3 ms·
tl;dr (I think) Dave Howells appears to run Avatron.com (looks like a one man shop?). It sells "Air Display", a screen sharing app for iOS / android. It seems
by lifeisstillgood 11y ago
tl;dr (I think)
Dave Howells appears to run Avatron.com (looks like a one man shop?). It sells "Air Display", a screen sharing app for iOS / android.
It seems he got a windfall of sales a year ago, and now has had that windfall refunded.
He had no idea where the good fortune came from, and he has again no idea where the bad fortune comes from (Aplle does not release purchaser details to the app maker)
Dave Howells assumption on Twitter is that his app was bundled with iPads for a school, that then returned everything.
His quote from the Twitter thread here is revealing :
"Basically Apple let them use my app for free for two whole school years without even asking my permission."
There are a lot of misconceptions and misunderstanding here - a few are
- the valid refund period on the App Store does seem excessive. That's nearly 18 mths
- don't get upset at not knowing where bad fortune comes from if you don't know where the good comes from too
- Apple should pass on some (anonymised?) feedback as to why the app was refunded.
- this is all made worse by it being 500 at once.
- but overall don't complain too much - Apple has built a global platform for small developers to sell onto that simply would not exist without Apple. It's incredible and also worrying but it's a ride you are along for, not a market as we know it.
- snsr 11y agoNo? The App Store terms specify that developers are on the hook for refunds for 90 days.
- zuminator 11y agoBottom line is that this could've just been a billing error from the outset that it took Apple two years to correct. Howells is making the assumption it was a school district with no evidence whatsoever. If it was Apple's policy to refund school district 3rd party app purchases regardless of time, we would be hearing this complaint constantly, not just from this one guy.
- asddubs 11y agothe problem is that apple is not giving any information whatsoever.
- hackaflocka 11y agoProblem is what if he bought a new house in the mean time based on this billing error. He could end up bankrupt because of this billing error.
- hackaflocka 11y agoProblem is what if he bought a new house in the mean time based on this billing error. He could end up bankrupt because of this billing error.
- vsl 11y ago> Howells is making the assumption it was a school district with no evidence whatsoever. You are making an assumption that he has no evidence with no evidence whatsoever. Apple provides educational discounts (if you allow it in your app’s iTC settings). He could almost certainly tell the purchase was from a school simply by dividing the reported revenue by the number of sold copies and comparing it with their regular price in the (also visible in the report) country.