4 ms·
So what are you gonna do? Move to another CAD package? Take a look at the reasonably large number of CAD packages listed on Wikioedua here: https://en.m.wikipe
by chris_wot 11y ago
So what are you gonna do? Move to another CAD package? Take a look at the reasonably large number of CAD packages listed on Wikioedua here:
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_computer-aided_design_editors https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_computer-aided...
Virtually all of them are proprietary. They are too expensive to move away from, and every one of them has flaws that firms workaround and build there workflows on. Retraining, proprietary file formats and the disruption of migrating an essential part of most businesses is prohibitive.
Frankly, IMO the CAD marketplace is an example of how closed source really bites an industry. Funnily enough, most engineers - who would never accept inaccurate tolerances on items like screws or bolts - seem to accept this is the way it is and despite the stories we read here let the situation continue.
I'm frankly amazed there aren't more failures in infrastructure from bugs in CAD software. That's more a testament to the fact that engineers are engineers though - when they realise there are problems, they dig in, figure out where the problem is and find a solution, and in the case of CAD software I really think they build or design their way around the problems.
Overall, CAD software is, despite all the flaws of being coded source, still pretty amazing and vendors do fix issues eventually. We can do so many more things in society because of it, but as we evolve as a society it becomes apparent there are limitations. Eventually CAD software vendors will be disrupted, but we're a long way from that point right now!
- rtpg 11y agoI mean sure, things have bugs, right? I get that. Sometimes autocorrect messes up things I type. It's not really a bug per-se, more just a side-effect of how things like autocorrect work, right? But sometimes Chrome crashes, and that's a bug... The OP seems to say that the bend radius thing is more of the first case than the second, and I'm wondering how true that is. I'm not really sure of the science behind it (maybe it's an impossible constraints problem).
- chris_wot 11y agoOh, no doubt. The issue is that the tools don't appear to document their limitations and constraints, and there is often no way of knowing until you get bitten. At least with OSS you can look at the code behind the program to work out how it calculates things like the bend radius. I'm no engineer, so I had to look it up (Wikipedia was no help whatsoever on this occasion) but I located this page which gives the formula and an explanation: "Calculating the correct flat pattern layout is crucial to getting a good quality finished part from your press brake. Yet, many CAD and CNC programmers have no idea how to calculate the required values. Years ago, the real experts created cheat sheets and tacked them to the wall. They only taught the new apprentice how to apply the results shown on the cheat sheet, not how to calculate the numbers. Well, now those experts have retired and it's time for a new generation to learn the right way to do the calculate the correct flat pattern layout." http://www.sheetmetalguy.com/bend-allowance.htm http://www.sheetmetalguy.com/bend-allowance.htm Now admittedly the guy does put the responsibility on the operator, but it appears CAD packages can indeed calculate this for you. So long as the right info was input into the program, the formula should be programmed correctly and the operator should be able to have confidence in the results!
- sammcf 11y ago>Now admittedly the guy does put the responsibility on the operator, but it appears CAD packages can indeed calculate this for you. So long as the right info was input into the program, the formula should be programmed correctly and the operator should be able to have confidence in the results! "Should" is the operative term. I can tell you with that having hand checked the automated results of several CAD packages at developing sheet metal flat patterns and finding unexplained variability and errors too many times to count that if you want confidence in the dimensional accuracy of a sheet metal part, you need to develop it by hand. Especially for anything over 5mm in sheet thickness. As far as I'm concerned you really can't engage in sheet metal design without being able to manually verify the development results, so in a sense it is up to the designer regardless of the capabilities of the CAD software. To be fair, I'm picking on one of the hardest physical manufacturing processes to actually get right - even CNC brake presses have a great amount of variance in calibration (e.g. the amount of bend allowance you need to make for various sheet thicknesses...) across different suppliers, materials, etc to produce physically identical parts. The valuable lesson for a fresh designer is don't trust your 3d representation of the part, don't trust the manufacturer specs on ANYTHING and always prototype. I'm guessing this is why people tolerate it - the world with 3d CAD is still a vastly nicer place to be an engineer than otherwise, so we just rationalise away the shitty parts as a reasonable price to pay.
- chris_wot 11y agoI'm guessing this is why people tolerate it - the world with 3d CAD is still a vastly nicer place to be an engineer than otherwise, so we just rationalise away the shitty parts as a reasonable price to pay. Yeah, I know. In my experience, engineers are normally immensely pragmatic people. My dad was an engineer, so I have a lot of respect for the profession. It would just be nice if CAD would be more open.
- Niksko 11y ago> Eventually CAD software vendors will be disrupted, but we're a long way from that point right now! Not so sure we're that far off. Nobody really has much incentive to innovate in this space because it's so niche. If you're a believer in the version of the future where 3D printers are as commonplace as 2D printers are today, then this may all change. Suddenly, 3D modelling skills are today's word processing skills (either for work or for fun), and there are a whole bunch of people working on coming up with innovative CAD solutions for the masses.
- Pamar 11y agoYour analogy would work better if wordprocessor vendors had been disrupted by open source alternatives that took the world by storm.
- CompelTechnic 11y agoI would argue that SolidWorks has been doing a good bit of innovation. The fact that its been stealing more and more market share over time speaks to it.
- auxym 11y agoEach new version of SW introduces new "features" (some genuinely useful, some shiny marketing gimmicks) and a host of new bugs. Software churn at it's best. Gotta release a new version to make money, just fixing bugs isn't profitable. Oh, and make sure file formats are not backwards compatible, even if for no good reason but to force upgrades.
- vlehto 11y ago>Nobody really has much incentive to innovate in this space because it's so niche. http://www.pwc.com/gx/en/industries/technology/publications/global-software-100-leaders/compare-results.html http://www.pwc.com/gx/en/industries/technology/publications/... Siemens makes CAD packages. Dassault too. Autodesk does nothing but CAD packages. All in the top 20 of "software companies by revenue". PTC is number 42 and Bentley is 70 again CAD packages. It might be a niche, but it's pretty expensive niche then. Pure CAD companies Autodesk, PTC and Bentley made 2,5 billion dollars of revenue in 2014.
- rjsw 11y agoThere is a common file file format for CAD as well as other areas of engineering [1], most proprietary CAD tools support it. I am the editor of a small part of it. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ISO_10303 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ISO_10303
- colomon 11y agoThat said, in the real world there are plenty of people who don't want to use it, for whatever reason. I've got customers who insist that they'd rather use a not-yet-written reverse-engineered Parasolid X_T exporter than a well-tested STEP exporter that's been around a decade.
- rjsw 11y agoWe also get people coming along every few years who argue that because there are some people not using STEP we should start again from scratch. They are very enthusiastic for a while until they realize how much work is involved and they give up, having wasted a fair bit of time in standards meetings. I think there is scope for some disruption from small companies willing to use STEP as the internal data model for their software but just working on small parts of the picture.