10 ms·
9/14/14: Sold 500 edu copies of Air Display 2. 4/25/16: All 500 refunded
- hackaflocka 11y agoAppalling.
- dantiberian 11y agoIn isolation, each of Apple's poor actions towards developers can be explained away. But in aggregate the collective paper cuts wear down a lot of the goodwill that Apple has with developers. There's a lot of hope riding on this WWDC turning stuff around, but I'm not too hopeful.
- rocky1138 11y agoI tried to convince a non-developer (and Apple lover) about this a few months ago but got nowhere. Developers are like bellwethers: if they hate you, even if you're successful now, your product/service is doomed.
- nl 11y agoOracle.
- pjmlp 11y agoI happen to be an HNer that has been on the Oracle developer list since the late 90's. I am yet to see a FOSS SQL database to match Oracle's tooling for database programming. The only ones I had similar good experience are with Microsoft and Informix (before it was acquired by IBM) databases.
- gaius 11y agoSame here. Once you get over the hump of treating it as a database and start using it as a platform, nothing can touch Oracle. But most people, even most long-term Oracle customers deeply invested in it, barely scratch the surface
- nikanj 11y agoNobody has the budget for licensing the more advanced bits. One of the tragedies of the computing world is how many great features remain locked to a really small subset of clients, because they're only available in the top-tier, more-money-than-god, if-you-have-to-ask-you-can't-afford-it edition
- infinite8s 11y agoCan you briefly describe some of that tooling?
- pjmlp 11y agoThe ones I care about: - The capabilities of PL/SQL and TransactSQL, FOSS databases don't have as feature rich programming language for stored procedures. - Ability to mix relation, object oriented and unstructured data modeling - The SQL features and extensions - Distributed transactions across multiple databases across clusters - The SQL Developer IDE or integration with Visual Studio, without relying on third parties
- Retric 11y agoMy General experence is stored procedures and even transactions scale really poorly. I have seen several ex-oracle projects and it really only seems to work well for hospitals and other organizations that don't grow. Or banks which have relativly few transactions per day. Ed: Or the old Cognos Big Data (No Users). Any thoughts?
- pjmlp 11y agoI have been involved in some telecommunications and health care projects in a couple of Fortune 500, using Informix, Oracle and SQL Server backends, which had more GB on their databases than most big data projects I see being tossed around in big data startups. Of course it is a personal experience and I cannot generalize, but on those projects we had all the scale we needed. All the issues we had, the DBAs could sort them out after checking the query optimizers and fine tune the model and respective indexes.
- pjc50 11y ago> transactions scale really poorly Please be more specific about 'scaling' numbers! > Or banks which have relativly few transactions per day. http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/newsbysector/banksandfinance/11672021/Mobile-banking-has-eclipsed-branches-and-even-the-rest-of-the-internet.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/newsbysector/banksandfina... "Banking apps were used 10.5m times a day across the country in March, eclipsing the 9.6m daily log-ins to internet banking services"
- Joeri 11y agoYou know, Oracle is not so bad for developers if you can get their attention. Basically, if you pay enough, or promise to pay enough (in a pre-sales track), you get treated well. Then again, there is PL/SQL. If any technology ever demonstrated a casual but deep hatred of the developers that must endure it, it is that one.
- santaclaus 11y agoSalesforce -- successful business, hated by every programmer who has ever touched it.
- codeulike 11y agoI don't mind it. With SF you've got to remember they've been updating and extending the same live platform for over ten years. It's amazing that it's as cohesive as it is.
- polskibus 11y agoFor all their revenue, they almost never turned a profit. They are popular but I wouldn't call it successful in business sense.
- skj 11y agoMy wife, who is a sales director, loves SalesForce. Maybe programmers aren't their target market?
- warfangle 11y agoNope, but they are required if you want to do anything on it that's custom. And Apex as a platform is a nightmare to work with.
- dclowd9901 11y agoI can attribute this one to developers having to interact with sales force on behalf of their bosses. Hard to refuse usin a technology if your boss tells you you need to support it.
- bendbro 11y agoWhat are the rumors? I'd consider myself anti-apple, but it still saddens me that they aren't doing cool stuff anymore.
- CydeWeys 11y agoDoes Apple have goodwill with developers? I can't think of the last time that would have been the case.
- aftbit 11y agoHow is this legal? Surely after more than a full fiscal year, nobody could reasonably expect a refund? Although I suppose some consumer protection laws require many-year warranties. Is that comparable?
- snsr 11y agoIt's also against the t&c included in the Apple developer agreement. https://pbs.twimg.com/media/ChWM2h8W4AEKiBT.jpg:large https://pbs.twimg.com/media/ChWM2h8W4AEKiBT.jpg:large
- pjc50 11y agoI'd suggest legal action, but unless a system like the UK small claims court is available this would probably cost more than could be recovered.
- klagermkii 11y agoWouldn't taking Apple to small claims court be a very fast way to get you booted out the App Store entirely? I don't think those 500 copies would ever be worth that.
- thedz 11y agoIs there a refund time limit in the store ToS? A year and a half or so seems excessively long for anything, let alone hardware.
- mathrawka 11y ago90 Days https://pbs.twimg.com/media/ChWM2h8W4AEKiBT.jpg https://pbs.twimg.com/media/ChWM2h8W4AEKiBT.jpg
- chrisbennet 11y ago"Well sharecropper, if you don't like working my land, go to somewhere else."
- wtbob 11y agoActually, it's worse: sharecroppers really good go plant cotton somewhere else. But if you want to write iOS apps, you have the deal with Apple.
- jakobegger 11y agoIt's long overdue that Apple allows installing software without their approval on iOS devices. It's appalling that there is no alternative to the App Store. The imbalance of power between developers and Apple is unacceptable. It doesn't look like Apple will change without outside pressure; the time is now ready for government regulation. I really hope that the EU takes on this problem, and forces Apple to allow competing stores, just like they required Microsoft to let users choose alternative browsers.
- digi_owl 11y agoNot likely to happen, as unlike Microsoft, Apple makes and sell the whole widget.
- zamalek 11y agoI'm still genuinely confused as to why Apple hasn't been slammed with antitrust on multiple fronts. You can ignore the whole App Store fiasco and still come up with several other anti-competitive and anti-consumer practices: as a paying Winamp customer, I can't access the iPhone. This isn't a silly little issue like a browser and they get away with it consistently.
- MichaelBurge 11y agoUnlike the old railroad companies that needed huge capital investments to set up national railroad networks, anyone with a couple million could cobble together a PoC of some phones. So being the biggest phone seller doesn't turn them into some untouchably large company. There's a ton of companies trying to release their own phones; even Ubuntu has their own line[1]. The only industry in all of computing where antitrust seems to me to be directly applicable to a business - only considering itself - is owning and running fabrication plants. I think they cost something like $1 billion to set up. Maybe Comcast or AT&T or similar could also count with their expensive communications infrastructure, and if we didn't otherwise have regulation for those industries. Of course, Apple colluding with Google to fix the store cut would also count, as would many other similar examples. But those involve multiple companies conspiring together, not a single one like you've mentioned. [1] http://www.ubuntu.com/phone/devices http://www.ubuntu.com/phone/devices
- kayoone 11y agoIt's ridiculous to be a slave of Apples good will for years without knowing when and how much revenue they might just take away from you again without even giving a reason. What if you invested it elsewhere a long time ago and your business is not doing that well anymore ?
- gambiting 11y agoI don't really see how different it is from a normal retailer situation. If you have a small store, sell someone a fridge, then 6 months later go under, and the fridge breaks down and can't be repaired in 11 months, the customer is still within the rights to ask you for a full refund(at least in the EU). It doesn't matter if you are doing well or not - as a business, you should plan for these situations. The problem here is, that I don't think Apple says anywhere that they can issue refunds for your products 18(!!!!) months after purchase! normal refund time is 90 days.
- kayoone 11y agoyeah the problem is not the existence of refunds, the problem is the timeframe which is highly unreasonable for a $10 application. 3-6 months okay, but almost 2 years ?
- DiabloD3 11y agoThis is absolutely appalling. Apple cannot possibly think they are in the right here, especially due to their own ToS. It seems this dude lives in the US, doesn't he have a legal case against Apple for theft?
- carlesfe 11y agoThis is crazy. I'm not in the App Store, how does this kind of refund even work? Surely the money had already been transferred to the developer's bank account. Does Apple bill the developer for the value of the refund? Charge their credit card? Do they withhold future sales for that value?
- vacri 11y agoFrom the follow-up comments, it sounds like it was simply deducted from his current month sales revenue. Actually, I imagine this is just an oversight, and he's been caught in-between some automated cracks. If he raises the issue with Apple and it isn't resolved immediately, then it's time to grumble.
- jbmorgado 11y ago"If he raises the issue with Apple and it isn't resolved immediately, then it's time to grumble." Like the developer says in his own Tweets: for that, there would have to be an open channel between developers and Apple. There isn't, developers don't get to discuss with the Apple App Store representatives, it's a one way dialog in which they receive some automated or if they are lucky, semi-automated response from the App Store and that's it.
- supercoder 11y agoGenerally any reasonably sized developer has an Apple assigned dev relation contact.
- lifeisstillgood 11y agotl;dr (I think) Dave Howells appears to run Avatron.com (looks like a one man shop?). It sells "Air Display", a screen sharing app for iOS / android. It seems he got a windfall of sales a year ago, and now has had that windfall refunded. He had no idea where the good fortune came from, and he has again no idea where the bad fortune comes from (Aplle does not release purchaser details to the app maker) Dave Howells assumption on Twitter is that his app was bundled with iPads for a school, that then returned everything. His quote from the Twitter thread here is revealing : "Basically Apple let them use my app for free for two whole school years without even asking my permission." There are a lot of misconceptions and misunderstanding here - a few are - the valid refund period on the App Store does seem excessive. That's nearly 18 mths - don't get upset at not knowing where bad fortune comes from if you don't know where the good comes from too - Apple should pass on some (anonymised?) feedback as to why the app was refunded. - this is all made worse by it being 500 at once. - but overall don't complain too much - Apple has built a global platform for small developers to sell onto that simply would not exist without Apple. It's incredible and also worrying but it's a ride you are along for, not a market as we know it.
- snsr 11y agoNo? The App Store terms specify that developers are on the hook for refunds for 90 days.
- zuminator 11y agoBottom line is that this could've just been a billing error from the outset that it took Apple two years to correct. Howells is making the assumption it was a school district with no evidence whatsoever. If it was Apple's policy to refund school district 3rd party app purchases regardless of time, we would be hearing this complaint constantly, not just from this one guy.
- asddubs 11y agothe problem is that apple is not giving any information whatsoever.
- hackaflocka 11y ago
- buro9 11y agoThe headline took so long to parse. Middle-endian dates remain very confusing to everyone outside the USA.
- wutbrodo 11y agoIs this really that difficult? I was born and raised in the US but have been traveling around the world for almost the last year and it gets easy REALLY fast to switch between them, especially when one of the interpretations is clearly incompatible (like in this case where there's no 14th month). I've had probably more than a 100 lodging and train and flight bookings and I've yet to find it confusing. Though I do think that it's stupid that we use middle endian dates. My habit has become to just put the unambiguous fullyear-month-day.
- falcolas 11y agoI imagine it's due to the lack of context. If you see the date 11/2/12, what date is it? If I'm in America, I assume that it's M/D/Y, making it November 2, 2012. If I'm not in America, then I assume it's D/M/Y, making it February 11, 2012. But if I'm on the internet, I have no fricking clue. I agree on the unambiguous version - as a side effect, it sorts very nicely.
- Piskvorrr 11y agoAnd if you're the genius somewhere in the neighboring thread using YY/MM/DD, it's February 12, 2011. Heuristically, "if it has slashes, it's USian mm/dd/yy, if it has dots, it's European dd.mm.yy, if it has dashes, it's ISOish yy-mm-dd, YMMV."
- stordoff 11y agoI can switch between them without issue, but (especially online) you don't always have the context needed to decide which to use. If I come across, say, "01/05/2016", unless I know the country of origin for the site, I have no idea if that is 2016 May 1 or 2016 Jan 5.
- kyriakos 11y ago
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- cm3 11y agoTo be clear, he knows exactly that it's those 500 sold on 9/14/14, right?
- grapehut 11y agoInterestingly, the software is not very highly regarded: https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/air-display-2/id705578162?mt=8 https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/air-display-2/id705578162?mt... https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.avatron.airdisplay2&hl=en https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.avatron.ai... I wonder if apple decided to make a special case, and do a blanket refund?
- raverbashing 11y agoWhich is totally fair, if the refund is done on the allotted time (90 days)
- charlesdm 11y agoIt might have been amazing / done well two years ago. Two years is an aweful long time in App Store land.
- LorenPechtel 11y agoA thought here--suppose the original 500 sales turned out to somehow be a fraudulent transaction. In that case Apple would undo it no matter how long it had been.
- hellofunk 11y agoI'd argue this is why you should distribute your app on the App Store, but don't rely on Apple to handle the payments. Make your app free, with a payment to your site directly, where you then provide an activation code or password, etc, to run the free iOS app. One additional perk is that you don't give Apple 30% when you do this. For the App Store to approve your app, you provide a test username/password or authentication code in the notes to the reviewer. After the app is approved, you can then deactivate that test account. This requires more development overhead from the developer, certainly. But the extra 30% you get in revenue and the comfort of being solely in control of your payment process can be worth it. There are a few apps that do this, but not many.
- shalmanese 11y agoThis is also prohibited by the app store TOS.
- hellofunk 11y agoThe terms of service prevent you from soliciting payment via an outside source within your app. But I don't think there's anything against what I described, so long as you don't link to your site for payment. Is this not the case?
- grapehut 11y agoIf you're big enough that the 30% makes a difference, you're not going to want to risk having your app banned by flagrantly violating the ToS. And even if you ignore that, the extra friction you're going to cause users is going to dwarf that 30% fee. I've literally spent hundreds of dollars on apps, and generally don't mind forking out $3 or $4 for something I think might be useful. However the probability of me giving some app that's violating the app-store policies my credit-card details is pretty close to zero. I might consider paypal (which I don't even have the details of on my phone), but if there's any equivalent app, I sure as hell will just buy it through the app store.