of the proposal...The proposal addresses venue; it does not itself create authority for electronic searches or alter applicable statutory or constitutional requirements." [1] http://www.nytimes.com/2016/04/14/technology/fbi-tried-to-defeat-encryption-10-years-ago-files-show.html http://www.nytimes.com/2016/04/14/technology/fbi-tried-to-de... [2] https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/technology/2013/12/06/352ba174-5397-11e3-9e2c-e1d01116fd98_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/technology/2013/12/0... [3] https://www.aclu.org/sites/default/files/assets/aclu_comments_on_rule_41.pdf https://www.aclu.org/sites/default/files/assets/aclu_comment... [4] https://www.aclu.org/files/assets/aclu_comment_on_remote_access_proposal.pdf https://www.aclu.org/files/assets/aclu_comment_on_remote_acc... [5] http://bigstory.ap.org/article/23f882720e564b918d83abb18cd5deef/fbi-argument-can-be-made-fake-ap-story-broke-rules http://bigstory.ap.org/article/23f882720e564b918d83abb18cd5d...
- tptacek 11y agoThanks for writing this comment. It's deeply informative and useful. Two things I want to call out, one minor and one more significant. The significant one first: Your employer, in the response you linked to, wrote approvingly of Orin Kerr's proposed alternative language, which would enable the same sort of remote "hacking" with the new precondition that it be allowed only when it's impossible for the courts to ascertain the right district. If ACLU is OK with that narrower language, is it safe to say that you disagree with your employer? Because your arguments strongly implicate Kerr's proposed language as well. Put simply: you appear to favor broad restrictions on DOJ's ability to coercively collect electronic evidence regardless of whether courts authorize it. The minor objection I have to your comment is the link to WaPo about the FBI being able to record video from laptop cameras without lighting the LED. That's an unsourced anonymous claim that, by my reading, can't possibly be accurate as stated, since different laptops have different mechanisms and it is vanishingly unlikely that the FBI has defeated all of them. I'm prepared to be wrong about this, but expect that I'm not, and would like to know if you can provide any more evidence backing that extraordinary WaPo claim up.
- joering2 11y agoThat;s fine, they can hack into our computers. Its not like they would plant something on your computer.. Truly the poison tree and its fruit are both dead.