7 ms·
This Is Your Brain on Podcasts
- mapleoin 11y agoThis is what I got from this article: Researchers looked at MRI scans of people listening to a Podcast on their daily commute. The researchers don't know what any of it means.
- revelation 11y agoFunctional MRI scans are the equivalent of looking at what transistors are switching in a chip at any given moment, only more useless since the brain is much more generalized. "Oh! Cache is lighting up!"
- Balgair 11y agohttp://www.wired.com/2009/09/fmrisalmon/ http://www.wired.com/2009/09/fmrisalmon/ It's from 2009, so things have improved, but still.
- ddt_Osprey 11y agoYou know what? I bet the differentiation in the exposure to light (via different pictures), combined with ever-so-slightly-still-electrolytically-active neuro-pathways, produced those results. Dead salmon, though they may be, light-sensitive organs the eyes still are. And provided that the salmon were probably preserved on ice, much of the carcasses probably remained fairly chemically stable, so while the electron pumps in the electron transport chains of the multi-polar neurons were deactivated, I bet the whole pipeline from salmon's visual cortex to its eyeball probably was still slightly capable of transmitting photo-sensitivity. Then, it probably came down to the fMRI imaging software being so fine-tuned as to notice that differentiation, and amplify it into statistical significance!
- Balgair 11y agoIf that is true, then fMRI studies of V1 in humans are totally screwed. You show them anything, and the unconscious effects overwhelm the stats software and you get 'hits'. As the article goes into, you better be damn careful with your controls and your p values if you want to actually do anything useful in fMRI. If you want to just publish papers, it seems like a great field, but there seems to be better ways to just make a paycheck.
- wimagguc 11y agoThe paper this article references has not much to do with listening to podcasts while commuting. It's about how "the meaning of language is represented in regions [of the brain]". Wonder if the post would have received the same attention with the more precise title "This is your brain on stories".
- johnchristopher 11y agoI certainly would like to read an article on "This is your brain on stories" that would highlights and explores escapism, role of story-telling, etc. That would make a nice book as well. I recently got into listening to podcasts. I noticed that I really don't like the "get together to discuss a topic" kind or the "here's a 2 minutes segment from the radio news" but really do enjoy one-hour long political, history and documentary podcasts.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- civilian 11y agoJust wanna make sure you have these in your feed: Revolutions Podcast, History of Rome podcast (finished, but with 5 years of content), Dan Carlin's Hardcore History. Idk, the "get together and discuss" podcasts vary widely in quality. I find that the way the hosts talk really determines whether I like it. I really enjoy My Brother My Brother and Me (A comedy podcast around answering YahooAnswers questions), and listening to Boars, Gore and Swords helps me solidify and digest what I watched in Game of Thrones. But some of the discussions podcasts are just babbly. "One bad mother", "Throwing shade". There's very little content. Even RadioLab does me wrong sometimes, but that's probably just because I have a basic science education and Robert Krulwich is an idiot. Radiolab suffers from the balance fallacy, argument to moderation, and false dilemma.
- agumonkey 11y agoPodcasts are my tool of choice for bike riding smooth cardio sessions. They drive my mind off the effort, it makes my rhythm more regular and the experience more pleasurable. Sometimes I'm even thinking "hard" while pedaling.
- travelbyphone 11y agoI do the same when running. Much better than music
- ecuzzillo 11y agoLink to paper full text?
- slashcom 11y agohttp://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v532/n7600/full/nature17637.html http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v532/n7600/full/nature1...
- hgh 11y agoArticle itself is pretty light on the details, but good opportunity to ask the HN community -- which podcasts really fire your neurons?
- bognition 11y agoI used to listen to the "classics": - This American Life - 99% Invisible - Serial - Invisibilia (sp?) - TED Radio Hour - Radio Lab But after a few years they all feel very boring.
- Aleman360 11y agoAgreed, they're all same-ish now.
- icebraining 11y agoI feel a bit of that from 99%, but not from TAL and Serial. Though I'm still mourning the loss of David Rakoff.
- SyneRyder 11y agoI'm feeling that about 99% Invisible too. I like the show, but the several minutes of ads and cross-promotion for every Radiotopia production & challenge coins & "beautiful nerds" is getting really grating. And putting random episodes of other podcasts into the feed or as an extra 15 minutes at the end of episodes is really annoying. I still listen to it, but it's on my shortlist of podcasts I may unsubscribe from in 2016.
- icebraining 11y agoHeh, except for the challenge coins, I don't really mind any of that; just that it got somewhat repetitive. I'd rather they'd cut the episode length and maybe only released bi-weekly.
- j_s 11y agoThis discussion 2 weeks ago was filled with recommendations: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11509835 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11509835
- Amorymeltzer 11y agoAmusingly, I heard about this research on the Nature podcast. I was skeptical at first — these fMRI studies are a dime a dozen these days, with dubious results — but this one is pretty robust. The use of training data is nice, and definitely adds a level of verifiablility to it. It's a nice step toward actually understanding how the brain processes not just language but ideas. There is definitely a future where we can understand what people are thinking by observing their brain.
- svensken 11y agoIsn't it just the bloodflow within the brain that we're observing? We'll never be able to read a mind based on fMRI-style data any more than we'll be able to judge the ongoings of America by the headlights on the highways.
- Dowwie 11y agoEconTalk The RSA events London School of Economics events CATO Institute Events Commonwealth Club of California Big Ideas produced by Australian Broadcasting Corp Stanford Entrepreneurship Series Inquiring Minds BBC Thinking Allowed Science Friday Both US and UK Intelligence squared debates Edge.org talks are great, too, but I don't think they're offered as podcasts yet. Minor inconvenience.. For stories, there's Radiolab, Freakonomics, Snap Judgment, and The Moth
- towlejunior 11y agoC++ podcasts, anyone? A niche request, yes, but my podcast app's search won't respect the plus characters. :(
- lexap 11y agoIncredible that they were able to predict areas of the brain that would light up.