7 ms·
1984 v. Brave New World
- devnonymous 11y agoFor those who found that interesting - There's an also a comic made using the foreword to ' Amusing ourselves to death ' which also contrasts the two: http://highexistence.com/amusing-ourselves-to-death-huxley-vs-orwell/ http://highexistence.com/amusing-ourselves-to-death-huxley-v... It's a pity the comic had to be removed from its original site citing copyright reasons. imho, it could have been considered as fair use. Sad.
- dsfuoi 11y agoSome of the examples on the comic page starting with: Huxley feared we would become a trivial culture, preoccupied with some equivalent of the feelies..., are not chosen well. I think the opposite of a trivial culture is a culture of self improvement, and at least four of those six examples are ostensibly doing something to improve themselves. One is a competitor in online gaming, one is debating online, the two are watching and debating current politics, one is improving his body. Those are all meaningful activities. I understand that they are not intended to be in the context of the comic, and the visual space is limited. Great comic by the way. Our society seems to be going the way of pleasure, but I don't think it will ruin us.
- nomoch 11y agoOrwell talked about this in one of his essays. The man who does not have fascism beating in his breast can't understand the pleasure of smashing someones have with a boot for all eternity. Sex, money and control have nothing to do with the pleasure of destroying others and their work.
- PavlovsCat 11y agoJust like Hitler wrote (and proved), if you just lie big enough, people will be too "polite" to even suspect it a lie, and that works in many layers. E.g. for many wars, there is the outermost facade which is usually "we have to save X from the aggression of Y". Then there is "we meant well, but made mistakes" as the next layer, then comes "we didn't really mean well, it was about geopolitics and national power", then "it's not actually about national power, but about transfer of tax payer money to the military-industrial complex which ultimately has no ties to any particular nation, at the deliberate expense of social development". And then you have the same game with the people involved in that, first there's how much they care for their children and are worried they might have to grow up without private jets, or how they're just trying to prevent a job someone would do anyway being done badly, and a whole host of other good reasons (maybe they simply operate a "business" and it "makes sense" to "make profit", no further questions). Then there's how they really just want power and fame, because we're all just apes and that's what apes want, and so on... but that they might simply be sociopath/narcissist and essentially stuck at some point in their childhood they built a shell around, that they might be merely a black hole chasing a fix they can never quite reach, now that is too much. Sure, we grant that it occurs here and there, but not as a major driving force, as the underlying pattern for a lot of things. No, of course it has to be more grandiose than that, if only because we're under the heel of and/or doing it. It boils down to this, "normal" people aren't that way, simply cannot fathom the utterly alien and barren landscape some others operate in, and would rather pile on rationalizations and faux complexity. Even you described as "pleasure" which I would assume is more a temporary relief from the pain and fear of existence someone who never got to develop a personality feels constantly, and tries to instill in others. TLDR: > "I learned that it is the weak who are cruel, and that gentleness is to be expected only from the strong." -- Leo Rosten
- uptownJimmy 11y agoOrwell was the better writer, Huxley the better prognosticator.
- justsaysmthng 11y ago"The change will be brought about as a result of a felt need for increased efficiency. " - Huxley vs today : "Work less, enjoy more!" --- Of course it is much more efficient to keep the subjects well fed and well hypnotized, rather than waste a lot of energy on keeping them subdued through violence. It is harder, but the returns are much worth it. And that's not only what the "elites" who realize (they only gain a slightly higher standard of living), but also the mythical "AI singularity" which should one day spontaneously arrive. Our fears of "the machine" which kills all humans because we are pests are unfounded - a hyper intelligent entity would quickly understand that violence is a very weak tool of control. Pleasure is much more powerful and achieves much more plus a thankful smile. It is "efficiency", "pleasure", "less work", "more fun" that we should be wary about ... but not me , I like to enjoy myself. And I welcome whatever overlord (AI, aliens) that promises more pleasure and less pain any day.
- PavlovsCat 11y agoI dislike pain because it keeps me from doing and being person things. So what use is pleasure induced/increased to such degree that it ALSO keeps me from developing as a person? I have to ask, do you see yourself as nothing more dignified than a pet or a slave? I don't mean to be rude, but you can't have your overlords without them ruling me as well, and I don't want them, at all, and you basically said you welcome "whatever" might force me and my offspring to live in what I would consider a golden cage and utter depravity. So this is a discussion, if not civil war, I'd rather have sooner than later :P And besides, why would someone or something who sees you as pet or slave feel the need to control you past the point where you are no longer a threat or useful to them? Everything that makes you happy, they could simply take from you, cutting out the middleman. Who genuinely cares about a "thankful smile" from a drone? It's a nice hypothesis, but here's mine: The pleasure stage comes before the non-existence stage, and the wide-eyed and shallow cheerleading we have now is a bit like the Nazis painting the red cross on the ad-hoc pits where they would kill people who were too weak for transport. By the time you find out what it is, it's too late. People and systems don't dissolve who you are and could have been as a person to ultimately look out for you.
- 11y ago
- redsummer 11y agoNorth Korea, Belarus and perhaps a few others are Orwell. The rest are Huxley. I've noticed that former Orwells, like East Germany and Poland, are thought to be warmer in character, have closer families, and are less atomised than the western consumerist equivalents.
- mattmaroon 11y agoBoth ended up far wrong because they overestimated government's cohesiveness. Most first world governments are far too inept to accomplish anything so difficult as either book prognosticates. We've seen nothing but a slide toward increasingly ineffective democracies since their era.
- daveguy 11y agoWe have seen a shift toward increasing corporate influence which may eventually take government anti-roles similar to a Gibson dystopia. Most of what was in both books required significant advances in biotech and automation. The advances we are seeing around crispr-cas9 and IoT may provide those tools. I am not a Luddite and I think advancement of tech is almost always beneficial (who uses that tech and how is the question). However, it may be premature to say they both ended up far wrong. They are still very important books to demonstrate the wrong ways to use technology. Edit: not that governments couldn't take the anti-roles back, but it would need a combination of increased technology and acceptance along with unfettered surveillance using that technology -- zero day Alexa bug for the NSA?
- chippy 11y agoBoth were not predictions of their immediate future, but fiction which have a message for today.
- peatmoss 11y agoI tend to find the dystopian vision of Terry Gilliam's movie Brazil the most utterly believable. In it, we have benign or benevolent actors, who are guilty of nothing more than incompetence. Evil is an emergent property of the system rather than a conscious act. People give up autonomy and privacy for retention of their bourgeois lifestyle, and mostly ignore the economic underclasses. A small number of malcontents are branded as terrorists and the government ineffectually tries to treat the symptom rather than the underlying disease.
- ricksplat 11y ago> benign or benevolent actors This was Hannah Arendt's "banality of evil" theory that she developed post WW2 when everybody was trying to figure out what happened. Evil acts are perpetrated by dumb people "just doing their job".
- vmorgulis 11y agoZamyatin is the less known precursor of Huxley and Orwell: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yevgeny_Zamyatin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yevgeny_Zamyatin
- digi_owl 11y agoI think its a bit of both. The masses being distracted and sedated in a BNW fashion, with those that step outside being hit with the 1984 treatment. The big irony being that this is not a willed construct, but a emergent phenomena.
- riprowan 11y agoI agree that the phenomena are not purely constructed, however I disagree with the idea that the phenomena are purely emergent. Maybe they are "curated emergent phenomena?"
- grifter2000 11y agopure emergence, nihilism. curated emergence, existentialism.
- Retra 11y agoAll phenomena are emergent.
- PavlovsCat 11y ago> The big irony being that this is not a willed construct, but a emergent phenomena. I'm pretty sure I saw the link to this essay on HN first, and it's still one of the more interesting ones I know. I'll quote a bit, but the whole thing is worth a read if not several: http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/07/30/meditations-on-moloch/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/07/30/meditations-on-moloch/ > There’s a passage in the Principia Discordia where Malaclypse complains to the Goddess about the evils of human society. “Everyone is hurting each other, the planet is rampant with injustices, whole societies plunder groups of their own people, mothers imprison sons, children perish while brothers war.” > The Goddess answers: “What is the matter with that, if it’s what you want to do?” > Malaclypse: “But nobody wants it! Everybody hates it!” > Goddess: “Oh. Well, then stop.” > The implicit question is – if everyone hates the current system, who perpetuates it? And Ginsberg answers: “Moloch”. It’s powerful not because it’s correct – nobody literally thinks an ancient Carthaginian demon causes everything – but because thinking of the system as an agent throws into relief the degree to which the system isn’t an agent. > Bostrom makes an offhanded reference of the possibility of a dictatorless dystopia, one that every single citizen including the leadership hates but which nevertheless endures unconquered. It’s easy enough to imagine such a state. Imagine a country with two rules: first, every person must spend eight hours a day giving themselves strong electric shocks. Second, if anyone fails to follow a rule (including this one), or speaks out against it, or fails to enforce it, all citizens must unite to kill that person. Suppose these rules were well-enough established by tradition that everyone expected them to be enforced. > So you shock yourself for eight hours a day, because you know if you don’t everyone else will kill you, because if you don’t, everyone else will kill them, and so on. Every single citizen hates the system, but for lack of a good coordination mechanism it endures. From a god’s-eye-view, we can optimize the system to “everyone agrees to stop doing this at once”, but no one within the system is able to effect the transition without great risk to themselves. > And okay, this example is kind of contrived. So let’s run through – let’s say ten – real world examples of similar multipolar traps to really hammer in how important this is.