3 ms·
> Not only is rule 41 potential overreach but it is enacted by the backdoor avoiding Congressional oversight. That's wrong. It's being enacted by the same proc
by tzs 11y ago
> Not only is rule 41 potential overreach but it is enacted by the backdoor avoiding Congressional oversight.
That's wrong. It's being enacted by the same procedure that is used for all of the rules of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure, as specified by Congress in the Rules Enabling Act, which includes Congressional oversight. After the Supreme Court approves a proposed rule change, there is a delay to allow Congress to say no if they wish.
> 5. They have copies of everything sent over the wire, so they have the contents of C at NSA H.Q. already. Just get a warrant to look at it there.
You are greatly overestimating what the NSA has. They don't have everything that goes over the internet, and much of what they do intercept is encrypted with methods that they are not known to be able to defeat.
- deepnet 11y agoI accept Congress can disavow this before December the 1st, hence the EFF's call to action - but the article does state this is a new & overreaching use of this procedure. "By law, the rules and proposals are supposed to be procedural and must not change substantive rights. But the amendment to Rule 41 isn’t procedural at all. It creates new avenues for government hacking that were never approved by Congress." > overestimating what the NSA has. The secret rooms at AT&T, like 641A that Mark Klein whistleblew in 2006, suggests they had the potential for universal domestic collection capability of everything domestic since 2003. Other Five Eyes may have similar hardwired intercepts abroad. Snowden's XKeyscore slide shows collection of 'nearly everything a user does online'[1]. Otherwise I agree that encryption exists that the NSA is not known to be able to defeat with the caveat that courts can currently order decryption and jail those in contempt. [1] http://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/jul/31/nsa-top-secret-program-online-data http://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/jul/31/nsa-top-secret-...