3 ms·
In traditional tumbling, let's say you have ten people who all want to intermingle their funds. So you have ten inputs and ten outputs, and now there's some pl
by CydeWeys 11y ago
In traditional tumbling, let's say you have ten people who all want to intermingle their funds. So you have ten inputs and ten outputs, and now there's some plausible deniability added because you don't know which particular one of the ten any given output corresponds to. But you do know it belongs to one of the ten, which is still significant information. And, most importantly, the vast majority of Bitcoiners do not use tumbling services.
With mining, however, you are intermingling with the activities of an entire mining pool. It is WAAAY harder to trace. Let's say I want to launder 1,000 BTC, and I have a sympathetic mining pool that will launder it for me. So I sign a 1,000 BTC transaction that gives it all away as a transaction fee, and they include it in their next mined block, eating the full bonus.
Then, separately, either before or after, and possibly far separated in time chronologically, they issue a series of transactions to a set of separate virgin receiving addresses I have created that total up to, say, 999 BTC (they keep 1 BTC as their mixing fee). As a key point, these transactions do NOT spend the output of the 1,000 BTC reward block, but rather, block generation rewards from previous blocks they've mined. They are indistinguishable from standard mining reward payouts, which any pool goes through a huge number of every day.
Those 999 BTC I now have spread across my addresses are way more anonymized than anything I could get with a traditional mixing pool.
- joshuak 11y agoThis does not serve as a tumbling mechanism because the participants aren't peers. The coins went all one direction from source to many destinations. If those many destinations don't, in turn, pay the source back in some way you've just lost the money not laundered it.
- CydeWeys 11y agoI don't understand your objection. The mechanism I explained works to launder and obscure the auditable trail of Bitcoin. All I figure is that you're pointing out some there is some risk inherent in the mining pool simply walking away with the money. OK, sure. There's lots of trust involved in the Bitcoin ecosystem. Every time I buy something on the Internet with Bitcoin I'm trusting the retailer to send me what I ordered rather than walking away with my money. Every time I transfer BTC to an exchange in order to sell it I'm similarly trusting that they won't instead simply screw me over.
- mnx 11y agoWhich... they historically are not that unlikely to do.
- CydeWeys 11y agoWell you are laundering money (which is likely illegal depending on your reason for doing so), so it'd be unreasonable not to expect there to be some risk. You're just trading off risk from government for risk from mining pool. But if you do the laundering over a series of transactions spread out in time, you are limiting your potential losses. Say you do it in fifty blocks over a week -- if the miner betrays you your maximum loss is 2%. If you don't tell the miner how much you're laundering through them (they'll just know when you are finished), and you give them an acceptable cut (say, 3%), it would be in their vested interest not to betray you because the expected value of more laundering from you is greater than what they could make by eating any one given attempt. Also, if they are doing laundering as a service, then trust in them is very important, and screwing over one customer at the cost of potentially losing all future customers is not worth it. For instance, let's say I'm selling $5K of Bitcoin. I'm not worried too much that any given exchange is going to screw me over and eat it, because the big exchanges are doing many millions of dollars in business a day, and stand to lose a lot more from a hit to their reputation from stealing from me than they do to gain from eating my money. The only worry is if an entire exchange goes down (a la MtGox), but you can minimize that risk by not keeping money in an exchange.
- joshuak 11y agoNo, you're not describing something like A (typical tumbling) is risky, and B (paid back by miners) is better but with somewhat more risk. A is I give you a million dollars, you give me the deed on your house. There is risk, there is trust involved, but we both are peers and bare equivalent risk. B is I give a small portion of a million dollars to hundreds or thousands of people and ask that they pay a new account some large portion of it. B is 100% risk. It is in fact guaranteed not to work in the aggregate. The problem is that none of the individual miners have a stake, as I said they are not peers. In fact it's worse then that, they would incur unnecessary risk of their own to payback the money rather than just keep it because of the danger of being implicated in a money laundering scheme. With tumbling every participant shares risk equally since every participant puts funds into the system. In your scenario weather it's 10 miners or 10000 miners NONE of them are putting up any money at the same time, AND you must trust every single individual. It simply doesn't work. It is not a lauding scheme of any kind.