5 ms·

care to make a more detailed comparison between this and org mode ?

tines 10y ago
I too would like to hear about how org-mode is an effective task manager. On its face, it seems like grandparent is saying "This doesn't compare with the power of Markdown for managing to-dos." One is a tool, the other is a formatting language.
- Jtsummers 10y ago
  Org mode is a tool. It's got a formatting language in it, but it provides calendar, schedule, time tracking, workflow management, and more.
- hsitz 10y ago
  If you're implying that TaskWarrior is a tool and that org-mode is a formatting language (or file format), then you're way off to begin with. Org-mode does have a specific format for its files. But much of its power derives from the tools it incorporates. E.g., the org-mode Agenda functionality enables complex searches over multiple files and collects and orders the results in a single buffer, and allows users to perform operations on the results (i.e., on the original buffers containing the results) directly from the Agenda buffer. There's much, much, more. Org-mode is primarily a tool, not a file format. If you want an overview of some of its functionality, you can take a look here: http://doc.norang.ca/org-mode.html http://doc.norang.ca/org-mode.html
- maaku 10y ago
  Org-mode has embraced the emacs philosophy with respect to workflow management. It is a document formatting language which has been co-opted into doing pretty much all aspects of workflow management -- tasks, reminders, calendars, etc. I personally don't think it does a very good job, but some people swear by it.
  - ProfDreamer 10y ago
    > I personally don't think it does a very good job [...] Why do you think so? Would you care to elaborate?
    - timroy 10y ago
      I posted above why I like Org-Mode. Here are a few things it doesn't do well. 1. Because it is text-based, its visual summaries are limited. Like, there's a calendar, and for org-habits a simple color-coded chart to show consistency, but that's about it. If you're looking a week or a month ahead to visually see how many tasks you have coming up, the org-agenda is text-based. 2. While org-mode can sync with Trello, Beeminder, and a couple other task-management systems, its integrations are pretty limited. If you want to integrate with Contacts or whatever you'll have to work a bit. 3. org-mode's part of Emacs, so you'll need to be comfortable with Emacs. Contrast this with Sunrise Calendar. Sunrise Calendar grabs gmail messages and appointments, iCal, google calendar, and displays them all nicely. Pluses and minuses, depends on your needs and what you like.
ywecur 10y ago
I'm not the most familiar with either, but one of the simplest differences is that org-mode allows you to have entries longer than single lines and have it formatted. This is immensely more helpful when implementing GTD IMO. Org-mode can also easily become your calendar as well, which Taskwarrior cannot.
- nextos 10y ago
  The only thing I miss in org-mode is a more powerful domain-specific language for events. Like remind, which is a very nice Unix GPLed utility: https://www.roaringpenguin.com/products/remind https://www.roaringpenguin.com/products/remind
- tingol 10y ago
  Why not? Taskwarrior has time scheduling, due dates and a calendar.
  - zeckalpha 10y ago
    Not at a level lower than a day.

tines 10y ago

I too would like to hear about how org-mode is an effective task manager. On its face, it seems like grandparent is saying "This doesn't compare with the power of Markdown for managing to-dos." One is a tool, the other is a formatting language.

Jtsummers 10y ago
Org mode is a tool. It's got a formatting language in it, but it provides calendar, schedule, time tracking, workflow management, and more.
hsitz 10y ago
If you're implying that TaskWarrior is a tool and that org-mode is a formatting language (or file format), then you're way off to begin with. Org-mode does have a specific format for its files. But much of its power derives from the tools it incorporates. E.g., the org-mode Agenda functionality enables complex searches over multiple files and collects and orders the results in a single buffer, and allows users to perform operations on the results (i.e., on the original buffers containing the results) directly from the Agenda buffer. There's much, much, more. Org-mode is primarily a tool, not a file format. If you want an overview of some of its functionality, you can take a look here: http://doc.norang.ca/org-mode.html http://doc.norang.ca/org-mode.html
maaku 10y ago
Org-mode has embraced the emacs philosophy with respect to workflow management. It is a document formatting language which has been co-opted into doing pretty much all aspects of workflow management -- tasks, reminders, calendars, etc. I personally don't think it does a very good job, but some people swear by it.
- ProfDreamer 10y ago
  > I personally don't think it does a very good job [...] Why do you think so? Would you care to elaborate?
  - timroy 10y ago
    I posted above why I like Org-Mode. Here are a few things it doesn't do well. 1. Because it is text-based, its visual summaries are limited. Like, there's a calendar, and for org-habits a simple color-coded chart to show consistency, but that's about it. If you're looking a week or a month ahead to visually see how many tasks you have coming up, the org-agenda is text-based. 2. While org-mode can sync with Trello, Beeminder, and a couple other task-management systems, its integrations are pretty limited. If you want to integrate with Contacts or whatever you'll have to work a bit. 3. org-mode's part of Emacs, so you'll need to be comfortable with Emacs. Contrast this with Sunrise Calendar. Sunrise Calendar grabs gmail messages and appointments, iCal, google calendar, and displays them all nicely. Pluses and minuses, depends on your needs and what you like.

ywecur 10y ago

I'm not the most familiar with either, but one of the simplest differences is that org-mode allows you to have entries longer than single lines and have it formatted. This is immensely more helpful when implementing GTD IMO. Org-mode can also easily become your calendar as well, which Taskwarrior cannot.

nextos 10y ago
The only thing I miss in org-mode is a more powerful domain-specific language for events. Like remind, which is a very nice Unix GPLed utility: https://www.roaringpenguin.com/products/remind https://www.roaringpenguin.com/products/remind
tingol 10y ago
Why not? Taskwarrior has time scheduling, due dates and a calendar.
- zeckalpha 10y ago
  Not at a level lower than a day.